Measurement of the cosmic ray and neutrino-induced muon flux at the Sudbury neutrino observatory

B. Aharmim, S. N. Ahmed, Thomas Andersen, A. E. Anthony, N. Barros, R. Bayes, A. Bellerive, B. Beltrán, M. Bergevin, S. D. Biller, K. Boudjemline, M. G. Boulay, T. H. Burritt, B. Cai, Y. D. Chan, M. Chen, M. C. Chon, B. T. Cleveland, G.a. Cox-Mobrand, C. Currat, X. Dai, F. Dalnoki‐Veress, Huiqiu Deng, J. A. Detwiler, P. J. Doe, R.s. Dosanjh, G. Doucas, P.‐l. Drouin, F. A. Duncan, M. Dunford, S. R. Elliott, H. C. Evans, G. T. Ewan, J. Farine, H. Fergani, F. Fleurot, R. Ford, J. A. Formaggio, N. Gagnon, J. T. M. Goon, K. Graham, D. R. Grant, E. Guillian, S. Habib, R. L. Hahn, A. L. Hallin, E. D. Hallman, C. K. Hargrove, P. J. Harvey, R. Hazama, K. M. Heeger, W. J. Heintzelman, J. Heise, R. L. Helmer, R.j. Hemingway, R. Henning, A. Hime, C. Howard, M. A. Howe, M. Huang, B. Jamieson, N.a. Jelley, J. R. Klein, M. Kos, A. Krüger, C. Kraus, C. B. Krauss, T. Kutter, Christopher C. M. Kyba, R. Lange, J. Law, I. Lawson, K. T. Lesko, J. R. Leslie, I. Levine, J. C. Loach, S. Luoma, R. MacLellan, Steve Majerus, H.‐b. Mak, J. Maneira, A. D. Marino, R. D. Martin, N. McCauley, A. B. McDonald, S. McGee, C. Mifflin, M. L. Miller, B. Monreal, J. Monroe, A. J. Noble, N. S. Oblath, C. Okada, H. M. O’Keeffe, Y. P. Opachich, G. D. Orebi Gann, S. M. Oser, R. A. Ott, S. J. M. Peeters, A. W. P. PoonPhysical 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports the first measurement of the atmospheric neutrino-induced muon flux at SNO with minimized neutrino oscillation effects. The measured flux is 1.22 ± 0.09 times the Bartol prediction, and the zenith distribution is consistent with known neutrino oscillation parameters. This work provides a crucial benchmark for understanding atmospheric neutrino fluxes and their interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atmospheric neutrinos, produced by cosmic ray interactions in Earth's atmosphere, are a fundamental probe of particle physics, particularly neutrino oscillations. However, precisely measuring their flux and understanding their interactions with matter is challenging. High-energy muons generated by these neutrinos are a key observable. The challenge lies in distinguishing these neutrino-induced muons from the much more abundant cosmic-ray muons, especially at large zenith angles. Furthermore, understanding how neutrino oscillations affect the flux as it travels through the Earth is crucial. This paper aims to measure the flux of muons produced by atmospheric neutrinos, particularly in a regime where neutrino oscillations are minimized, and to compare this measurement to theoretical predictions.

Methods

The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO), located deep underground, was used to detect through-going muons. The deep location (2 km) significantly attenuates cosmic-ray muons, allowing for the detection of less frequent neutrino-induced muons. The experiment utilized a sophisticated event reconstruction algorithm to determine the muon's trajectory and energy. A key aspect of the analysis was the use of a Monte Carlo simulation (NUANCE and PROPMU) to model neutrino interactions, muon propagation, and detector response. This simulation was crucial for distinguishing between neutrino-induced muons and residual cosmic-ray muons, as well as for understanding detector efficiencies. The analysis involved a "blind" data-taking and analysis procedure to minimize biases. The zenith angle distribution of the detected muons was analyzed to extract the flux normalization and to test neutrino oscillation parameters.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this analysis consists of 1229.30 days of data collected by the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO) across its three operational phases. This data was used to identify and reconstruct muon events. For comparison and simulation, Monte Carlo datasets were generated using the NUANCE neutrino event generator and the PROPMU muon transport code. Additionally, the analysis references and compares its results with data from other experiments like LVD and MACRO for cosmic-ray muon flux measurements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Minimizing Oscillation Effects: By focusing on muons with zenith angles where neutrino oscillations are less pronounced (specifically, the region where neutrino oscillations are minimized), SNO provides a more direct measurement of the initial atmospheric neutrino flux.
  • Flux Normalization Discrepancy: The measured flux normalization of neutrino-induced muons is found to be 1.22 ± 0.09 times the Bartol prediction. While consistent within uncertainties, this suggests a potential refinement needed in atmospheric neutrino flux models.
  • Consistency with Oscillation Parameters: Despite measuring in a region where oscillations are minimized, the zenith distribution of the detected muons is consistent with previously established atmospheric neutrino oscillation parameters, validating the overall understanding of neutrino behavior.
  • Cosmic Ray Muon Flux Measurement: The experiment also provides a precise measurement of the cosmic-ray muon flux at SNO's depth, serving as a valuable benchmark for understanding background processes.

