Measuring jet quenching with a Bayesian inference analysis of hadron and jet data by JETSCAPE

R. J. Ehlers, A. Angerami, R. Arora, Steffen A. Bass, Shanshan Cao, Y. Chen, Lipei Du, Hannah Elfner, Wenkai Fan, Rainer J. Fries, Charles Gale, Yayun He, Ulrich Heinz, B. V. Jacak, P. M. Jacobs, Sangyong Jeon, Y. Ji, L. Kasper, M. Kordell, Amit Kumar, R. Kunnawalkam-Elayavalli, J. Latessa, Seongmin Lee, Y. -j. Lee, D. Liyanage, Matthew Luzum, Simon Mak, Abhijit Majumder, A. Mankolli, C. Martin, H. Mehryar, T. Mengel, James Declan Mulligan, C. Nattrass, J. -f. Paquet, Charles Thomas Parker, J. H. Putschke, Hendrik Roch, G. Roland, B. Schenke, L. Schwiebert, A. Sengupta, Chun Shen, C. Sirimanna, D. Soeder, R. A. Soltz, Ismail Soudi, M. Strickland, Y. Tachibana, J. Velkovska, Gojko Vujanovic, X. -n. Wang, W. ZhaoarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The JETSCAPE Collaboration reports the first multi-messenger study of the QGP jet transport parameter $\hat{q}$ using Bayesian inference, incorporating all available hadron and jet inclusive yield and jet substructure data from RHIC and the LHC. The theoretical model utilizes virtuality-dependent in-medium partonic energy loss coupled to a detailed dynamical model of QGP evolution. Tension is observed when constraining $\hat{q}$ for different kinematic cuts of the inclusive hadron data. The addition of substructure data is shown to improve the constraint on $\hat{q}$, without inducing tension with the constraint due to inclusive observables. These studies provide new insight into the mechanisms of jet interactions in matter, and point to next steps in the field for comprehensive understanding of jet quenching as a probe of the QGP.

Introduction

This research by the JETSCAPE Collaboration represents a major milestone in our understanding of the Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP)—the ultra-hot, dense state of matter that existed in the early universe. By applying advanced Bayesian inference to a massive multi-experiment dataset, the researchers have provided the most comprehensive constraints to date on how high-energy particles interact with this exotic medium.

The Challenge of Jet Quenching

When heavy ions collide at nearly the speed of light at facilities like RHIC or the LHC, they create a droplet of QGP. Physicists study this medium by observing "jets"—sprays of particles resulting from high-energy quarks or gluons produced in the initial collision. As these jets traverse the QGP, they lose energy and change shape, a phenomenon known as jet quenching.

The fundamental difficulty in this field is that many different theoretical models can describe the same basic data equally well. To distinguish between physical mechanisms, researchers require a systematic way to compare models against a wide variety of "messengers"—different types of experimental measurements. This paper addresses this need by establishing a rigorous statistical framework to combine diverse data sources and pin down the fundamental transport properties of the QGP.

Methodology

The researchers utilized the JETSCAPE simulation framework, a multi-stage modeling tool designed for high-energy nuclear physics.

  • Physical Modeling: The study combined the MATTER (high virtuality) and LBT (low virtuality) models to simulate parton energy loss. The medium itself was modeled using 2+1D relativistic viscous hydrodynamics.
  • The Transport Parameter: The focus was on $\hat{q}$ (q-hat), the jet transport coefficient, which characterizes the transverse momentum squared transferred from the medium to the jet per unit path length.
  • Statistical Framework: They employed Bayesian inference to produce a "posterior distribution"—a map of the most likely values for $\hat{q}$ given the experimental evidence, accounting for both theoretical and experimental uncertainties.

Datasets

The study incorporated a vast array of data from both the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) and the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), including experiments from ALICE, ATLAS, CMS, PHENIX, and STAR. The observables included inclusive charged hadron $R_{AA}$ (the ratio of production in heavy-ion vs. proton-proton collisions), inclusive jet $R_{AA}$, and jet substructure measurements such as hadron-in-jet fragmentation $D(z)$ and "groomed" observables ($z_g$ and $R_g$).

