Measurement of charm production cross sections in<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:msup><mml:mi>e</mml:mi><mml:mo>+</mml:mo></mml:msup><mml:msup><mml:mi>e</mml:mi><mml:mo>−</mml:mo></mml:msup></mml:math>annihilation at energies between 3.97 and 4.26 GeV

D. Cronin-Hennessy, K. Y. Gao, J. Hietala, Y. Kubota, T. Klein, B. W. Lang, R. Poling, A. W. Scott, P. Zweber, S. Dobbs, Z. Metreveli, K. K. Seth, A. Tomaradze, J. Libby, A. Powell, G. Wilkinson, K. M. Ecklund, W. A. Love, V. Savinov, A. Lopez, H. Méndez, J. E. Ramirez Vargas, Jun Ge, D. H. Miller, I. P. J. Shipsey, B. Xin, G. S. Adams, Mark Anderson, J. P. Cummings, I. Danko, D. Hu, B. Moziak, J. Napolitano, Q. He, J. Insler, H. Muramatsu, C. S. Park, E. H. Thorndike, F. Yang, M. Artuso, S. Blusk, S. Khalil, J. Li, R. Mountain, S. Nisar, K. Randrianarivony, N. Sultana, T. Skwarnicki, S. Stone, J. C. Wang, L. M. Zhang, G. Bonvicini, D. Cinabro, M. Dubrovin, A. Lincoln, J. H. Rademacker, D. M. Asner, K. W. Edwards, P. Naik, J. Reed, R. A. Briere, T. Ferguson, G. Tatishvili, H. Vogel, M. E. Watkins, J. L. Rosner, J. Alexander, D. G. Cassel, J. E. Duboscq, R. Ehrlich, L. Fields, L. Gibbons, R. Gray, S. W. Gray, D. L. Hartill, B. K. Heltsley, D. Hertz, C. D. Jones, J. Kandaswamy, D. L. Kreinick, В. Е. Кузнецов, H. Mahlke-Krüger, D. Mohapatra, P. U. E. Onyisi, T. Sanuki, D. Peterson, D. Riley, A. Rýd, A. J. Sadoff, X. Shi, S. Stroiney, W. Sun, T. Wilksen, S. B. Athar, R. Patel, J. Yelton, P. Rubin, B. I. Eisenstein, I. Karliner, S. MehrabyanPhysical 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the most precise measurements to date of charm meson production cross-sections in electron-positron collisions near the charm production threshold. These detailed measurements reveal the intricate structure of charm production, including the emergence of multi-body final states, and provide crucial data for understanding the nature of exotic charmonium states like the Y(4260).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the behavior of electron-positron annihilation into hadrons just above the charm production threshold has been a puzzle. While the total cross-section, denoted by R, shows interesting features like enhancements and plateaus, the precise composition of these features in terms of specific charm meson final states has been poorly understood. This lack of detailed knowledge hinders our ability to test theoretical models of quarkonium physics, understand the properties of exotic states (like hybrids and tetraquarks), and precisely measure fundamental parameters like CKM matrix elements. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing detailed measurements of exclusive and inclusive cross-sections for various charm meson final states in a critical energy region.

Methods

The CLEO-c detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring (CESR) was used to collect data at thirteen distinct center-of-mass energies between 3.97 and 4.26 GeV. The analysis involved identifying charm mesons ($D^0$, $D^+$, and $D_s^+$) through their decay products. For exclusive final states involving two charm mesons (e.g., $D^0\overline{D}^0$, $D^{*+}D^-$), candidates were selected based on their invariant mass and total energy. The momentum spectra of these candidates were then analyzed. For multi-body final states (where a charm meson pair is accompanied by a pion), missing mass techniques were employed to identify these events, as the ISR (Initial State Radiation) smearing of momenta made direct momentum analysis challenging. Cross-sections were determined by fitting the observed yields to Monte Carlo simulations, which incorporated detailed descriptions of production mechanisms, decay angular distributions, and ISR effects.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of $e^+e^-$ collision data collected by the CLEO-c detector at thirteen center-of-mass energies between 3.97 and 4.26 GeV. This dataset includes a total integrated luminosity of approximately 200 pb$^{-1}$, with a significant portion (178.9 pb$^{-1}$) collected at 4170 MeV for detailed analysis. The analysis also relied on Monte Carlo simulations generated using GEANT and EvtGen for modeling detector response and particle production/decay processes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emergence of Multi-body Production: A significant finding is the clear evidence for multi-body final states, such as $D^{(*)}D^{(*)}\pi$, which had not been previously observed in this energy region. This indicates that charm production is more complex than just two-body processes.
  • Structure Reflects Thresholds: The measured cross-sections for various two-body and multi-body final states exhibit distinct structures (peaks, plateaus, dips) that directly correspond to the opening of new production thresholds for different charm meson combinations.
  • No Y(4260) Enhancement in Open Charm: Crucially, no significant enhancement in any of the measured open-charm final states was observed at the energy of the Y(4260) resonance. This suggests that if the Y(4260) decays to open charm, it does so with a relatively small branching ratio compared to its decay to $J/\psi$ and pions.
  • Validation of Theoretical Models: The detailed cross-section measurements provide stringent tests for theoretical models of charmonium physics, including potential models and theories of exotic states.

Key Results

  • Measured inclusive and exclusive cross-sections for $D^+$, $D^0$, and $D_s^+$ meson production at thirteen energies between 3.97 and 4.26 GeV.
  • Exclusive cross-sections for two-charm-meson final states: $D\overline{D}$, $D^{*0}\overline{D}^0$, $D^{*0}\overline{D}^{*0}$, $D_s^+D_s^-$, $D_s^{*+}D_s^-$, and $D_s^{*+}D_s^{*-}$.
  • Exclusive cross-sections for multi-body final states: $D^{*0}D^0\pi$, $D^{*0}D^{*0}\pi$.
  • The total charm cross-section was measured and found to be consistent with previous measurements of R and the sum of exclusive cross-sections.
  • The data show excellent agreement with the updated potential model predictions of Eichten et al. for most two-charm-meson final states, with some notable exceptions (e.g., $D^{*0}\overline{D}^{*0}$).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the agreement between measured and predicted cross-sections is generally good, there are some discrepancies, particularly for the $D^{*0}\overline{D}^{*0}$ channel, where the measured cross-section exceeds predictions. The lack of obvious enhancement at the Y(4260) in open-charm channels, while informative, does not definitively rule out all exotic interpretations. Future experiments with higher statistics and improved precision are needed to further refine these measurements and potentially resolve remaining theoretical puzzles, especially concerning the nature of the Y(4260) and other potential new resonances. The paper also suggests that more definitive statements about hybrid charmonium and tetraquark proposals will require additional data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using the CLEO-c detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring, we have measured inclusive and exclusive cross sections for the production of ${D}^{+}$, ${D}^{0}$ and ${D}_{s}^{+}$ mesons in ${e}^{+}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}}$ annihilations at 13 center-of-mass energies between 3.97 and 4.26 GeV. Exclusive cross sections are presented for final states consisting of two charm mesons ($D\overline{D}$, ${D}^{*}\overline{D}$, ${D}^{*}{\overline{D}}^{*}$, ${D}_{s}^{+}{D}_{s}^{\ensuremath{-}}$, ${D}_{s}^{*+}{D}_{s}^{\ensuremath{-}}$, and ${D}_{s}^{*+}{D}_{s}^{*\ensuremath{-}}$) and for processes in which the charm-meson pair is accompanied by a pion. No enhancement in any final state is observed at the energy of the $Y(4260)$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{croninhennessy2009measurement,
  author = {D. Cronin-Hennessy and K. Y. Gao and J. Hietala and Y. Kubota and T. Klein and B. W. Lang and R. Poling and A. W. Scott and P. Zweber and S. Dobbs and Z. Metreveli and K. K. Seth and A. Tomaradze and J. Libby and A. Powell and G. Wilkinson and K. M. Ecklund and W. A. Love and V. Savinov and A. Lopez and H. Méndez and J. E. Ramirez Vargas and Jun Ge and D. H. Miller and I. P. J. Shipsey and B. Xin and G. S. Adams and Mark Anderson and J. P. Cummings and I. Danko and D. Hu and B. Moziak and J. Napolitano and Q. He and J. Insler and H. Muramatsu and C. S. Park and E. H. Thorndike and F. Yang and M. Artuso and S. Blusk and S. Khalil and J. Li and R. Mountain and S. Nisar and K. Randrianarivony and N. Sultana and T. Skwarnicki and S. Stone and J. C. Wang and L. M. Zhang and G. Bonvicini and D. Cinabro and M. Dubrovin and A. Lincoln and J. H. Rademacker and D. M. Asner and K. W. Edwards and P. Naik and J. Reed and R. A. Briere and T. Ferguson and G. Tatishvili and H. Vogel and M. E. Watkins and J. L. Rosner and J. Alexander and D. G. Cassel and J. E. Duboscq and R. Ehrlich and L. Fields and L. Gibbons and R. Gray and S. W. Gray and D. L. Hartill and B. K. Heltsley and D. Hertz and C. D. Jones and J. Kandaswamy and D. L. Kreinick and В. Е. Кузнецов and H. Mahlke-Krüger and D. Mohapatra and P. U. E. Onyisi and T. Sanuki and D. Peterson and D. Riley and A. Rýd and A. J. Sadoff and X. Shi and S. Stroiney and W. Sun and T. Wilksen and S. B. Athar and R. Patel and J. Yelton and P. Rubin and B. I. Eisenstein and I. Karliner and S. Mehrabyan},
  title = {{Measurement of charm production cross sections in<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:msup><mml:mi>e</mml:mi><mml:mo>+</mml:mo></mml:msup><mml:msup><mml:mi>e</mml:mi><mml:mo>−</mml:mo></mml:msup></mml:math>annihilation at energies between 3.97 and 4.26 GeV}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.80.072001},
}
Figure