Mechanism and risk identification of rockburst in negative coal pillar roadway induced by dynamic load disturbance

Yan Cai, S. Zhu, Xiufeng Zhang, Tao Xiang, Yuzhen Ma, Linlin Chen, Kun Xia, Tao Yang, Weikang WangChinese 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

While "negative coal pillar" (NCP) layouts are designed to shield mine roadways from high static stress, dynamic shocks from nearby mining can still trigger catastrophic rockbursts. This paper reveals the mechanics behind these failures and introduces a dual-criterion risk identification model—based on energy and displacement—to predict and prevent these violent events.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In deep coal mining, "rockbursts"—the sudden, violent ejection of coal and rock—are a major safety hazard. To combat this, engineers often use a "negative coal pillar" (NCP) arrangement, where roadways are tucked beneath the edge of a previously mined-out area (the gob). This layout typically places the roadway in a low-stress "pressure relief" zone, making it significantly safer than traditional layouts.

However, a major rockburst occurred unexpectedly in an NCP roadway at the Junde Coal Mine during a mining shock event. This incident proved that NCP layouts are not immune to "dynamic load disturbances"—vibrations and pressure waves caused by rock fractures elsewhere in the mine. The authors set out to understand why these supposedly safe zones fail and how to identify when they are at risk.

Methods

The researchers employed a three-pronged approach:

  1. Field Investigation: They analyzed the "11.14" rockburst event at Junde Coal Mine, documenting damage like hydraulic support failure and roadway deformation.
  2. Numerical Simulation: Using PFC2D (Particle Flow Code), they created a virtual model of the mine to simulate how individual particles of coal and rock move and interact during a shock. This allowed them to visualize stress waves and energy absorption that are impossible to see in real life.
  3. Theoretical Modeling: They developed mathematical models based on energy attenuation theory and rock dynamics. These models calculate how much energy a shock wave loses as it travels through different rock layers and whether the remaining energy is enough to "eject" coal into the roadway.

Datasets

The study relies on:

  • Field Data: Microseismic monitoring records and borehole data from the Junde Coal Mine (specifically the 17-seam gob-side face).
  • Geomechanical Parameters: Laboratory-tested values for rock properties (density, elasticity, friction angles, and cohesion) for various strata like siltstone and coarse-grained sandstone.
  • Validation Case: Data from the Huafeng Coal Mine was used to verify the effectiveness of the proposed prevention measures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Double-Exceeded" State: A rockburst occurs when two thresholds are crossed simultaneously: the shock energy exceeds the support system's absorption capacity (Energy Criterion), and the resulting movement exceeds the roadway's structural stability limits (Displacement Criterion).
  • The Role of the Plastic Zone: The "broken" or plastic coal surrounding an NCP roadway actually acts as a buffer. If this zone is wide enough, it absorbs the kinetic energy of the shock wave, preventing a burst.
  • Shock Path Matters: The researchers identified three main paths for vibration waves: through the roof, the floor, or the coal seam itself. Each path attenuates energy differently, meaning the location of the "source" tremor drastically changes the risk level.
  • Quantified Risk: The paper defines specific "danger zones" based on ejection velocity ($v_p$). For instance, if the calculated ejection velocity is $\ge 10$ m/s, a rockburst is considered certain.

Key Results

  • Risk Identification Model: The authors proposed a quantitative method to calculate the "Critical Width" of the pressure relief zone. For the Junde case, they calculated that the plastic zone needed to be expanded to at least 21.7 meters to ensure stability.
  • Displacement Thresholds: Roadway stability was categorized into three levels: Stable ($u < 50$ mm), Moderately Stable ($50 \le u < 200$ mm), and Unstable ($u \ge 200$ mm).
  • Prevention Success: By implementing three targeted measures—quantifying relief zones, optimizing support resistance, and using roof pre-cracking (blasting) to reduce the intensity of tremors—the researchers successfully mitigated rockburst risks in similar geological conditions at the Huafeng Coal Mine.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their model is robust, it relies on accurate microseismic data and precise geomechanical parameters, which can vary wildly across different mines. Future work could involve integrating this theoretical model into real-time monitoring software that provides "early warnings" to miners based on live seismic activity. Additionally, the 2D simulation (PFC2D) could be expanded to 3D to better capture the complex, multi-directional nature of stress waves in deep mines.

Summary updated

Abstract

The negative coal pillar roadway arrangement has been widely adopted in rockburst-prone mines across the country, demonstrating effectiveness in mitigating the rockburst risk associated with roadways along the gob. However, an unexpected rockburst incident occurred in the negative coal pillar roadway during the mining of the 17-seam coal gob-side fully mechanized caving face at Junde Coal Mine. In response to this incident, we conducted a comprehensive investigation of the rockburst damage characteristics of the negative coal pillar roadway in the context of dynamic load disturbances. Our approach utilized a multifaceted methodology, incorporating field measurements, numerical simulations of particle flow, and theoretical analysis. This enabled us to clarify the underlying mechanisms of rockbursts in negative coal pillar roadways induced by dynamic load disturbances and to propose a methodology for identifying rockburst hazards in such roadways. The findings of this study can be summarized as follows: We analyzed the movement and evolution characteristics of surrounding rock in the negative coal pillar roadway and proposed a risk criterion for rockbursts under dynamic load disturbances based on the ejection velocity of coal and rock bodies and the maximum radial displacement of the roadway. A rockburst damage calculation model for the negative coal pillar roadway under dynamic load disturbances was developed based on energy attenuation theory and rock dynamics. We derived the displacement damage engineering criterion and the dynamic damage criterion for the coal body in the negative coal pillar roadway under dynamic load disturbances, and proposed a method for identifying rockburst risk in this context. From a displacement perspective, the radial displacement of the roadway depends on the stress of the original rock, the angle of internal friction, and cohesion, which reflect the inherent strength of the rock, support resistance, and dynamic load. From an energy perspective, the ejection velocity of the coal body in the roadway is influenced by the energy of the mining shock, the distance from the mining shock to the negative coal pillar roadway, the energy attenuation coefficient, the range of the plastic zone, and the energy-absorbing effect of the roadway support assemblies. We proposed three targeted prevention and control measures, focusing on the generation of the vibration source, the propagation path of the vibration wave, and the mechanism of vibration wave disaster. These measures are designed to reduce the risk of rockbursts in negative coal pillar roadways subjected to dynamic load disturbances. The first measure involves quantifying the critical width of the pressure relief protection zone. The second measure addresses the over-support of the negative coal pillar roadway. The third measure entails pre-cracking and blasting of the roof plate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cai2025mechanism,
  author = {Yan Cai and S. Zhu and Xiufeng Zhang and Tao Xiang and Yuzhen Ma and Linlin Chen and Kun Xia and Tao Yang and Weikang Wang},
  title = {{Mechanism and risk identification of rockburst in negative coal pillar roadway induced by dynamic load disturbance}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3724/1000-6915.jrme.2024.0907},
}
Figure