Measurement of cross sections for D0D¯0 and D+D−D+D− production in e+e−e+e− annihilation at s=3.773 GeV

F. De Mori, J. Z. Bai, Y. Ban, J. G. Bian, X. Cai, J. F. Chang, H.f. Chen, H.s. Chen, H.x. Chen, J.c. Chen, Jin Chen, Jun Chen, Meixia Chen, Y.b. Chen, S.p. Chi, Y. P. Chu, X. Z. Cui, H. L. Dai, Y. S. Dai, Z. Y. Deng, L. Y. Dong, S. X. Du, Zhaocheng Du, Fang Ji, S. S. Fang, C. D. Fu, H. Y. Fu, C. S. Gao, Ya Gao, Ming Gong, W. X. Gong, S. Gu, Yuanyuan Guo, Yi-Qing Guo, K. L. He, M. He, Xiang He, Y. K. Heng, H. Hu, T. Hu, L. Huang, X. P. Huang, X. B. Ji, Qing Jia, Chen Jiang, X. S. Jiang, D. P. Jin, S. Jin, Y. Jin, Y.f. Lai, F. Li, G. Li, H.h. Li, J. Li, Q.j. Li, R.b. Li, R.y. Li, S.m. Li, X.l. Li, X.q. Li, XinYu Li, Liang Yu, H. Liao, C.x. Liu, Fei Liu, Fang Liu, H.m. Liu, J.b. Liu, J.p. Liu, R.g. Liu, Z.a. Liu, Zhengyang Liu, F. Lu, G.r. Lu, J. G. Lu, C.l. Luo, X. L. Luo, F.c. Ma, Xinhua Ma, L.l. Ma, Qiang Ma, Z. P. Mao, X. H. Mo, Jing Nie, Z. D. Nie, H. P. Peng, N. D. Qi, Chen Qian, H. Qin, J.f. Qiu, Zhanli Ren, G. Rong, L.y. Shan, Lianguang Shang, D. L. Shen, X. Y. Shen, H. Y. ShengPhysics 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports precise measurements of the cross sections for producing pairs of charm mesons ($D^0\bar{D}^0$ and $D^+D^-$) in electron-positron collisions at a specific energy (3.773 GeV). These measurements are crucial for understanding the properties of the $\psi(3770)$ resonance and for refining theoretical models of particle physics, particularly in the context of the Standard Model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the behavior of fundamental particles and their interactions is a cornerstone of modern physics. At energies around 3.773 GeV, electron-positron collisions are dominated by the production of the $\psi(3770)$ resonance, a state composed of charm quarks. This resonance is known to decay into pairs of charm mesons, specifically $D^0\bar{D}^0$ and $D^+D^-$. Precisely measuring the rates (cross sections) at which these charm meson pairs are produced is vital for several reasons:

  1. Probing the $\psi(3770)$ resonance: The decay patterns and production rates of the $\psi(3770)$ provide key insights into its internal structure and how it interacts.
  2. Testing theoretical models: Various theoretical models predict these cross sections. Accurate experimental measurements serve as crucial benchmarks to validate or refine these models.
  3. Determining fundamental parameters: These measurements can help determine fundamental parameters of the Standard Model, such as the total hadronic cross section, which is important for understanding phenomena like vacuum polarization.
  4. Investigating charm physics: The study of charm mesons is a significant area in particle physics, and precise measurements at specific energy points contribute to a broader understanding of the charm sector.

The challenge lies in accurately identifying and counting these specific particle decays within the complex environment of a particle collider experiment.

Methods

The researchers utilized data collected by the Beijing Spectrometer (BES-II) detector at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPC). The core of their method involved:

  • Data Collection: They analyzed a dataset corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 17.3 pb⁻¹ collected at a center-of-mass energy ($\sqrt{s}$) of 3.773 GeV.
  • Charm Meson Reconstruction: Charm mesons ($D^0$ and $D^+$) were identified by reconstructing their decay products. Specifically, they looked for final states involving kaons and pions, such as $K^-\pi^+$ for $D^0$ and $K^-\pi^+\pi^+$ for $D^+$.
  • Kinematic Fitting: To improve the precision of their measurements, they employed a kinematic fit. This technique uses the measured momenta of the decay particles and the known properties of the mesons to refine their reconstructed properties, leading to better signal-to-noise ratios and improved mass resolution.
  • Singly Tagged Events: The analysis focused on "singly tagged" events, meaning they identified one of the two produced charm mesons and used its properties to infer the presence of its partner.
  • Radiative Corrections: A crucial step was applying radiative corrections. Electron-positron collisions are not perfectly monochromatic; particles can emit photons (Bremsstrahlung) before annihilating, effectively reducing the collision energy. The observed cross sections were corrected for these initial state radiation (ISR) effects to obtain the "tree-level" cross sections, representing the fundamental interaction without these energy-reducing effects.
  • Background Subtraction and Fitting: Standard techniques involving maximum likelihood fits were used to separate the signal (charm meson decays) from background noise, employing Gaussian functions for signals and specialized functions for background.