Key Results

  • Neutrino-Induced Muon Flux: The measured flux normalization is 1.22 ± 0.09 times the Bartol prediction.
  • Cosmic Ray Muon Flux: The cosmic ray muon flux at SNO with zenith angle cos θzenith > 0.4 is measured to be (3.31 ± 0.01 (stat.) ± 0.09 (sys.)) × 10⁻¹⁰ μ/s/cm².
  • Zenith Distribution: The observed zenith distribution of neutrino-induced muons is consistent with previously measured atmospheric neutrino oscillation parameters.
  • Exposure: The analysis covers a total exposure of 2.30 × 10¹⁴ cm² s, with 514 muon-like events measured in the relevant zenith angle range (-1 ≤ cos θzenith ≤ 0.4).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Systematic Uncertainties: While statistical errors are significant, systematic uncertainties in detector modeling, cross-section models, and muon propagation contribute to the overall error budget. The paper details these uncertainties extensively.
  • Model Dependence: The interpretation of the flux normalization relies on the Bartol atmospheric neutrino flux model and the NUANCE cross-section model. Future work could involve comparing results with alternative models.
  • Future Constraints: The paper suggests that this data can be used to further constrain atmospheric neutrino oscillation models and improve our understanding of neutrino physics. The consistency with existing oscillation parameters indicates that SNO's measurements are robust and can contribute to more precise global fits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Results are reported on the measurement of the atmospheric neutrino-induced muon flux at a depth of 2 kilometers below the Earth's surface from 1229 days of operation of the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO). By measuring the flux of through-going muons as a function of zenith angle, the SNO experiment can distinguish between the oscillated and unoscillated portion of the neutrino flux. A total of 514 muonlike events are measured between $\ensuremath{-}1\ensuremath{\le}\mathrm{cos}{\ensuremath{\theta}}_{\mathrm{zenith}}\ensuremath{\le}0.4$ in a total exposure of $2.30\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{14}\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}\text{ }\mathrm{s}$. The measured flux normalization is $1.22\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.09$ times the Bartol three-dimensional flux prediction. This is the first measurement of the neutrino-induced flux where neutrino oscillations are minimized. The zenith distribution is consistent with previously measured atmospheric neutrino oscillation parameters. The cosmic ray muon flux at SNO with zenith angle $\mathrm{cos}{\ensuremath{\theta}}_{\mathrm{zenith}}>0.4$ is measured to be $(3.31\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.01(\mathrm{stat})\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.09(\mathrm{sys}))\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}10}\text{ }\text{ }\ensuremath{\mu}/\mathrm{s}/{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aharmim2009measurement,
  author = {B. Aharmim and S. N. Ahmed and Thomas Andersen and A. E. Anthony and N. Barros and R. Bayes and A. Bellerive and B. Beltrán and M. Bergevin and S. D. Biller and K. Boudjemline and M. G. Boulay and T. H. Burritt and B. Cai and Y. D. Chan and M. Chen and M. C. Chon and B. T. Cleveland and G.A. Cox-Mobrand and C. Currat and X. Dai and F. Dalnoki‐Veress and Huiqiu Deng and J. A. Detwiler and P. J. Doe and R.S. Dosanjh and G. Doucas and P.‐L. Drouin and F. A. Duncan and M. Dunford and S. R. Elliott and H. C. Evans and G. T. Ewan and J. Farine and H. Fergani and F. Fleurot and R. Ford and J. A. Formaggio and N. Gagnon and J. T. M. Goon and K. Graham and D. R. Grant and E. Guillian and S. Habib and R. L. Hahn and A. L. Hallin and E. D. Hallman and C. K. Hargrove and P. J. Harvey and R. Hazama and K. M. Heeger and W. J. Heintzelman and J. Heise and R. L. Helmer and R.J. Hemingway and R. Henning and A. Hime and C. Howard and M. A. Howe and M. Huang and B. Jamieson and N.A. Jelley and J. R. Klein and M. Kos and A. Krüger and C. Kraus and C. B. Krauss and T. Kutter and Christopher C. M. Kyba and R. Lange and J. Law and I. Lawson and K. T. Lesko and J. R. Leslie and I. Levine and J. C. Loach and S. Luoma and R. MacLellan and Steve Majerus and H.‐B. Mak and J. Maneira and A. D. Marino and R. D. Martin and N. McCauley and A. B. McDonald and S. McGee and C. Mifflin and M. L. Miller and B. Monreal and J. Monroe and A. J. Noble and N. S. Oblath and C. Okada and H. M. O’Keeffe and Y. P. Opachich and G. D. Orebi Gann and S. M. Oser and R. A. Ott and S. J. M. Peeters and A. W. P. Poon},
  title = {{Measurement of the cosmic ray and neutrino-induced muon flux at the Sudbury neutrino observatory}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.80.012001},
}
Figure