Measurement of Underwater Acoustic Energy Radiated by Single Raindrops

Shu Liu, Qi Li, Dajing Shang, Rui Tang, Qingming ZhangSensors 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical gap in understanding the acoustic energy radiated by individual raindrops, moving beyond previous studies focused on sound pressure and frequency. By developing a predictive model based on experimental measurements, the authors provide a method to estimate the total underwater acoustic energy from rainfall, crucial for applications like sonar performance and understanding marine environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Underwater ambient noise is significantly influenced by rainfall, which can interfere with sonar systems and impact marine life. While previous research has characterized the sound pressure and frequency spectrum of rainfall noise, a comprehensive understanding of the acoustic energy generated by individual raindrops, the fundamental source of this noise, has been lacking. This deficiency hinders accurate prediction of total rainfall noise, especially considering the wide range of raindrop sizes and their varying acoustic contributions. The authors aim to fill this gap by proposing a method to predict the acoustic energy radiated by single raindrops of any diameter and subsequently, the total acoustic energy during a rainfall event.

Methods

The study employs a two-pronged approach: theoretical modeling and experimental validation.

  • Theoretical Framework: The authors derive a formula to calculate the underwater sound energy radiated by single raindrops, treating the sound generation as a dipole radiation pattern. This model accounts for both the initial impact sound and the sound produced by the resulting underwater bubble.
  • Experimental Setup: A series of controlled experiments were conducted in a large reverberation tank (15m x 9m x 6m) filled with tap water. Standard intravenous drip bottles with needles of varying calibers were used to generate raindrops of five specific diameters (0.7, 0.9, 1.5, 2.5, and 3.9 mm). These drops were released from a height of 6m to ensure they reached their terminal velocity before impacting the water surface.
  • Measurement: A hydrophone was strategically placed 20 cm below the impact point to capture the acoustic signals, avoiding direct reflections from the tank walls. The collected signals were amplified and recorded using a pulse collector and a PC.
  • Analysis: The researchers analyzed the acoustic energy characteristics, including peak axial sound pressure, frequency distributions, and acoustic energy distributions for both impact and bubble sounds. They also calculated the conversion efficiency from the raindrop's kinetic energy to acoustic energy.
  • Model Development: Based on the experimental data and theoretical insights, a model was developed to predict the average underwater sound energy radiated by single raindrops. This model was then extended to predict the total underwater sound energy of all raindrops during a rainfall event, utilizing the drop size distribution.

Datasets

The study does not rely on pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generates its own experimental data through controlled raindrop impact experiments. The paper introduces a dataset of measured acoustic signals (sound pressure, frequency, and energy) from single raindrops of various sizes impacting a water surface.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Pressure and Frequency: The study highlights that focusing solely on sound pressure and frequency is insufficient for understanding rainfall noise; acoustic energy is a critical, previously understudied component.
  • Bubble Dynamics are Key: While initial impact contributes, the underwater bubble generated by a raindrop is a significant source of acoustic energy, particularly for larger drops. The type and probability of bubble formation vary with raindrop size.
  • Size Matters (A Lot): The acoustic energy radiated by a raindrop scales significantly with its diameter. Larger raindrops produce substantially more acoustic energy, with the energy of the bubble noise covering a much wider range.
  • Kinetic to Acoustic Energy Conversion is Inefficient: The efficiency of converting a raindrop's kinetic energy into radiated acoustic energy is very low, on the order of 10⁻⁵ for small raindrops and even lower for larger ones. This implies most of the raindrop's energy is dissipated through other means.
  • Predictive Model for Rainfall Noise: The developed model offers a practical way to estimate the total underwater acoustic energy from rainfall based on drop size distribution, which is a significant advancement for acoustic modeling in marine environments.

Key Results

  • Raindrop Size and Acoustic Energy:
    • Small raindrops (0.8 mm ≤ d ≤ 1.1 mm) primarily produce a weak initial impact sound and a type-I damped bubble with 100% probability. Their acoustic energy conversion efficiency is approximately 1 × 10⁻⁵.
  • Large raindrops (d > 2.2 mm) produce stronger initial impact sounds and type-II/III bubbles with varying probabilities. Their acoustic energy conversion efficiency is approximately 2d × 10⁻⁷.
  • The average acoustic energy of the initial impact noise increases with raindrop diameter, with values for 3.9 mm drops reaching up to 340 pJ.
  • The acoustic energy of bubble noise for larger drops (2.5 and 3.9 mm) covers a much wider range (0.4–243 pJ and 0.5–2200 pJ, respectively) compared to smaller drops.
  • Model Validation: The proposed model, based on experimental data and conversion efficiencies, can predict the average underwater sound energy radiated by single raindrops and, consequently, the total underwater sound energy during a rainfall event using the Marshall-Palmer expression for drop size distribution.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that for single raindrops, the efficiency of sound energy conversion is of "no practical significance" due to the variability in bubble production. The focus is on average efficiencies for groups of raindrops of the same size.
  • The experiments were conducted in a reverberation tank, which, while large, might still introduce some acoustic reflections. The authors state the pool was "sufficiently large to eliminate these effects," but this is a potential area of concern for precise measurements.
  • The model for predicting total rainfall noise relies on the Marshall-Palmer expression for drop size distribution, which is an empirical model and may have its own limitations.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest studying the correlation between different rainfall rates and corresponding total underwater sound energy to enable inversion of rainfall rates by measuring underwater sound energy.
  • The developed model has implications for predicting underwater sound energy from other liquids (e.g., waterfalls, ship discharges) hitting a water surface, provided their kinetic energy and conversion efficiencies are analyzed. This opens up broader applications for the methodology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Underwater noise produced by rainfall is an important component of underwater ambient noise. For example, the existence of rainfall noise causes strong disturbances to sonar performance. The underwater noise produced by a single raindrop is the basis of rainfall noise. Therefore, it is necessary to study the associated underwater noise when drops strike the water surface. Previous research focused primarily on the sound pressure and frequency spectrum of underwater noise from single raindrops, but the study on its sound energy is insufficient. The purpose of this paper is to propose a method for predicting the acoustic energy generated by raindrops of any diameter. Here, a formula was derived to calculate the underwater sound energy radiated by single raindrops based on a dipole radiation pattern. A series of experiments were conducted to measure the underwater sound energy in a 15 m × 9 m × 6 m reverberation tank filled with tap water. The analysis of the acoustic energy characteristics and conversion efficiency from kinetic to acoustic energy helped develop the model to predict the average underwater sound energy radiated by single raindrops. Using this model, the total underwater sound energy of all raindrops during a rainfall event can be predicted based on the drop size distribution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021measurement,
  author = {Shu Liu and Qi Li and Dajing Shang and Rui Tang and Qingming Zhang},
  title = {{Measurement of Underwater Acoustic Energy Radiated by Single Raindrops}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21082687},
}

Loading related content...

Figure