Datasets

  • Experimental Data: The primary dataset used was collected by the BES-II detector at the BEPC, with a total integrated luminosity of 17.3 pb⁻¹. This data was specifically collected at a center-of-mass energy of $\sqrt{s} = 3.773$ GeV.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: Monte Carlo simulations were extensively used to estimate the efficiency of reconstructing different decay modes of the charm mesons and to understand detector effects. These simulations were generated using a GEANT-based package.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Precision Charm Production Measurement: The paper provides some of the most precise measurements to date for $D^0\bar{D}^0$ and $D^+D^-$ production cross sections at $\sqrt{s} = 3.773$ GeV. This level of precision is essential for discriminating between theoretical models.
  • Refining $\psi(3770)$ Understanding: The results offer direct experimental input for understanding the decay properties of the $\psi(3770)$ resonance, particularly its exclusive decays into $D\bar{D}$ pairs.
  • Contribution to Hadronic Cross Section: By combining the $D\bar{D}$ cross sections with extrapolations of other hadronic cross sections, the paper contributes to a more accurate determination of the total tree-level hadronic cross section. This is a fundamental quantity in particle physics, impacting calculations for phenomena like vacuum polarization.
  • Discrepancy with Theoretical Models: The measured tree-level cross sections for $D\bar{D}$ production were found to be approximately 2.5 times larger than predictions from a coupled-channel model. This significant difference highlights areas where theoretical models may need revision or where new physics might be at play.

Key Results

  • Observed Cross Sections:
    • $D^0\bar{D}^0$: $\sigma_{obs}^{D^0\bar{D}^0} = (3.58 \pm 0.09 \pm 0.31)$ nb
    • $D^+D^-$: $\sigma_{obs}^{D^+D^-} = (2.56 \pm 0.08 \pm 0.26)$ nb
    • Total $D\bar{D}$: $\sigma_{obs}^{D\bar{D}} = (6.14 \pm 0.12 \pm 0.50)$ nb
  • Tree-Level Cross Sections (after radiative corrections):
    • $D^0\bar{D}^0$: $\sigma_{tree}^{D^0\bar{D}^0} = (4.60 \pm 0.12 \pm 0.45)$ nb
    • $D^+D^-$: $\sigma_{tree}^{D^+D^-} = (3.29 \pm 0.10 \pm 0.37)$ nb
    • Total $D\bar{D}$: $\sigma_{tree}^{D\bar{D}} = (7.88 \pm 0.15 \pm 0.74)$ nb
  • Total Hadronic Cross Section ($R$): The paper reports $R = 3.55 \pm 0.03 \pm 0.18$ at $\sqrt{s} = 3.773$ GeV, derived from their $D\bar{D}$ measurements and other hadronic contributions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical Model Discrepancy: The most significant limitation highlighted is the substantial difference between the experimental results and the predictions of the coupled-channel model. This suggests that the model may not fully capture all relevant physics at this energy.
  • Systematic Uncertainties: While statistical errors are relatively small, systematic uncertainties (e.g., from luminosity, tracking, particle identification, and fitting parameters) contribute significantly to the overall precision. Further improvements in detector calibration and analysis techniques could reduce these.
  • Future Work: The authors implicitly suggest that further theoretical work is needed to reconcile the discrepancies observed. Additionally, continued data collection and analysis at this and other energy points will refine our understanding of charm physics and the Standard Model. The paper also mentions the importance of these measurements for understanding vacuum polarization effects, indicating that these results will be integrated into broader theoretical calculations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The cross sections for D0D¯0 and D+D− production at 3.773 GeV have been measured with BES-II detector at BEPC. These measurements are made by analyzing a data sample of about 17.3 pb−1 collected at the center-of-mass energy of 3.773 GeV. Observed cross sections for the charm pair production are radiatively corrected to obtain the tree level cross section for DD¯ production. A measurement of the total tree level hadronic cross section is obtained from the tree level DD¯ cross section and an extrapolation of the Ruds below the open charm threshold.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mori2004measurement,
  author = {F. De Mori and J. Z. Bai and Y. Ban and J. G. Bian and X. Cai and J. F. Chang and H.F. Chen and H.S. Chen and H.X. Chen and J.C. Chen and Jin Chen and Jun Chen and Meixia Chen and Y.B. Chen and S.P. Chi and Y. P. Chu and X. Z. Cui and H. L. Dai and Y. S. Dai and Z. Y. Deng and L. Y. Dong and S. X. Du and Zhaocheng Du and Fang Ji and S. S. Fang and C. D. Fu and H. Y. Fu and C. S. Gao and Ya Gao and Ming Gong and W. X. Gong and S. Gu and Yuanyuan Guo and Yi-Qing Guo and K. L. He and M. He and Xiang He and Y. K. Heng and H. Hu and T. Hu and L. Huang and X. P. Huang and X. B. Ji and Qing Jia and Chen Jiang and X. S. Jiang and D. P. Jin and S. Jin and Y. Jin and Y.F. Lai and F. Li and G. Li and H.H. Li and J. Li and J.C. Li and Q.J. Li and R.B. Li and R.Y. Li and S.M. Li and W. G. Li and X.L. Li and X.Q. Li and XinYu Li and Liang Yu and H. Liao and C.X. Liu and Fei Liu and Fang Liu and H.M. Liu and J.B. Liu and J.P. Liu and R.G. Liu and Z.A. Liu and Zhengyang Liu and F. Lu and G.R. Lu and J. G. Lu and C.L. Luo and X. L. Luo and F.C. Ma and Xinhua Ma and L.L. Ma and Qiang Ma and X. Y. Ma and Z. P. Mao and X. H. Mo and Jing Nie and Z. D. Nie and H. P. Peng and N. D. Qi and Chen Qian and H. Qin and J.F. Qiu and Zhanli Ren and G. Rong and L.Y. Shan and Lianguang Shang and D. L. Shen and X. Y. Shen and H. Y. Sheng},
  title = {{Measurement of cross sections for D0D¯0 and D+D−D+D− production in e+e−e+e− annihilation at s=3.773 GeV}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2004.10.029},
}
Figure