Measurement of beauty and charm photoproduction using semi-muonic decays in dijet events at HERA

F. D. Aaron, C. Alexa, V. Andreev, S. Backović, A. Baghdasaryan, S. Baghdasaryan, E. Barrelet, W. Bartel, K. Begzsuren, A. Belousov, P. Belov, J.c. Bizot, V. Boudry, I. Božović-Jelisavčić, J. Braciník, O. Brandt, Martin Brinkmann, V. Brisson, D. Britzger, D. Bruncko, A. Bunyatyan, A. Bylinkin, L. Bystritskaya, Alan Campbell, K. B. Cantun Avila, F. Ceccopieri, K. Černý, V. Černý, V. Chekelian, J.g. Contreras, J. A. Coughlan, J. Cvach, J.b. Dainton, K. Daum, B. Delcourt, J. Delvax, E. A. De Wolf, C. Diaconu, M. Dobre, V. Dodonov, A. Dossanov, A. Dubak, G. Eckerlin, S. Egli, A. Eliseev, E. Elsen, L. Favart, A. Fedotov, R. Felst, J. Feltesse, J. Ferencei, D.-j. Fischer, M. Fleischer, A. Fomenko, E. Gabathuler, J. Gayler, S. Ghazaryan, A. Glazov, L. Goerlich, N. Gogitidze, M. Gouzevitch, C. Grab, A. Grebenyuk, T. Greenshaw, G. Grindhammer, S. Habib, D. Haidt, R. C. W. Henderson, E. Hennekemper, H. Henschel, M. Herbst, G. Herrera, M. Hildebrandt, K. H. Hiller, D. Hoffmann, R. Horisberger, T. Hreus, F. Huber, M. Jacquet, X. Janssen, L. Jönsson, H. Jung, M. Kapichine, I. R. Kenyon, C. Kiesling, M. Klein, C. Kleinwort, T. Kluge, R. Kogler, P. Kostka, Michael Krämer, J. Kretzschmar, K. Krüger, M. P. J. Landon, W. Lange, G. Laštovička-Medin, P. Laycock, A. Lebedev, V. Lendermann, S. LevonianThe European Physical Journal C 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents precise measurements of beauty and charm quark production in photoproduction events at the HERA collider. By analyzing dijet events with an associated muon, the H1 collaboration provides new data that tests fundamental predictions of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) in a challenging kinematic regime. The results generally agree with theoretical models, offering valuable insights into the complex interactions governing heavy quark production.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how heavy quarks (beauty and charm) are produced in high-energy collisions is crucial for testing and refining our understanding of the strong nuclear force, described by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). Photoproduction, where a photon acts as a projectile, is particularly interesting because it offers a unique way to probe the structure of the proton and the photon itself. However, precisely measuring these processes is challenging due to the complex final states involving multiple jets and the need to distinguish between different heavy quark flavors. This paper aims to provide precise measurements of beauty and charm photoproduction in a specific event topology (dijets with a muon) to test leading-order (LO) and next-to-leading order (NLO) QCD predictions.

Methods

The H1 collaboration employed a sophisticated analysis strategy:

  • Event Selection: They selected events with at least two jets, requiring specific transverse momentum and pseudorapidity ranges for these jets. A key requirement was the presence of a muon associated with one of the jets, with its own kinematic constraints. This selection aimed to isolate events originating from beauty and charm quark decays.
  • Flavor Separation: Distinguishing between beauty, charm, and lighter (uds) quarks was achieved using two primary variables:
  • Impact Parameter ($\delta$): The transverse distance of closest approach of the muon track to the interaction point. Beauty and charm quarks, due to their longer lifetimes, tend to produce muons with larger impact parameters.
  • Transverse Momentum ($P_T^{\mathrm{Prel}}$): The transverse momentum of the muon relative to the axis of its associated jet. This variable also helps differentiate between the heavy quark flavors. A binned likelihood fit was used to determine the fractions of beauty ($f_b$), charm ($f_c$), and light ($f_l$) quark events.

  • Cross Section Measurement: The measured cross sections were calculated by converting the fitted flavor fractions and the number of observed events into cross sections, taking into account the integrated luminosity. Differential cross sections were also measured as a function of various kinematic variables.

  • Theoretical Comparisons: The experimental results were compared to predictions from several Monte Carlo (MC) generators (PYTHIA, CASCADE, HERWIG) at leading order (LO) and a dedicated NLO calculation (MC@NLO).

Datasets

The analysis utilized data collected by the H1 detector at the HERA collider during the years 2006 and 2007. This dataset corresponds to an integrated luminosity of 179 pb⁻¹. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Impact Parameter as a Flavor Tag: The study highlights the power of the impact parameter of a muon track as a crucial tool for separating beauty and charm quark production from lighter quark contributions. This technique leverages the longer lifetimes of B and D hadrons.
  • Dijet Topology as a Probe: Focusing on dijet events provides a hard scale, which is essential for making precise predictions within the framework of perturbative QCD. The presence of two jets helps to constrain the kinematics of the heavy quark production process.
  • Agreement with QCD Predictions: A significant finding is the general agreement between the measured cross sections and both LO and NLO QCD predictions. This provides further validation for the theoretical models used to describe these complex interactions.
  • Sensitivity to Direct vs. Resolved Photons: By analyzing events in different regions defined by the variable $x_{y}^{\mathrm{obs}}$, the study could probe the contributions from direct photon processes (where the photon interacts directly) and resolved photon processes (where the photon acts as a source of partons).

