Abstract
Deep sea mining concerns the extraction of poly-metallic nodules, cobalt-rich crusts and sulphide deposits from the ocean floor. The exploitation of these resources will result in adverse ecological effects arising from the direct removal of the substrate and, potentially, from the formation of sediment plumes that could result in deposition of fine sediment on sensitive species or entrainment of sediment, chemicals and nutrients into over-lying waters. Hence, identifying the behaviour of deep-sea sediment plumes is important in designing mining operations that are ecologically acceptable. Here, we present the results of novel in situ deep sea plume experiments undertaken on the Tropic seamount, 300 nautical miles SSW of the Canary Islands. These plume experiments were accompanied by hydrographic and oceanographic field surveys and supported by detailed numerical modelling and high resolution video settling velocity measurements of the in situ sediment undertaken in the laboratory. The plume experiments involved the controlled formation of benthic sediment plumes and measurement of the plume sediment concentration at a specially designed lander placed at set distances from the plume origin. The experiments were used as the basis for validation of a numerical dispersion model, which was then used to predict the dispersion of plumes generated by full-scale mining. The results highlight that the extent of dispersion of benthic sediment plumes, resulting from mining operations, is significantly reduced by the effects of flocculation, background turbidity and internal tides. These considerations must be taken into account when evaluating the impact and extent of benthic sediment plumes.
Introduction
As global demand for critical metals like cobalt and copper intensifies, the prospect of deep-sea mining moves closer to reality. A primary environmental concern is the generation of benthic sediment plumes—clouds of fine silt kicked up by harvesting machinery. Historically, it was feared these particles could remain suspended for weeks, traveling great distances and smothering distant ecosystems. However, these concerns often stemmed from simplified models lacking real-world validation. This study addresses this gap by providing in situ measurements and validated modeling of plume behavior on a seamount.
Methodology
The research was centered on the Tropic Seamount, located approximately 1,000m deep in the Atlantic. The team employed a multi-faceted approach:
- Field Experiments: A Remotely Operated Vehicle (ROV) generated controlled sediment plumes at distances of 25m to 100m from a benthic lander.
- Instrumentation: The lander utilized Optical Backscatter Sensors (OBS) and Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers (ADCP) for real-time data. An Autonomous Underwater Vehicle (AUV) tracked plumes at a 1 km range.
- Laboratory Analysis: The LabSFLOC-2 video-imaging system measured the settling velocities of in situ sediment samples, accounting for particle clumping (flocculation).
- Numerical Modeling: TELEMAC-3D and SEDPLUME-RW models were used to simulate full-scale mining scenarios, with the field data serving as a critical validation set.
Results and Discussion
The study revealed that sediment plumes are significantly more localized than previously estimated, driven by three key factors:
- Flocculation: Fine sediments do not remain isolated. Biological agents and bacteria in seawater cause particles to form "flocs," which sink 10 to 100 times faster than individual silt grains. Mean settling velocities were measured at 10–11 mm/s.
- Internal Tides: On seamounts, rotational current patterns caused by internal tides help trap plumes near the summit, preventing wide-scale dispersal.
- Background Turbidity: At distances of roughly 1 km, plume concentrations typically fall below the ocean's natural background turbidity levels.
In simulated full-scale mining, the plume excursion was limited to approximately 1.4 km, with the vast majority of sediment settling within 100 meters of the source. The numerical model demonstrated a 51% accuracy in predicting mean concentrations, a high benchmark for such complex environments.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While these findings suggest a more contained physical footprint for mining activities, several questions remain. The study focused on short-term dynamics and did not address long-term sediment accumulation or the specific biological thresholds of deep-sea organisms. Furthermore, while benthic plumes appear localized, future research must investigate "mid-water" plumes resulting from discharge at the surface. Understanding these factors is essential for developing ecologically acceptable mining operations.
Summary updated