Meat procurement strategy from the Neolithic to the Bronze Age in the Guanzhong region of Shaanxi Province, China

Qingbo Hu, Ningning Dong, Songmei Hu, Xiaoli Qin, Jing YuanFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

By analyzing animal remains across 26 archaeological sites, researchers have mapped the non-linear evolution of meat procurement in China’s Guanzhong region from 5900 BCE to 771 BCE. The study reveals a "mosaic" subsistence strategy where urban centers prioritized intensive animal husbandry while smaller settlements continued to rely on hunting, eventually shifting toward a diverse, bovid-heavy livestock economy that fueled the rise of the Western Zhou dynasty.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The transition from hunting-gathering to agriculture is often envisioned as a straight line, but the reality is frequently more complex. In the Guanzhong region—a cradle of early Chinese civilization—the specific trajectory of how people acquired meat was poorly understood.

While the region is famous for the Yangshao and Longshan cultures, researchers hadn't yet synthesized how environmental changes, population booms, and the emergence of social hierarchies (cities vs. villages) dictated what was on the dinner table. This paper seeks to determine if meat procurement followed a progressive path toward husbandry and how social status influenced diet and resource management.

Methods

The authors conducted a meta-analysis of zooarchaeological data—the study of animal remains from archaeological sites. They collated data from 26 different sites/locales, focusing specifically on mammals.

To quantify the data, they used two standard metrics:

  • NISP (Number of Identified Specimens): A count of every bone fragment identified to a specific taxon.
  • MNI (Minimum Number of Individuals): An estimate of the fewest number of individual animals necessary to account for all the skeletal elements found.

The researchers categorized the sites by period (Neolithic to Bronze Age) and by settlement hierarchy, distinguishing between "central urban settlements" (over 20 hectares or walled) and "lower-ranking ordinary settlements."

Datasets

The study utilizes a collated dataset from 26 Neolithic and Bronze Age sites in the Guanzhong region (Shaanxi Province). These sites span several distinct cultural periods:

  • Pre-Yangshao (Laoguantai culture): 5900–5000 BCE.
  • Yangshao (Banpo, Miaodigou, Xiwangcun phases): 4900–2900 BCE.
  • Longshan (Miaodigou II, Keshengzhuang phases): 2900–2000 BCE.
  • Bronze Age (Xia, Shang, Pre-Zhou, and Western Zhou): 2070–771 BCE.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Winding Path" of Progress: Meat procurement did not follow a linear progression from hunting to farming. Instead, it involved "accelerations and regressions." For example, during the late Yangshao period, husbandry actually declined in many sites, with a temporary return to a heavier reliance on wild resources.
  • The Mosaic Pattern: A clear "subsistence divide" emerged alongside social hierarchy. Residents of large, central urban sites opted for intensive animal husbandry (mostly pigs), while those in smaller, lower-ranking settlements continued to rely heavily on hunting wild game like sika deer.
  • The Bovid Revolution: For millennia, the domesticated pig was the undisputed king of the Guanzhong diet. It wasn't until the Pre-Zhou and Western Zhou periods (c. 1300 BCE onwards) that domesticated bovids (sheep, goats, and cattle) surged in importance, eventually outnumbering pigs.
  • Demographics as a Driver: The authors argue that population density was a primary driver for husbandry. As populations spiked during the Miaodigou period, the demand for meat could no longer be met by hunting alone, forcing an intensification of pig farming.

Key Results

  • Pig Dominance: In early periods, pigs often accounted for 75% to 100% of all domesticated animal remains.
  • Urban vs. Rural: At the urban site of Yangguanzhai (Middle Yangshao), domesticates made up 94% of the assemblage. Meanwhile, at the smaller site of Jiangzhai II (Shijia culture), domesticates dropped to just 13%, showing a massive reliance on wild animals.
  • The Zhou Shift: By the Western Zhou period, the proportion of domesticated bovids rose dramatically, reaching 40% to 72% of the domesticated assemblage at some sites.
  • Correlation with Urbanization: The study found a positive correlation (r = 0.3) between the proportion of domesticated animals and the size of the settlement, suggesting that as cities grew, they became increasingly "disconnected" from wild meat sources.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the Guanzhong region is well-studied, their findings are regional. They suggest that future research should expand into "untapped" areas like the Sichuan Basin and Northeast China to see if these patterns hold true elsewhere.

Additionally, they highlight the need for more integrated studies using stable isotope analysis (to understand what the animals themselves were eating) and ancient DNA (aDNA) to track the specific lineages of these early domesticates. This would provide a higher-resolution look at how trade and migration influenced local meat strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Meat procurement strategies, displaying a great variety world-widely, are ideal for examining how geography and culture shape the subsistence. We collate zooarchaeological data from 26 Neolithic and Bronze Age sites/locales in the Guanzhong region (Shaanxi Province, China), a key region of early Chinese civilization, to demonstrate the changing process of meat procurement and its associations with environmental, demographic and societal factors. Comparing the proportion of the domesticates versus wild animals, along with the proportion of the domesticated pigs versus bovids (i.e., sheep, goat, and cattle), we summarize three characteristics of the meat procurement strategy at Guanzhong. Firstly, the changing pattern of meat procurement did not follow a linear progression of shifting subsistence from hunting to husbandry, albeit involving acceleration and regression from the pre-Yangshao period to the Western Zhou dynasty. Secondly, contrasting meat procurement strategies might have been employed between central settlements and lower-ranking settlements. Thirdly, an increasing importance of domesticated bovids was evident during the pre-Zhou and Western Zhou periods. We therefore argue population size and societal form might have shaped meat procurement strategies, in addition to natural environments. Subsistence, in turn, also lays the economic foundation for social development. It was not until the pre-Zhou and Western Zhou periods, when a more stable meat procurement strategy involving utilizing a variety of the domesticates was pervasively employed in this region, that Guanzhong had gradually gained its prominence in Chinese civilization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2023meat,
  author = {Qingbo Hu and Ningning Dong and Songmei Hu and Xiaoli Qin and Jing Yuan},
  title = {{Meat procurement strategy from the Neolithic to the Bronze Age in the Guanzhong region of Shaanxi Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2023.1098984},
}

Loading related content...

Figure