Key Results

  • Total Cross Sections: The total visible measured beauty cross section was found to be $43.3 \pm 2.1 \text{ (stat.)} \pm 4.5 \text{ (sys.) pb}$, and for charm, it was $81.3 \pm 4.3 \text{ (stat.)} \pm 8.5 \text{ (sys.) pb}$.
  • Differential Cross Sections: The paper presents a comprehensive set of differential cross sections for both beauty and charm production as a function of muon transverse momentum ($P_T^\mu$), muon pseudorapidity ($\eta^\mu$), leading jet transverse momentum ($P_T^{\mathrm{jet}1}$), azimuthal angle difference between jets ($\Delta\phi^{\mathrm{jet}}$), and the photon's inelasticity ($y^{\mathrm{obs}}$).
  • Model Comparisons: While most models provide a reasonable description, the PYTHIA prediction showed the highest normalization for beauty, and MC@NLO predictions tended to be slightly underestimated by the data, though still within errors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Uncertainties: Despite the large luminosity, statistical uncertainties remain significant in some bins, particularly for the differential cross sections.
  • Theoretical Uncertainties: The theoretical predictions, especially from NLO calculations, still carry uncertainties related to scale choices and parton distribution functions.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that the precise measurements presented can be used to further constrain theoretical models and improve our understanding of heavy quark production in photoproduction. The extended phase space and improved detector understanding compared to previous analyses allow for more detailed tests of QCD. The study of distributions sensitive to higher-order corrections, like $\Delta\phi^{\mathrm{jet}}$, is also highlighted as a path for future investigations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Measurements of cross sections for beauty and charm events with dijets and a muon in the photoproduction regime at HERA are presented. The data were collected with the H1 detector and correspond to an integrated luminosity of 179 pb−1. Events with dijets of transverse momentum $P_{T}^{\mathrm{jet}1}> 7\ \mbox{GeV}$ and $P_{T}^{\mathrm{jet}2}> 6\ \mbox{GeV}$ in the pseudorapidity range −1.5<η jet<2.5 in the laboratory frame are selected in the kinematic region of photon virtuality Q 2<2.5 GeV2 and inelasticity 0.2<y<0.8. One of the two selected jets must be associated to a muon with $P_{T}^{\mu} > 2.5\ \mbox{GeV}$ in the pseudorapidity range −1.3<η μ <1.5. The fractions of beauty and charm events are determined using the impact parameters of the muon tracks with respect to the primary vertex and their transverse momentum relative to the axis of the associated jet. Both variables are reconstructed using the H1 vertex detector. The measurements are in agreement with QCD predictions at leading and next-to-leading order.
BibTeX
@article{aaron2012measurement,
  author = {F. D. Aaron and C. Alexa and V. Andreev and S. Backović and A. Baghdasaryan and S. Baghdasaryan and E. Barrelet and W. Bartel and K. Begzsuren and A. Belousov and P. Belov and J.C. Bizot and V. Boudry and I. Božović-Jelisavčić and J. Braciník and O. Brandt and Martin Brinkmann and V. Brisson and D. Britzger and D. Bruncko and A. Bunyatyan and A. Bylinkin and L. Bystritskaya and Alan Campbell and K. B. Cantun Avila and F. Ceccopieri and K. Černý and V. Černý and V. Chekelian and J.G. Contreras and J. A. Coughlan and J. Cvach and J.B. Dainton and K. Daum and B. Delcourt and J. Delvax and E. A. De Wolf and C. Diaconu and M. Dobre and V. Dodonov and A. Dossanov and A. Dubak and G. Eckerlin and S. Egli and A. Eliseev and E. Elsen and L. Favart and A. Fedotov and R. Felst and J. Feltesse and J. Ferencei and D.-J. Fischer and M. Fleischer and A. Fomenko and E. Gabathuler and J. Gayler and S. Ghazaryan and A. Glazov and L. Goerlich and N. Gogitidze and M. Gouzevitch and C. Grab and A. Grebenyuk and T. Greenshaw and G. Grindhammer and S. Habib and D. Haidt and R. C. W. Henderson and E. Hennekemper and H. Henschel and M. Herbst and G. Herrera and M. Hildebrandt and K. H. Hiller and D. Hoffmann and R. Horisberger and T. Hreus and F. Huber and M. Jacquet and X. Janssen and L. Jönsson and H. Jung and M. Kapichine and I. R. Kenyon and C. Kiesling and M. Klein and C. Kleinwort and T. Kluge and R. Kogler and P. Kostka and Michael Krämer and J. Kretzschmar and K. Krüger and M. P. J. Landon and W. Lange and G. Laštovička-Medin and P. Laycock and A. Lebedev and V. Lendermann and S. Levonian},
  title = {{Measurement of beauty and charm photoproduction using semi-muonic decays in dijet events at HERA}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-012-2047-5},
}
Figure