Measuring<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>α</mml:mi></mml:math>in the early universe: CMB temperature, large-scale structure, and Fisher matrix analysis

C. J. A. P. Martins, A. Melchiorri, Roberto Trotta, Rachel Bean, G. Rocha, P. P. Avelino, P. T. P. VianaPhysical 2002 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We extend our recent work on the effects of a time-varying fine-structure constant $\alpha$ in the cosmic microwave background by providing a thorough analysis of the degeneracies between $\alpha$ and the other cosmological parameters, and discussing ways to break these with both existing and/or forthcoming data. In particular, we present the state-of-the-art cosmic microwave background constraints on $\alpha$ through a combined analysis of the BOOMERanG, MAXIMA and DASI data sets. We also present a novel discussion of the constraints on $\alpha$ coming from large-scale structure observations, focusing in particular on the power spectrum from the 2dF survey. Our results are consistent with no variation in $\alpha$ from the epoch of recombination to the present day, and restrict any such variation to be less than about 4%. We show that the forthcoming Microwave Anisotropy Probe and Planck experiments will be able to break most of the currently existing degeneracies between $\alpha$ and other parameters, and measure $\alpha$ to better than percent accuracy.

Introduction

In the late 1990s and early 2000s, astronomical observations of distant quasars sparked a debate by suggesting that the fine-structure constant, $\alpha$—which dictates the strength of electromagnetic interactions—might have been slightly smaller billions of years ago. Such a discovery would fundamentally alter our understanding of physics, potentially validating theories involving extra dimensions or string theory. This paper, published in 2002, provides a rigorous independent check on these claims by analyzing the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Large-Scale Structure (LSS) of the universe.

Methodology and Datasets

Measuring $\alpha$ from the early universe is challenging due to parameter degeneracies. In the CMB power spectrum, a change in $\alpha$ can mimic the effects of varying other parameters like the baryon density ($\omega_b$) or the Hubble constant ($h$). To address this, the researchers employed three strategies:

  1. Likelihood Analysis: Using a modified CMBFAST code to calculate fluctuations with a varying $\alpha$, compared against data from BOOMERanG-98, MAXIMA-1, and DASI.
  2. LSS Integration: Incorporating the matter power spectrum from the 2dF (Two-degree-Field) galaxy redshift survey to break degeneracies.
  3. Fisher Matrix Analysis (FMA): Forecasting the precision of future missions like the Microwave Anisotropy Probe (MAP) and the Planck satellite.

Breaking Degeneracies with Complementary Data

The physical link between $\alpha$ and the CMB lies in recombination. $\alpha$ determines the energy levels of hydrogen; a different value in the past would shift the temperature at which the universe became neutral, thereby altering the positions and heights of the acoustic peaks in the CMB spectrum.

Joint constraints on the fine-structure constant and matter density from CMB and 2dF data.

A key insight of this work is that while CMB data alone might suggest a slightly lower value for $\alpha$, the inclusion of LSS data from the 2dF survey pulls the result back toward the standard value. As shown in the figure above, combining these datasets effectively "cancels out" systematic shifts, leading to a much tighter constraint that is consistent with no variation.

Future Prospects: From MAP to Planck

The study identified a nearly perfect correlation (0.99) between $\alpha$ and the "shift parameter" $\mathcal{R}$, which relates to the angular diameter distance to the last scattering surface. This explains why earlier experiments struggled to isolate $\alpha$ uniquely. However, the authors' Fisher Matrix Analysis predicted a dramatic shift in precision with upcoming missions.

Forecasted 1-sigma error ellipses for Boomerang, MAP, and Planck experiments showing the reduction in parameter degeneracies.

While early 2000s data restricted $\alpha$ variation to within roughly 4% ($0.98 \pm 0.04$), the analysis projected that the MAP satellite would reach ~2% accuracy, and the Planck mission would achieve sub-percent precision. This leap in resolution allows for the measurement of higher-order acoustic peaks, which are essential for disentangling $\alpha$ from other cosmological variables.

Conclusion

The combined analysis of CMB and LSS data provides a vital cross-check against quasar-based claims of a varying $\alpha$. The results are currently consistent with a constant $\alpha$ from the epoch of recombination ($z \approx 1100$) to the present. While some "geometrical degeneracies" remain, the authors suggest that future CMB polarization data will serve as the final piece of the puzzle to definitively pin down the fundamental constants of our universe.

Summary updated

Abstract

We extend our recent work on the effects of a time-varying fine-structure constant $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ in the cosmic microwave background by providing a thorough analysis of the degeneracies between $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and the other cosmological parameters, and discussing ways to break these with both existing and/or forthcoming data. In particular, we present the state-of-the-art cosmic microwave background constraints on $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ through a combined analysis of the BOOMERanG, MAXIMA and DASI data sets. We also present a novel discussion of the constraints on $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ coming from large-scale structure observations, focusing in particular on the power spectrum from the 2dF survey. Our results are consistent with no variation in $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ from the epoch of recombination to the present day, and restrict any such variation to be less than about $4%.$ We show that the forthcoming Microwave Anisotropy Probe and Planck experiments will be able to break most of the currently existing degeneracies between $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and other parameters, and measure $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ to better than percent accuracy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{martins2002measuring,
  author = {C. J. A. P. Martins and A. Melchiorri and Roberto Trotta and Rachel Bean and G. Rocha and P. P. Avelino and P. T. P. Viana},
  title = {{Measuring<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>α</mml:mi></mml:math>in the early universe: CMB temperature, large-scale structure, and Fisher matrix analysis}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.66.023505},
}
Figure