Measuring the tolerance of the genetic code to altered codon size

Erika A. DeBenedictis, Dieter Söll, Kevin M. EsveltbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why life settled on a three-base genetic code instead of a four-base one. Researchers found that while E. coli tRNAs can be engineered to read four-base codons, the limited compatibility with aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and the need for multiple mutations to achieve efficient translation likely prevented the evolution of an all-quadruplet genetic code. This work provides a foundation for engineering synthetic all-quadruplet genetic codes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The genetic code, the set of rules by which information encoded in genetic material (DNA or RNA sequences) is translated into proteins, universally uses three-nucleotide "codons" to specify each of the 20 amino acids. This raises a fundamental question: why a triplet code (64 possible codons) and not a quadruplet code (256 possible codons)? A quadruplet code would offer a much larger repertoire of codons, potentially allowing for a more diverse set of amino acids and functionalities in proteins. This paper explores the evolutionary and biochemical constraints that might have prevented the emergence and widespread adoption of a quadruplet genetic code, and conversely, how such a code could be engineered for synthetic biology applications.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to assess the feasibility of quadruplet codon translation:

  • Point Insertions in Anticodon Loops: They introduced single-nucleotide insertions into the anticodon loops of E. coli tRNAs to create quadruplet tRNAs (qtRNAs) and tested their ability to decode four-base codons.
  • Directed Evolution and Phage Display: For a more comprehensive exploration, they used M13 bacteriophage displaying a selection marker (pIII) to evolve qtRNAs. Libraries of tRNAs with randomized anticodons were selected for their ability to suppress a quadruplet stop codon in the phage gene, allowing for the identification of functional qtRNAs.
  • Luciferase Readthrough Assay: This assay was used to quantitatively measure the efficiency of quadruplet codon translation. A reporter construct with a quadruplet codon was used; functional qtRNAs would allow for full-length luciferase production, while non-functional ones would lead to premature termination.
  • Mass Spectrometry for Amino Acid Incorporation: To determine which amino acid a specific qtRNA incorporated, they co-expressed the qtRNA with a modified GFP protein containing a quadruplet codon at a specific position. After purifying the GFP, mass spectrometry was used to identify the amino acid incorporated at that position.
  • Directed Evolution of Anticodon Loop Sides: To investigate factors beyond anticodon recognition, they performed directed evolution on bases flanking the anticodon loop (positions 32, 37, and 38) to improve qtRNA translation efficiency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated through their assays and selections, rather than pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Broad tRNA Amenability: Remarkably, tRNAs from all 20 canonical E. coli isoacceptor classes can be engineered to support quadruplet codon translation, suggesting that the basic machinery for reading four-base codons is widely available.
  • Synthetase Bottleneck: The major hurdle for an all-quadruplet code is the limited compatibility of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (AARSs). Only 9 out of 20 AARSs were found to tolerate quadruplet anticodons and selectively charge their cognate tRNAs, severely restricting the chemical diversity of an all-quadruplet system.
  • Efficiency Requires More Than Just Anticodon: While many tRNAs can be converted to functional qtRNAs, efficient translation often requires additional mutations in the anticodon loop sides, suggesting that simply altering the anticodon is not enough for high-fidelity, efficient quadruplet decoding.
  • Promiscuous Arginine Charging: A significant observation was the promiscuous charging of many qtRNAs with arginine by ArgRS. This is attributed to ArgRS's broad recognition of multiple Arg-tRNAs and its tolerance for variations in anticodon identity elements.
  • Evolutionary Trade-offs: The study suggests that while quadruplet codon translation components likely arose frequently during early evolution, strong fitness defects associated with some qtRNAs and the need for multiple mutations to achieve efficiency likely prevented their widespread adoption.

Key Results

  • 12/20 tRNA Isoacceptor Classes: Readily converted to functional qtRNAs through point insertions.
  • 9/20 AARSs: Tolerate quadruplet anticodons and selectively charge cognate qtRNAs.
  • Efficient Translation Requires Multiple Mutations: For many qtRNAs, efficiency improvements were observed with additional mutations in anticodon loop sides.
  • Selective Amino Acid Incorporation: In many cases, qtRNAs selectively incorporated the amino acid cognate to their original scaffold, even with altered anticodons. However, some qtRNAs promiscuously incorporated arginine.
  • Blueprint for Synthetic Codes: The study identified specific qtRNAs and their corresponding codons that are selectively charged, providing a foundation for engineering synthetic all-quadruplet genetic codes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fitness Defects: Some engineered qtRNAs exhibited significant fitness defects, hindering their potential for natural selection.
  • Efficiency Bottleneck: Achieving high translation efficiency often requires multiple mutations beyond the anticodon itself, which would have been a barrier to de novo evolution.
  • AARS Intolerance: The limited number of AARSs that tolerate quadruplet anticodons restricts the amino acid diversity of a potential all-quadruplet code.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that refactoring or replacing AARSs, particularly ArgRS, could be a strategy to expand the amino acid repertoire of quadruplet codes. They also highlight the need for strategies like CCA tail engineering to mitigate toxicity and competition with existing triplet tRNAs. The work provides a clear blueprint for synthetic biologists aiming to engineer a 256-amino acid genetic code.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary Protein translation using four-base codons occurs in both natural and synthetic systems. What constraints contributed to the universal adoption of a triplet-codon, rather than quadruplet-codon, genetic code? Here, we investigate the tolerance of the E. coli genetic code to tRNA mutations that increase codon size. We found that tRNAs from all twenty canonical isoacceptor classes can be converted to functional quadruplet tRNAs (qtRNAs), many of which selectively incorporate a single amino acid in response to a specified four-base codon. However, efficient quadruplet codon translation often requires multiple tRNA mutations, potentially constraining evolution. Moreover, while tRNAs were largely amenable to quadruplet conversion, only nine of the twenty aminoacyl tRNA synthetases tolerate quadruplet anticodons. These constitute a functional and mutually orthogonal set, but one that sharply limits the chemical alphabet available to a nascent all-quadruplet code. Our results illuminate factors that led to selection and maintenance of triplet codons in primordial Earth and provide a blueprint for synthetic biologists to deliberately engineer an all-quadruplet expanded genetic code.
BibTeX
@misc{debenedictis2021measuring,
  author = {Erika A. DeBenedictis and Dieter Söll and Kevin M. Esvelt},
  title = {{Measuring the tolerance of the genetic code to altered codon size}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.04.26.441066},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure