Measuring mental wellbeing of children via human-robot interaction

Nida Itrat Abbasi, Micol Spitale, Peter B. Jones, Hatice GüneşInteraction 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reviews existing research on using robots to measure children's mental wellbeing, identifying key challenges and opportunities. It highlights that while robots show promise in this area, significant hurdles remain in robot functionality, study protocols, and establishing long-term, naturalistic interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The mental wellbeing of children has become a growing concern, exacerbated by recent global events. While Socially Assistive Robots (SARs) show potential for supporting children with mental health issues, there's a significant gap in understanding how these robots can be effectively used to measure mental wellbeing. Traditional methods often fall short with children due to engagement issues, difficulty in detecting subtle distress, and reluctance to disclose sensitive information. This paper aims to bridge this gap by reviewing current Child-Robot Interaction (cHRI) research focused on mental wellbeing assessment, identifying challenges, and suggesting future research directions.

Methods

The authors conducted a narrative review of empirical studies in cHRI related to mental wellbeing. They employed a two-step search strategy:

  1. IEEE ROMAN proceedings (2016-2021): This focused on recent advancements in the field.
  2. Google Scholar (last 15 years): This broader search, using keywords like "robot," "mental," and "child," aimed to capture a comprehensive set of relevant articles.

The SPIDER framework was used to systematically identify and include studies. The review focused on 10 screened papers, analyzing them based on robot-related factors (autonomy, type), protocol-related factors (purpose, tasks, participants, sensing), and data-related factors (analysis, findings).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review of existing literature and does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Robots as a Trustworthy Medium: Children may be more comfortable disclosing sensitive information to robots than to human interviewers, potentially overcoming a significant barrier in mental health assessment.
  • The "Novelty Effect" Challenge: The initial excitement of interacting with a robot can influence measurements, making it difficult to ascertain true, long-term wellbeing.
  • Need for Naturalistic Interactions: Current studies often involve short, controlled interactions. Developing robots capable of more naturalistic, prolonged engagement is crucial for building rapport and obtaining more reliable data.
  • Validation is Key: Establishing a "ground truth" for robot-based assessments is difficult due to varying experimental protocols and robot autonomy levels. This makes generalizing findings challenging.
  • Ethical Considerations are Paramount: Researchers must carefully consider robot appearance, autonomy, privacy, attachment formation, deception, and accountability when designing studies involving children.

Key Results

The review identified four main challenges in cHRI studies for mental wellbeing:

  1. Functionality of the Robotised Setup: Limitations in robot sensing abilities and processing power hinder accurate user behavior evaluation and prolonged interactions.
  2. Protocol Related Limitations: Small sample sizes, narrow age ranges, and homogeneous participant pools limit the generalizability of findings.
  3. Establishing Less Constrained/More Naturalistic and Prolonged Interactions: The effectiveness of long-term interactions and building trust is often unexplored.
  4. Development of a Validation Protocol: The lack of consistent baselines and varying experimental protocols make it difficult to validate robot-based assessments.

Specific findings from the screened studies included:

  • Children were more willing to share information about bullying with a robot than a human interviewer (Study 52).
  • Robot-based social status estimation achieved 71.4% accuracy (Study 75).
  • Temperament estimation achieved 85% accuracy (Study 76).
  • Cross-cultural differences in engagement levels were observed (Study 77).
  • Personality estimation was demonstrated successfully compared to chance results (Study 79).
  • Friendship estimation achieved 80% accuracy for 5% of friendships (Study 80).

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The review is narrative, acknowledging potential selection bias due to unclear titles and keywords in the screened papers. * The identified challenges are broad categories, and researchers may face more specific issues.

Future Work: * Develop more sophisticated robot sensing and processing capabilities for naturalistic interactions. * Design studies with larger, more diverse participant groups to improve generalizability. * Focus on longitudinal studies to understand long-term effects and build trust. * Establish robust validation protocols to ensure the reliability of robot-based measurements. * Explore remote robotised screening platforms, especially given the rise of remote/hybrid formats. * Conduct multidisciplinary research involving experts from computer science, psychology, medicine, and engineering. * Investigate the impact of demographic factors (age, gender) on children's perception and interaction with robots. * Further explore neurophysiological responses and multimodal sensing for more accurate wellbeing assessment.

Summary updated

Abstract

During the last decade, children have shown an increasing need for mental wellbeing interventions due to their anxiety and depression issues, which the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated. Socially Assistive Robotics have been shown to have a great potential to support children with mental wellbeing-related issues. However, understanding how robots can be used to aid the measurement of these issues is still an open challenge. This paper presents a narrative review of child-robot interaction (cHRI) papers (IEEE ROMAN proceedings from 2016-2021 and keyword-based article search using Google Scholar) to investigate the open challenges and potential knowledge gaps in the evaluation of mental wellbeing or the assessment of factors affecting mental wellbeing in children. We exploited the SPIDER framework to search for the key elements for the inclusion of relevant studies. Findings from this work (10 screened papers in total) investigate the challenges in cHRI studies about mental wellbeing by categorising the current research in terms of robot-related factors (robot autonomy and type of robot), protocol-related factors (experiment purpose, tasks, participants and user sensing) and data related factors (analysis and findings). The main contribution of this work is to highlight the potential opportunities for cHRI researchers to carry out measurements concerning children's mental wellbeing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abbasi2022measuring,
  author = {Nida Itrat Abbasi and Micol Spitale and Peter B. Jones and Hatice Güneş},
  title = {{Measuring mental wellbeing of children via human-robot interaction}},
  booktitle = {Interaction},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1075/is.21027.abb},
}
Figure