Measurement of the scintillation and ionization response of liquid xenon at MeV energies in the EXO-200 experiment

G. Anton, I. Badhrees, P. S. Barbeau, D. Beck, V. Belov, Trilochan Bhatta, M. Breidenbach, T. Brunner, G. F. Cao, W. R. Cen, C. Chambers, B. T. Cleveland, Minor J. Coon, A. Craycraft, T. Daniels, L. Darroch, S. J. Daugherty, J. Davis, S. Delaquis, A. Der Mesrobian-Kabakian, R. DeVoe, J. Dilling, A. Dolgolenko, M. J. Dolinski, J. Echevers, W. M. Fairbank, D. Fairbank, J. Farine, Soheyla Feyzbakhsh, P. Fierlinger, D. Fudenberg, P. Gautam, R. Gornea, G. Gratta, C. Hall, E. V. Hansen, J. Hoessl, P. Hufschmidt, M. Hughes, A. Iverson, A. Jamil, C. E. Jessiman, M. J. Jewell, A. Johnson, A. Karelin, L. J. Kaufman, T. Koffas, R. Krücken, A. Kuchenkov, K.s. Kumar, Y. Lan, A. C. Larson, B. G. Lenardo, D. S. Leonard, G. S. Li, Z. Li, C. Licciardi, Y. H. Lin, R. MacLellan, Thomas McElroy, Thilo Michel, B. Mong, David C. Moore, K. Murray, R. Neilson, O. Njoya, O. Nusair, A. Odian, I. Ostrovskiy, A. Piepke, A. Pocar, F. Retière, A. L. Robinson, P.c. Rowson, J. Runge, Susann Schmidt, D. Sinclair, A. K. Soma, V. Stekhanov, M. Tarka, J. Todd, T. Tolba, D. Tosi, T.i. Totev, B. Veenstra, V. Veeraraghavan, J.-l. Vuilleumier, M. Wagenpfeil, J. Watkins, M. Weber, Liangjian Wen, U. Wichoski, Gerrit Wrede, Sen Wu, Q. Xia, D. R. Yahne, L. Yang, Y.-r. Yen, O. ZeldovichPhysical Review. C 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first absolutely calibrated measurements of liquid xenon's response to MeV-scale gamma rays, crucial for next-generation neutrinoless double beta decay experiments. The study precisely determines the W-value (energy per detected quantum) and reveals deviations in recombination fluctuations at higher energies compared to lower-energy extrapolations, leading to an improved detector resolution model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detectors searching for rare events like neutrinoless double beta decay (0νββ) often utilize liquid xenon (LXe) due to its excellent scintillation and ionization properties. To accurately predict the sensitivity and performance of these detectors, especially future large-scale experiments like nEXO, a precise understanding of LXe's response to energy depositions is essential. This includes knowing the absolute yields of scintillation light and ionization charge produced by interactions, and how these yields change with electric fields. Previous measurements have primarily focused on lower energy depositions (keV scale), leaving a gap in our understanding at the MeV scale relevant for many calibration sources and potential background events. Furthermore, accurately modeling the energy resolution of these detectors requires a detailed understanding of recombination fluctuations, which are the anti-correlation between charge and light signals.

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the EXO-200 experiment, a single-phase LXe time projection chamber. They employed a suite of calibration sources ($^{228}$Th, $^{226}$Ra, and $^{60}$Co) emitting gamma rays in the 1-2.5 MeV range. A key aspect of their method was an "external charge-injection" calibration to precisely determine the gain of the charge readout electronics, achieving a high precision of 1.8% uncertainty. This allowed for an absolute calibration of the charge and light yields. They developed a semi-empirical model for the detector's energy resolution, incorporating measured detector parameters like electronics noise, recombination fluctuations, and photon detection efficiency. This model was then used to constrain the recombination efficiency, a crucial parameter for understanding the charge-light anti-correlation.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the EXO-200 experiment, specifically calibration data collected during Phase I and Phase II operations. These datasets consist of recorded signals from the charge readout wires and the avalanche photodiodes (APDs) for various gamma-ray energies (2615 keV, 1764 keV, 1332 keV, and 1173 keV) at different applied electric fields. The paper also references and compares its findings with data from previous experiments and simulations, such as the Noble Element Simulation Technique (NEST) [9, 29].

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MeV-Scale Response is Crucial: This work bridges a critical gap by providing the first absolutely calibrated measurements of LXe response at MeV energies, directly relevant for predicting the performance of future 0νββ detectors.
  • Precise W-Value: The measured W-value of 11.5 ± 0.5 (syst.) ± 0.1 (stat.) eV is a fundamental parameter for energy scale calibration in LXe detectors.
  • Recombination Deviations: Recombination fluctuations at MeV energies deviate from extrapolations of lower-energy data, highlighting the need for energy-dependent models.
  • Improved Resolution Model: A semi-empirical model was developed that accurately describes the EXO-200's energy resolution across various electric fields, providing a valuable tool for detector design and analysis.
  • Constrained Recombination Efficiency: The study successfully constrained the recombination efficiency ($\epsilon_r$), finding it to be very close to 1 (0.97), indicating that nearly all recombining electrons produce a detectable photon.

