Mechanism, measurement, and quantification of stress in decision process: a model based systematic-review protocol

Chang Su, Xiaoyuan Li, Lin Yang, Yong ZengarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

The relationship between stress and decision-making is a critical area of study, particularly in high-stakes environments like aviation, emergency response, and medicine. However, the field currently suffers from "conceptual mush"—a lack of clear distinction between terms such as "mental stress," "cognitive workload," and "mental effort." This paper presents a protocol for a systematic review designed to standardize these definitions and identify the most effective methods for quantifying stress within the decision-making process.

Theoretical Framework: The Stress-Effort Model

Central to this protocol is the transition from the classic Yerkes-Dodson "inverted-U" performance curve to a more nuanced stress-effort model. In this framework, mental effort is viewed as a resource deployed to meet the demands of a stressor. As stress increases, effort initially rises to maintain performance until it reaches a peak threshold. Beyond this point, effort declines as the cognitive system becomes overwhelmed, leading to a drop in decision quality.

Figure 1: The stress-effort model illustrating the relationship between stress and mental effort.

The General Decision Mechanism

The authors propose a General Decision Mechanism to map how stressors translate into behavioral and physiological outputs. This model breaks the decision process into four distinct stages:

  1. Perception and Engagement: Initial detection and focus on the stressor.
  2. Understanding: Processing the nature and context of the challenge.
  3. Analysis: Evaluating potential responses and outcomes.
  4. Decision Making: Selecting and executing the final action.
Figure 2: The proposed General Decision Mechanism framework, showing the flow from stressor input to behavioral and physiological output.

Under extreme stress, the model accounts for "automatic" decision-making, where the understanding and analysis phases are bypassed in favor of rapid, reflexive responses. Crucially, the model incorporates recursive feedback, where the resulting stress and workload from one stage become inputs that influence the next stage of the process.

Methodology and Physiological Mapping

The planned systematic review follows PRISMA-P guidelines and will analyze literature from 1990 to 2020 across major databases like Web of Science and PubMed. The focus is strictly on acute stress in healthy adults to ensure a clear baseline for quantification. The protocol aims to map specific physiological measures to biological systems to provide objective data points:

  • Autonomic Nervous System (ANS): Monitoring heart rate, heart rate variability (HRV), and skin conductance to track immediate sympathetic responses.
  • HPA Axis: Measuring cortisol levels as a marker of the endocrine system's response to stressors.
  • Brain Networks: Utilizing Electroencephalography (EEG) to observe activation patterns during the decision-making process.

Quantification and Future Applications

A key goal of the review is to evaluate mathematical models of stress. The authors highlight a specific formula where stress ($\sigma$) is a function of perceived workload ($w_p$), knowledge ($k$), skills ($S$), and affect ($\alpha$):

$$\sigma = \frac{w_p}{(k+S)*\alpha}$$

By standardizing these metrics, the authors hope to provide a solid foundation for ergonomics and human-computer interaction (HCI). Understanding the precise "breaking point" of a decision-maker allows for the design of better training protocols and more resilient interfaces in critical infrastructure where human error can have catastrophic consequences.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{su2022mechanism,
  author = {Chang Su and Xiaoyuan Li and Lin Yang and Yong Zeng},
  title = {{Mechanism, measurement, and quantification of stress in decision process: a model based systematic-review protocol}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2203.10397},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.10397},
}
Figure