TL;DR
This paper presents a highly precise measurement of the tau lepton's mass, $M_\tau = 1776.68 \pm 0.41$ MeV, using a novel pseudomass endpoint method with BABAR data. This measurement also yields a stringent upper limit on the mass difference between the tau lepton and its antiparticle, providing a sensitive test of CPT symmetry.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Standard Model of particle physics relies on fundamental parameters like particle masses, which cannot be predicted by the theory and must be experimentally determined. The tau lepton ($\tau$) is the heaviest known charged lepton, and its mass is a crucial parameter for various theoretical calculations, including branching fractions and tests of lepton universality. Furthermore, CPT (Charge, Parity, Time) symmetry is a fundamental principle in quantum field theory, stating that physical laws should remain unchanged under combined charge conjugation, parity inversion, and time reversal. A precise measurement of the mass difference between a particle and its antiparticle is a direct and sensitive test of CPT invariance. Any observed difference would signal physics beyond the Standard Model. Previous measurements of the tau mass and its mass difference had room for improvement in precision.
Methods
The BABAR experiment collected a large dataset of $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance decays, which are a rich source of tau lepton pairs ($e^+e^- \to \tau^+\tau^-$). The core of this analysis is the pseudomass endpoint method. This method reconstructs the tau lepton's mass from the decay products, specifically focusing on the $\tau \to \pi^-\pi^+\pi^-\nu_\tau$ decay channel due to its relatively large branching ratio and good signal purity.
The pseudomass ($M_p$) is defined such that it is always less than or equal to the true tau mass ($M_\tau$). The distribution of these pseudomasses exhibits a sharp edge at $M_\tau$. The challenge lies in accurately determining the position of this edge, which is smeared by factors like initial and final state radiation (ISR/FSR) and detector resolution.
To address these smearing effects, the researchers employed a sophisticated track momentum reconstruction correction procedure. This involved:
- Energy loss correction: Using a Kalman filter to account for energy lost by charged particles traversing detector material.
- Magnetic field modeling: Precisely modeling the detector's solenoidal magnetic field and accounting for potential distortions caused by nearby magnets (BDM).
- SVT material increase: Empirically increasing the simulated SVT material density by 20% to better match the behavior of charged particle tracks observed in control samples (like $K_S^0$ decays).
- BDM field increase: Increasing the simulated BDM magnetic field strength by 20% to account for uncertainties in its magnetization.
- Solenoid field increase: Slightly increasing the solenoid field strength to improve agreement with known particle masses.
These corrections were validated using control samples of $K_S^0$ and $D^+$ decays, ensuring their accuracy. The tau mass was then extracted by fitting the pseudomass distribution with an empirical function, and the mass difference was determined by analyzing the distributions for $\tau^+$ and $\tau^-$ separately.
Datasets
The primary dataset used in this analysis is 423 fb$^{-1}$ of $e^+e^-$ collision data collected by the BABAR detector at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance. This dataset corresponds to over 388 million $\tau^+\tau^-$ pairs.
Control samples used for validating the reconstruction corrections included:
- Inclusive $K_S^0 \to \pi^+\pi^-$
- $D^+ \to K^-\pi^+\pi^+$
- $D^+ \to \phi\pi^+$
- $D^+_s \to \phi\pi^+$
Monte Carlo (MC) simulations were extensively used for modeling detector response, background estimation, and for determining the relationship between the pseudomass endpoint and the true tau mass.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Pseudomass Endpoint Method: This technique is crucial for measuring the tau mass and, importantly, allows for the separate measurement of $\tau^+$ and $\tau^-$ masses, enabling direct tests of CPT symmetry.
- Sophisticated Detector Corrections: The paper highlights the critical importance of meticulously modeling detector effects, particularly track momentum reconstruction, for achieving high-precision measurements. The systematic corrections applied, especially the empirical increase in SVT material, were key to improving the accuracy.
- Sensitivity to CPT Violation: The measurement of the mass difference between $\tau^+$ and $\tau^-$ provides one of the most sensitive probes for CPT violation in the lepton sector.
- Validation with Control Samples: The use of $K_S^0$ and $D^+$ decays to validate the track reconstruction corrections demonstrates a rigorous approach to ensuring the reliability of the analysis.
Key Results
- Tau Mass Measurement: The paper reports a precise measurement of the tau lepton mass: $M_\tau = 1776.68 \pm 0.12 \text{ (stat)} \pm 0.41 \text{ (syst) MeV}$
- Tau Mass Difference: The measurement of the mass difference between the $\tau^+$ and $\tau^-$ is: $(M_{\tau^+} - M_{\tau^-}) / M_{AVG}^\tau = (-3.4 \pm 1.3 \text{ (stat)} \pm 0.3 \text{ (syst)}) \times 10^{-4}$
-
CPT Test: This result leads to an upper limit on the mass difference: $|M_{\tau^+} - M_{\tau^-}| / M_{AVG}^\tau < 5.5 \times 10^{-4}$ at 90% confidence level. This is a stringent constraint on potential CPT violation.
-
Dominant Uncertainty: The primary source of systematic uncertainty is attributed to the momentum reconstruction of charged particles.
Limitations and Future Work
- Momentum Reconstruction Uncertainty: The authors acknowledge that the dominant systematic uncertainty stems from the momentum reconstruction, particularly the empirical corrections applied to SVT material and magnetic field strengths. While these corrections improve agreement with known particle masses, the exact physical origin of the underestimation remains somewhat unclear.
- MC Modeling of 3π System: The modeling of the three-pion decay of the tau lepton in MC simulations is based on limited form factor data from previous experiments. While the pseudomass distribution in MC is found to be similar to data, variations in this modeling were explored and accounted for as a systematic uncertainty.
- Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further improvements in detector modeling and understanding of particle interactions within the detector could lead to even more precise measurements. The stringent limit on the mass difference also opens avenues for future experiments to search for even smaller deviations from CPT symmetry.
Summary updated