Key Results

  • The W-value was measured to be $11.5 \pm 0.5$ (syst.) $\pm 0.1$ (stat.) eV.
  • The photon detection efficiency ($\epsilon_p$) was determined to be $(8.1 \pm 0.5)\%$.
  • The measured charge and light yields at MeV energies differ by approximately 10% and 20%, respectively, from NEST predictions.
  • The measured energy resolution at 2615 keV and 567 V/cm was found to be $1.23\%$.
  • The recombination efficiency ($\epsilon_r$) was constrained to $0.97$.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the semi-empirical resolution model relies on the accuracy of measured detector parameters. While systematic errors have been carefully considered, unknown sources of systematic error or contributions to the overall resolution not included in the model could still influence the best-fit values, particularly for $\epsilon_r$. Future work could involve further refining the NEST simulation to better match these MeV-scale measurements, especially concerning the charge-to-light ratio differences observed. Additionally, more precise measurements of IR photon contributions to scintillation in LXe would be beneficial. The developed resolution model provides a strong foundation for predicting the performance of future LXe detectors, and further improvements could be achieved by reducing dominant noise sources, particularly in the photo-detector readout.

Summary updated

Abstract

Liquid xenon (LXe) is employed in a number of current and future detectors for rare event searches. We use the EXO-200 experimental data to measure the absolute scintillation and ionization yields generated by $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ interactions from $^{228}\mathrm{Th}$ (2615 keV), $^{226}\mathrm{Ra}$ (1764 keV), and $^{60}\mathrm{Co}$ (1332 keV and 1173 keV) calibration sources, over a range of electric fields. The $W$ value that defines the recombination-independent energy scale is measured to be $11.5\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.5$ (syst.) $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.1$ (stat.) eV. These data are also used to measure the recombination fluctuations in the number of electrons and photons produced by the calibration sources at the MeV scale, which deviate from extrapolations of lower-energy data. Additionally, a semiempirical model for the energy resolution of the detector is developed, which is used to constrain the recombination efficiency, i.e., the fraction of recombined electrons that result in the emission of a detectable photon. Detailed measurements of the absolute charge and light yields for MeV-scale electron recoils are important for predicting the performance of future neutrinoless double $\ensuremath{\beta}$-decay detectors.
BibTeX
@article{anton2020measurement,
  author = {G. Anton and I. Badhrees and P. S. Barbeau and D. Beck and V. Belov and Trilochan Bhatta and M. Breidenbach and T. Brunner and G. F. Cao and W. R. Cen and C. Chambers and B. T. Cleveland and Minor J. Coon and A. Craycraft and T. Daniels and L. Darroch and S. J. Daugherty and J. Davis and S. Delaquis and A. Der Mesrobian-Kabakian and R. DeVoe and J. Dilling and A. Dolgolenko and M. J. Dolinski and J. Echevers and W. M. Fairbank and D. Fairbank and J. Farine and Soheyla Feyzbakhsh and P. Fierlinger and D. Fudenberg and P. Gautam and R. Gornea and G. Gratta and C. Hall and E. V. Hansen and J. Hoessl and P. Hufschmidt and M. Hughes and A. Iverson and A. Jamil and C. E. Jessiman and M. J. Jewell and A. Johnson and A. Karelin and L. J. Kaufman and T. Koffas and R. Krücken and A. Kuchenkov and K.S. Kumar and Y. Lan and A. C. Larson and B. G. Lenardo and D. S. Leonard and G. S. Li and S. Li and Z. Li and C. Licciardi and Y. H. Lin and R. MacLellan and Thomas McElroy and Thilo Michel and B. Mong and David C. Moore and K. Murray and R. Neilson and O. Njoya and O. Nusair and A. Odian and I. Ostrovskiy and A. Piepke and A. Pocar and F. Retière and A. L. Robinson and P.C. Rowson and J. Runge and Susann Schmidt and D. Sinclair and A. K. Soma and V. Stekhanov and M. Tarka and J. Todd and T. Tolba and D. Tosi and T.I. Totev and B. Veenstra and V. Veeraraghavan and J.-L. Vuilleumier and M. Wagenpfeil and J. Watkins and M. Weber and Liangjian Wen and U. Wichoski and Gerrit Wrede and Sen Wu and Q. Xia and D. R. Yahne and L. Yang and Y.-R. Yen and O. Zeldovich},
  title = {{Measurement of the scintillation and ionization response of liquid xenon at MeV energies in the EXO-200 experiment}},
  journal = {Physical Review. C},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevc.101.065501},
}
Figure