Measurement of Radial Elasticity and Original Height of DNA Duplex Using Tapping-Mode Atomic Force Microscopy

Longhai Li, Xu Zhang, Hongfei Wang, Qian Lang, Haitao Chen, Lianqing LiuNanomaterials 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Assumption-Calculation Method" (ACM) using tapping-mode Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) to accurately measure the radial elasticity and original height of DNA duplexes. This method overcomes previous limitations in precisely locating and measuring such small nanomaterials, providing valuable insights into their mechanical properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Measuring the mechanical properties of one-dimensional nanomaterials like DNA duplexes presents significant challenges. Traditional AFM techniques, while effective for larger structures, struggle with the small size of DNA. Issues like thermal drift and the non-linearity of AFM piezoelectric actuators make it difficult to precisely position the AFM tip on the tiny DNA strands. This precision is crucial for accurate force-distance curve measurements, which are commonly used to determine elasticity. Consequently, obtaining reliable radial Young's modulus data for DNA has been problematic, hindering a deeper understanding of its role in nanostructures and devices.

Methods

The core innovation is the Assumption-Calculation Method (ACM). This iterative approach combines physical modeling with experimental AFM data.

  1. Assumption: The Young's modulus of the DNA duplex is initially assumed within a plausible range.
  2. Simulation: Using a point-mass model for the AFM tip and the Derjaguin-Müller-Toporov (DMT) model for tip-sample interactions, the authors simulate the tapping force and resulting sample indentation for various assumed Young's moduli. This simulation is performed using MATLAB.
  3. Experiment: Tapping-mode AFM is used to image DNA duplexes on a mica surface. Crucially, the method avoids the need for exact tip placement on the sample by scanning multiple images with varying free and set-point amplitudes. The measured height of the DNA duplex is recorded.
  4. Calculation: The simulated tapping force and the experimentally measured height (corrected for indentation) are used to calculate an "effective" Young's modulus (Ec) via the DMT model.
  5. Iteration: The calculated Young's modulus (Ec) is compared to the assumed Young's modulus (Ea). If they don't match, the process repeats with a new assumed Young's modulus. The iteration continues until Ea = Ec, at which point the assumed value is considered the true radial Young's modulus of the DNA duplex.

This method also allows for the calculation of the original height of the DNA duplex by compensating for the indentation caused by the tapping force.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental AFM imaging of DNA duplexes prepared in the lab.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Overcoming Precision Limitations: The ACM effectively bypasses the need for exact tip placement on the DNA duplex by utilizing scanning over multiple amplitudes. This is a significant advantage for measuring ultra-small nanomaterials.
  • Combined Simulation and Experiment: The synergy between physical modeling (DMT and point-mass models) and experimental AFM data allows for a robust determination of mechanical properties.
  • Radial Elasticity Measurement: The method specifically targets and successfully measures the radial Young's modulus, which is more challenging to obtain than axial elasticity.
  • Original Height Determination: The approach not only measures elasticity but also accurately determines the DNA duplex's original height by accounting for tip-induced deformation.

Key Results

  • The radial compressive Young's modulus of DNA duplexes was determined to be 125–150 MPa.
  • This measurement was achieved under a tapping force range of 0.5–1.3 nN.
  • The original height of the DNA duplex was calculated to be approximately 1.9 nm. This is slightly smaller than theoretical values, potentially due to electrostatic forces with the mica surface.
  • The method demonstrated effectiveness in characterizing materials that are difficult to measure with traditional force-curve AFM.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Comparison to Other Studies: The measured stiffness is higher than some previous studies (5–30 MPa), which the authors attribute to the use of stronger acting forces in their experiments and potentially a stronger substrate effect from the mica surface.
  • Pico-Newton Scale Forces: Measuring at pico-newton scale tapping forces is challenging due to the difficulty in obtaining quality AFM images. Multi-harmonic AFM is suggested as a potential alternative for such low-force measurements.
  • Soft Nanomaterials Suitability: The approach is noted as being more suitable for soft nanomaterials, as the measured height of hard materials might not change significantly under varying tapping forces.
  • Future Applications: The authors suggest that this method is simpler and applicable to the measurement of other nanomaterials, opening avenues for characterizing a wider range of nanoscale mechanical properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) can characterize nanomaterial elasticity. However, some one-dimensional nanomaterials, such as DNA, are too small to locate with an AFM tip because of thermal drift and the nonlinearity of piezoelectric actuators. In this study, we propose a novel approach to address the shortcomings of AFM and obtain the radial Young's modulus of a DNA duplex. The elastic properties are evaluated by combining physical calculations and measured experimental results. The initial elasticity of the DNA is first assumed; based on tapping-mode scanning images and tip⁻sample interaction force simulations, the calculated elastic modulus is extracted. By minimizing the error between the assumed and experimental values, the extracted elasticity is assigned as the actual modulus for the material. Furthermore, tapping-mode image scanning avoids the necessity of locating the probe exactly on the target sample. In addition to elasticity measurements, the deformation caused by the tapping force from the AFM tip is compensated and the original height of the DNA is calculated. The results show that the radial compressive Young's modulus of DNA is 125⁻150 MPa under a tapping force of 0.5⁻1.3 nN; its original height is 1.9 nm. This approach can be applied to the measurement of other nanomaterials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019measurement,
  author = {Longhai Li and Xu Zhang and Hongfei Wang and Qian Lang and Haitao Chen and Lianqing Liu},
  title = {{Measurement of Radial Elasticity and Original Height of DNA Duplex Using Tapping-Mode Atomic Force Microscopy}},
  booktitle = {Nanomaterials},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/nano9040561},
}
Figure