Measuring the Psychological Behavior of Tourism Service Providers in Low-Income Regions: Implementing Effective Service Marketing and Performances Strategies

Shaochen Xu, Xiaofei Zhou, Zeeshan AhmadSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how service marketing strategies impact tourism businesses in the under-developed Italian region of Molise. By applying an econometric model to the 7Ps marketing mix, the research reveals that focusing on product development, local identity, and digital promotion significantly boosts revenue and profitability, offering a roadmap for sustainable growth in similar low-income regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of economic development in low-income, less-developed regions, specifically within the tourism sector. While major cities often benefit from tourism growth, smaller, less popular areas are frequently overlooked, leading to regional disparities. The authors aim to understand how effective service marketing strategies can be implemented by small tourism businesses in such regions to improve their performance and contribute to local economic growth, moving beyond the traditional focus on manufacturing as the primary driver of economic progress.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining structured interviews with tourism service providers and an econometric model for data analysis. The core of the analysis is the application of the 7Ps marketing mix strategy (Product, Price, Place, Promotion, People, Process, Physical Evidence) to understand its impact on enterprise performance, measured by revenue, cost, and profit. An econometric model is used to estimate the factors affecting these performance metrics, with control variables including gender, education, age, and business type. The research also draws on Stan Shih's innovation smiling curve theory to frame the relationship between upstream (R&D) and downstream (marketing) activities.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected through structured interviews with tourism and hospitality operators in the Molise region of Italy. The sample included three types of enterprises: hotels and accommodations, restaurants, and stores/gift shops. The paper does not mention the use of pre-existing datasets or the creation of new benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Product is King (and Queen): Product strategy, particularly focusing on quality that meets market requirements, reflecting local identity, and continuous development, had the most significant positive impact on revenue and profitability.
  • Digital Dominance: Online promotion, especially through websites and social media, proved far more effective than traditional advertising like billboards, leading to substantial profit increases.
  • Local Identity Matters: While not always statistically significant in all analyses, there's a strong indication that integrating local wisdom and identity into services can positively influence brand perception and potentially revenue.
  • People Power: Investing in staff development and training, and fostering team building, significantly boosted revenues and profits, highlighting the importance of human capital.
  • Price is Secondary (but still important): While price strategy had a less pronounced impact than product or promotion, having clearly stated, fair prices that are easily verifiable and do not exploit customers contributed to higher revenues.
  • The "Smiling Curve" in Action: The study supports Stan Shih's theory, showing that investments in both upstream (R&D) and downstream (marketing/brand development) activities are crucial for value creation and profitability.

Key Results

  • Enterprises that encouraged employee training or development saw sales increase by up to 48%.
  • Service product research and development activities had a beneficial impact, leading to revenue boosts of up to 161%.
  • A 1% increase in an enterprise's dependence on technology led to a 14% increase in costs/expenses.
  • Enterprises that prioritized team development saw an 80% boost in profits, though this also led to an 84% rise in costs.
  • Online sales/service promotions increased earnings by 58% compared to sales via agents.
  • Convenient locations reduced costs/expenses and increased profit margins by around 9%.
  • Marketing on websites and social media increased profits by 109% compared to advertising on billboards.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that comparing means without a controlled variable and estimate using an econometric model can be biased and inaccurate. They suggest that future research should incorporate more robust econometric modeling to provide a more definitive understanding of the relationships. Additionally, while the study focused on Molise, expanding the research to other underdeveloped regions would allow for broader generalizations. The paper also highlights the need for further investigation into how to effectively integrate local identities into service products and promotions to maximize their impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

An effective marketing strategy is a critical contribution in any business including the tourism sector. Understanding marketing strategies increases business performance. The purpose of this study is to determine how service marketing strategies impact small town tourism business owners. Using an econometric model, the implementation of the 4P mixed strategy on the profitability and potential of service providers in Molise is investigated. Revenue, cost, and profit are the three areas analyzed. Results showed that service operators have to place emphasis on research and development, reflecting cultural identities and the adoption of modern media. Operators should emphasize marketing and sales promotions through websites and social media. Creating a quality brand and setting reasonable prices without exploiting consumers are essential strategies. In conclusion, strategies that emphasize knowledge management and team building should be put into practice. This study could help tourism businesses in small regions to be more sustainable. It is the first research study where Stan Shih’s innovation smiling curve has been used in an Italian region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2022measuring,
  author = {Shaochen Xu and Xiaofei Zhou and Zeeshan Ahmad},
  title = {{Measuring the Psychological Behavior of Tourism Service Providers in Low-Income Regions: Implementing Effective Service Marketing and Performances Strategies}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141811459},
}
Figure