Measuring quantum states: Experimental setup for measuring the spatial density matrix

Max TegmarkPhysical 1996 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

To quantify the effect of decoherence in quantum measurements, it is desirable to measure not merely the square modulus of the spatial wave function, but the entire density matrix, whose phases carry information about momentum and how pure the state is. An experimental setup is presented that can measure the density matrix (or equivalently, the Wigner function) of a beam of identically prepared charged particles to an arbitrary accuracy, limited only by count statistics and detector resolution. The particles enter into an electric field, causing simple harmonic oscillation in the transverse direction. This corresponds to rotating the Wigner function in phase space. With a slidable detector, the marginal distribution of the Wigner function can be measured from all angles. Thus the phase-space tomography formalism can be used to recover the Wigner function by the standard inversion of the radon transform. By applying this technique to, for instance, double-slit experiments with various degrees of environment-induced decoherence, it should be possible to make our understanding of decoherence and apparent wave-function collapse less qualitative and more quantitative. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Introduction

In standard quantum mechanics, measurements typically yield the probability density—the square of the wavefunction ($|\psi|^2$). However, this "shadow" of the quantum state discards critical phase information. To fully characterize a system, especially one interacting with its environment, we require the density matrix ($\rho$). The density matrix allows us to distinguish between a pure quantum superposition and a classical statistical mixture, a distinction central to the study of decoherence.

Decoherence is the process by which quantum systems lose their "quantumness" due to environmental interactions. While theoretically well-understood, experimental verification has often been qualitative. Max Tegmark's 1996 proposal provides a concrete experimental framework to "photograph" the full spatial density matrix of a particle beam, enabling a quantitative study of decoherence.

The Experimental Apparatus

The proposed setup utilizes a beam of charged particles, such as electrons, which are collimated and passed through a specialized "Harmonic Oscillator Box."

Schematic of the proposed experimental setup for measuring the spatial density matrix.

As shown in Figure 1, the apparatus consists of:

  1. Electron Source and Collimators: These prepare a beam of identically prepared particles.
  2. The Harmonic Oscillator Box: A shielded region where metal plates create a transverse electric field. This field is engineered to produce a potential $\phi(x) \propto x^2$, effectively acting as a harmonic oscillator in the $x$-direction.
  3. Sliding Detector: A detector that can be moved along the $y$-axis (the direction of beam propagation). Because the particles oscillate as they travel, their position in the $y$-direction corresponds to the "time" spent in the harmonic potential.

Phase-Space Tomography and the Wigner Function

The core of the measurement technique lies in phase-space tomography. Instead of working directly with the density matrix, it is often more intuitive to use the Wigner function ($W(x, p)$), a quasi-probability distribution in position-momentum space.

A representation of a Wigner function in phase space, showing the characteristic oscillatory fringes of a quantum superposition.

In a harmonic oscillator potential, the Wigner function undergoes a rigid rotation in phase space over time (Figure 2). By measuring the particle's position at different $y$-coordinates, the experimenter is effectively measuring the "marginal distribution" (the projection or shadow) of the Wigner function from different angles $\theta$.

By collecting these projections over a range of angles (from 0 to $\pi/2$), the full 2D Wigner function can be reconstructed using the inverse Radon transform—the same mathematical principle used in medical CT scans. Once the Wigner function is known, the density matrix can be directly calculated.

Key Insights and Technical Requirements

Tegmark identifies several critical parameters for a successful implementation:

  • Voltage Requirements: To achieve a full 90-degree rotation in phase space, the voltage $V_0$ applied to the plates must be significantly higher (roughly five times) than the initial acceleration voltage of the beam.
  • Sampling and Resolution: To avoid information loss, the number of detector positions along the $y$-axis should be comparable to the number of resolution elements across the detector's width ($L/\Delta x$).
  • Distinguishing Decoherence from Noise: A major challenge is that finite detector resolution acts as a "blurring" filter on the Wigner function. This blurring is mathematically identical to the effects of physical decoherence. Therefore, high detector resolution and a "hard" vacuum (to prevent unwanted collisions with air molecules) are essential to ensure that the observed decoherence is a result of the intended experimental parameters rather than experimental error.

Conclusion

By providing a method to measure the complete spatial density matrix, this setup moves the study of quantum foundations from the realm of thought experiments into the laboratory. Observing the "fringes" of the Wigner function (seen in Figure 2) disappear as environmental noise is introduced would provide the first direct, quantitative visualization of decoherence in a spatial system. This technique is not limited to electrons and could potentially be adapted for neutral atoms or complex molecules, offering a versatile tool for exploring the boundary between the quantum and classical worlds.

Reference: Tegmark, M. (1996). Measuring quantum states: an experimental setup for measuring the spatial density matrix. Phys. Rev. A, 54(4), 2703.

Summary updated

Abstract

To quantify the effect of decoherence in quantum measurements, it is desirable to measure not merely the square modulus of the spatial wave function, but the entire density matrix, whose phases carry information about momentum and how pure the state is. An experimental setup is presented that can measure the density matrix (or equivalently, the Wigner function) of a beam of identically prepared charged particles to an arbitrary accuracy, limited only by count statistics and detector resolution. The particles enter into an electric field, causing simple harmonic oscillation in the transverse direction. This corresponds to rotating the Wigner function in phase space. With a slidable detector, the marginal distribution of the Wigner function can be measured from all angles. Thus the phase-space tomography formalism can be used to recover the Wigner function by the standard inversion of the radon transform. By applying this technique to, for instance, double-slit experiments with various degrees of environment-induced decoherence, it should be possible to make our understanding of decoherence and apparent wave-function collapse less qualitative and more quantitative. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tegmark1996measuring,
  author = {Max Tegmark},
  title = {{Measuring quantum states: Experimental setup for measuring the spatial density matrix}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1996},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.54.2703},
}
Figure