Mechanical Behavior of Tunnel Lining with Cracks at Different Positions

Jie Su, Yinming Jie, Xiaokai Niu, Chang Liu, Xuan LiuSymmetry 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how cracks in tunnel linings affect their structural integrity and carrying capacity. Using 3D model tests, researchers found that cracks significantly reduce a tunnel's ability to withstand loads, with cracks at the vault being the most detrimental. This research is crucial for improving the safety and longevity of underground infrastructure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tunnel linings are critical for the safety and stability of underground structures. However, existing cracks, whether from construction defects or operational stress, can severely compromise their load-bearing capacity and shorten their service life. While previous research has touched upon tunnel damage, many studies have relied on 2D models or focused on specific crack types. This paper addresses the need for a more comprehensive understanding of how longitudinal cracks at different positions within a tunnel lining influence its mechanical behavior, deformation, and ultimate carrying capacity, particularly in the context of subway tunnels.

Methods

The researchers employed a series of 3D model tests using a self-developed loading device that simulates the stress conditions of a tunnel. They created a 1:10 scale model of a typical horseshoe-shaped subway tunnel lining, using gypsum and cementing material to mimic concrete properties. A baseline test without cracks was conducted, followed by four tests with prefabricated longitudinal cracks introduced at specific locations: the vault, arch shoulder, sidewall, and arch spring. The tests involved applying increasing vertical and horizontal loads to simulate earth pressure. During the tests, internal forces (axial force and bending moment) and deformation (vertical and horizontal convergence) were meticulously measured using strain gauges and displacement sensors. The progression of crack development and the ultimate failure modes were also observed and recorded.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the 3D model tests.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cracks are a major load reducer: The presence of any prefabricated crack significantly reduces the tunnel lining's carrying capacity compared to an intact lining.
  • Location, location, location: The position of a crack is paramount. Cracks at the vault are the most damaging, leading to the largest deformations and the most substantial reduction in carrying capacity.
  • Vault cracks accelerate damage: A crack at the vault not only weakens the lining but also accelerates the propagation of other cracks, particularly those at the arch spring, leading to earlier failure.
  • Internal forces shift: The internal forces within the lining (axial force and bending moment) are significantly altered by the presence and location of cracks. Generally, internal forces decrease with cracks, but stress concentrations can occur at arch springs.
  • Deformation patterns vary: While all cracks increase deformation, vault cracks cause the most significant vertical deformation. Horizontal deformation is less sensitive to crack location but is still amplified by their presence.
  • Failure mechanism: The lining typically fails when a crack at the arch spring penetrates, but the presence of a prefabricated crack at the vault or arch spring can hasten this process.

Key Results

  • The carrying capacity of the lining was reduced in all tests with prefabricated cracks.
  • The ultimate load of the structure with a vault crack (Test 2) was 215 kPa, a 6% reduction compared to the intact lining (Test 1) which failed at 228 kPa.
  • Cracks at the arch spring (Test 5) also significantly reduced the ultimate load by 4% (219 kPa) compared to the baseline.
  • The largest deformation occurred when the prefabricated crack was located at the vault, followed by the arch spring, sidewall, and arch shoulder.
  • Tension cracks consistently appeared in the inner fiber of the vault and inverted arch, regardless of prefabricated cracks, indicating inherent stress patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified model: The study used a gypsum-based material to simulate concrete, which, while having similar brittle properties, may not perfectly replicate the complex behavior of actual reinforced concrete under long-term loading.
  • Geometric similarity: While a 1:10 scale was used, scaling effects in material properties and crack propagation might exist.
  • Crack characteristics: The study focused on longitudinal cracks of specific dimensions (60 cm length, 0.2 mm width, 1 cm depth). Further research could explore the impact of varying crack lengths, widths, depths, and orientations.
  • Loading conditions: The study simulated static loading. Dynamic loading conditions, such as those from seismic events or traffic, could lead to different failure mechanisms.

The authors suggest that longitudinal cracks at the vault are the most critical and require strengthened treatment and attention in future projects. Future work could expand on these findings by investigating the influence of different crack types, material properties, and more complex loading scenarios.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{su2020mechanical,
  author = {Jie Su and Yinming Jie and Xiaokai Niu and Chang Liu and Xuan Liu},
  title = {{Mechanical Behavior of Tunnel Lining with Cracks at Different Positions}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/sym12020194},
}
Figure