Measuring the Likelihood of Numerical Constraints

Marco Console, Matthias F. J. Hofer, Leonid LibkinIJCAI 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of quantifying the likelihood of numerical constraints without prior probability distributions or explicit bounds. They propose a formal definition of "likelihood" based on the asymptotic proportion of space satisfying a constraint and prove its existence for constraints definable in the real exponential field, while showing it fails for non-o-minimal structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imagine you have a set of rules or conditions involving numbers, like "x is greater than y" or "e to the power of x is less than y." How likely is it that a randomly chosen set of numbers will satisfy these rules, especially when we don't have any pre-defined ranges for these numbers or any idea of how likely different values are? This is the core problem. Traditional approaches to calculating such "likelihoods" often rely on finite bounds or probability distributions, which aren't always available. This paper aims to define and measure this likelihood for complex numerical constraints, even when they define unbounded regions in space. This is crucial for areas like program analysis, querying incomplete data, and temporal reasoning, where understanding the "certainty" or "probability" of conditions is important.

Methods

The authors define the "likelihood" of a constraint $\phi$ (represented by a formula) as the limit of the proportion of an $n$-dimensional ball of radius $r$ that satisfies $\phi$, as $r$ approaches infinity. They first establish that this definition is "well-behaved" (i.e., invariant under rotations and reflections) only when using the Euclidean norm (L2 norm).

A key theoretical contribution is proving that this likelihood exists for constraints definable in the real exponential field ($\mathbb{R}, +, \cdot, \exp$). This relies on deep results from model theory, specifically the concept of "o-minimality," which characterizes structures where definable sets are well-behaved (finite unions of intervals). They show that if a structure is not o-minimal (e.g., by adding natural numbers or trigonometric functions), the likelihood may not exist.

For practical computation, they focus on linear constraints (definable in $\mathbb{R}, +, \cdot$). Since exact computation is often intractable and results can be irrational, they develop an additive-error approximation scheme (AFPRAS). This algorithm works by sampling points from a ball and estimating the proportion that satisfies the constraint.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Likelihood as an Asymptotic Proportion: The paper formalizes the intuitive idea of likelihood for unbounded constraints by looking at how much "space" a constraint occupies as we consider larger and larger regions.
  • O-Minimality is Key: The existence of a well-defined likelihood is deeply tied to the o-minimal property of the underlying mathematical structure. This provides a powerful theoretical tool for understanding when likelihoods are meaningful.
  • Euclidean Norm is Special: Only the Euclidean norm (L2) leads to a "well-behaved" likelihood that is invariant under geometric transformations like rotations.
  • Approximation is Necessary for Linear Constraints: For linear constraints, exact likelihoods are often irrational, necessitating approximation techniques. The development of an AFPRAS offers a practical way to estimate these likelihoods.
  • Failure of Likelihood in Non-O-Minimal Structures: The paper demonstrates that adding features like natural number predicates or trigonometric functions can break the well-definedness of likelihood, highlighting the limitations of the approach.

Key Results

  • The likelihood of a numerical constraint is formally defined as a limit of volume ratios within expanding balls.
  • This likelihood is well-behaved (invariant under isometries) if and only if the Euclidean norm is used.
  • The likelihood exists for all constraints definable in the real exponential field ($\mathbb{R}, +, \cdot, \exp$), which is an o-minimal structure.
  • The likelihood does not exist for constraints in structures that are not o-minimal, such as those including natural number predicates or trigonometric functions.
  • Computing the exact likelihood for order constraints is #P-hard.
  • An AFPRAS is provided for computing the likelihood of linear constraints, guaranteeing an additive error.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation for Polynomial Constraints: The current approximation scheme is for linear constraints. Extending it to polynomial constraints is a significant open problem.
  • Applications: The authors highlight several potential applications in program analysis, querying incomplete data, and temporal constraint networks, suggesting these as avenues for future research.
  • Constraints over Integers: The paper notes that their results might help estimate likelihoods of constraints over integers ($\mathbb{Z}^n$), as lattice point counts can approximate volumes.
  • Decidability of Real Exponential Field: The decidability of the real exponential field is still an open problem, which impacts the practical computability of likelihoods for complex formulas in this structure.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{console2019measuring,
  author = {Marco Console and Matthias F. J. Hofer and Leonid Libkin},
  title = {{Measuring the Likelihood of Numerical Constraints}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2019/229},
}
Figure