Key Results and Insights

Kinematic Tension in Hadron Data

One of the most striking findings was a "tension" between different data classes. As shown in the posterior distributions below, low-momentum ($p_T$) hadrons consistently prefer a higher value of $\hat{q}$, while high-momentum hadrons and jets prefer a lower value. This suggests that current models might be missing physics—such as nuclear shadowing—or that theoretical uncertainties in certain kinematic regimes are being underestimated.

Posterior distributions of the jet transport parameter for different data classes, highlighting the tension between low and high pT hadron data.

The Power of Jet Substructure

The analysis demonstrates that internal jet structure (how energy is distributed inside the jet) provides unique information that inclusive yields do not. Interestingly, while inclusive hadrons showed tension, the substructure measurements were fully consistent with the inclusive jet data.

Adding substructure data significantly narrowed the 90% confidence interval for $\hat{q}$. As illustrated in the figure below, the inclusion of substructure data (the orange band) reduces the uncertainty in the extracted transport parameter compared to using jet yields alone (the blue band), particularly at higher temperatures.

The 90% credible interval for q-hat as a function of temperature, showing how adding jet substructure data (orange) significantly narrows the constraint compared to jet RAA alone (blue).

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The JETSCAPE Collaboration successfully extracted a consistent $\hat{q}$ distribution across multiple collision energies and experiments, confirming that the most probable value for $\hat{q}$ is temperature-dependent.

While the observed tension points to the need for more robust theoretical uncertainty modeling and the inclusion of effects like nuclear shadowing, this study serves as a powerful proof-of-concept. Future work will expand this analysis to semi-central collisions and include a wider library of observables and quenching models to further refine our understanding of the QGP's fundamental properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

The JETSCAPE Collaboration reports the first multi-messenger study of the QGP jet transport parameter $\hat{q}$ using Bayesian inference, incorporating all available hadron and jet inclusive yield and jet substructure data from RHIC and the LHC. The theoretical model utilizes virtuality-dependent in-medium partonic energy loss coupled to a detailed dynamical model of QGP evolution. Tension is observed when constraining $\hat{q}$ for different kinematic cuts of the inclusive hadron data. The addition of substructure data is shown to improve the constraint on $\hat{q}$, without inducing tension with the constraint due to inclusive observables. These studies provide new insight into the mechanisms of jet interactions in matter, and point to next steps in the field for comprehensive understanding of jet quenching as a probe of the QGP.
BibTeX
@misc{ehlers2024measuring,
  author = {R. J. Ehlers and A. Angerami and R. Arora and Steffen A. Bass and Shanshan Cao and Y. Chen and Lipei Du and Hannah Elfner and Wenkai Fan and Rainer J. Fries and Charles Gale and Yayun He and Ulrich Heinz and B. V. Jacak and P. M. Jacobs and Sangyong Jeon and Y. Ji and L. Kasper and M. Kordell and Amit Kumar and R. Kunnawalkam-Elayavalli and J. Latessa and Seongmin Lee and Y. -J. Lee and D. Liyanage and Matthew Luzum and Simon Mak and Abhijit Majumder and A. Mankolli and C. Martin and H. Mehryar and T. Mengel and James Declan Mulligan and C. Nattrass and J. -F. Paquet and Charles Thomas Parker and J. H. Putschke and Hendrik Roch and G. Roland and B. Schenke and L. Schwiebert and A. Sengupta and Chun Shen and C. Sirimanna and D. Soeder and R. A. Soltz and Ismail Soudi and M. Strickland and Y. Tachibana and J. Velkovska and Gojko Vujanovic and X. -N. Wang and W. Zhao},
  title = {{Measuring jet quenching with a Bayesian inference analysis of hadron and jet data by JETSCAPE}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2401.04201},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.04201},
}
Figure