Meaning Holism and Indeterminacy of Reference in Ontologies (Extended Abstract)

Adrien Barton, Paul Fabry, Jean-François EthierIJCAI 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of meaning holism and reference indeterminacy in ontology engineering. It proposes a refined definition of "meaning" for ontology terms, arguing that meaning holism is less pervasive than previously thought when applied to formal ontologies, and suggests strategies to mitigate its remaining challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ontologies are crucial for enabling semantic interoperability, allowing different agents to share and understand the meaning of terms. However, the philosophical concept of "meaning holism" poses a significant threat to this endeavor. Meaning holism suggests that the meaning of any single term is interconnected with the meanings of all other terms in a language. If this were strictly true for ontologies, adding or altering even a single term could fundamentally change the meaning of every other term, rendering ontologies unstable and impractical for development and use.

Furthermore, the related concept of "indeterminacy of reference" complicates matters. This refers to the difficulty in definitively linking words to specific real-world entities, even when all parties agree on the statements made about those entities. This paper aims to clarify the extent to which these philosophical challenges impact ontology engineering and to propose ways to manage them.

Methods

The authors approach this problem by first defining what constitutes the "meaning" of a class term within an ontology. They distinguish between formal and natural language meanings, focusing on the former. Their proposed definition, termed "MEAN," defines the formal meaning of a class term as the collection of axioms expressing necessary conditions (including necessary and sufficient conditions) on that term, which are entailed by the ontology's "analytic theory" and are not logically reducible to simpler axioms.

They then analyze how this definition of meaning interacts with meaning holism. They argue that by restricting the definition of meaning to analytic statements and excluding logically reducible axioms, the pervasive interconnectedness suggested by traditional meaning holism is significantly reduced in the context of formal ontologies. They also explore how anchoring formal ontologies in natural language can help mitigate the related issue of reference indeterminacy, although they acknowledge it cannot fully resolve it.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Meaning Holism is Less Pervasive in Formal Ontologies: The paper argues that when "meaning" is defined as a set of non-logically reducible analytic necessary conditions (MEAN), meaning holism doesn't operate as systematically as the strong formulation (H) suggests. Changes to one term's meaning don't necessarily cascade to all other terms.
  • The Analytic/Synthetic Distinction is Key: The paper highlights the importance of distinguishing between analytic (truth determined by meaning) and synthetic (truth determined by empirical facts) statements in ontologies. This distinction is crucial for defining what constitutes the core meaning of a term.
  • Mitigation Strategies for Indeterminacy: While natural language definitions can help, the paper acknowledges that even natural languages are subject to reference indeterminacy. However, carefully chosen additional statements can partially alleviate this.
  • Primitiveness and Circularity Pose Challenges: The paper identifies "primitiveness" (terms without formal definitions) and "circularity" (terms defined in terms of each other) as specific challenges that can exacerbate indeterminacy of reference within ontologies.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results in the traditional sense, as it's a theoretical and philosophical exploration. However, its key "results" are conceptual:

  • A refined definition of "meaning" for ontology terms (MEAN) that limits the scope of meaning holism.
  • An argument that meaning holism, under this refined definition, is not as detrimental to ontology engineering as initially feared.
  • The identification of analytic statements as the core of a term's meaning, with synthetic statements serving more as heuristic tools.
  • The suggestion that the analytic/synthetic distinction, while often overlooked in practice, is a valuable tool for managing meaning in ontologies.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Scope of MEAN: They question whether their definition of meaning (MEAN) might still be too broad and suggest further restrictions, particularly for axioms like A SubClassOf (R only B).
  • Object Property Terms: The current analysis focuses on class terms. Future work is needed to adapt these concepts to object property terms in OWL.
  • Operationalizing Inferential Role: The paper suggests "inferential role" as a potential proxy for meaning, especially if analytic/synthetic distinctions are abandoned. Further research is needed to rigorously define and utilize this.
  • Natural Language Integration: The import of natural language statements in constraining ontologies needs further investigation.
  • Formal Frameworks: Exploring the implications of meaning holism and indeterminacy within more formal frameworks of ontology nature (e.g., intensions, collections of propositions) is suggested.
  • Error Handling: Investigating how to control for errors in expressing a term's intended meaning is also a future direction.
  • Semantic Web Impact: A crucial open question is whether the Semantic Web can be practically realized given these challenges of meaning holism.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{barton2025meaning,
  author = {Adrien Barton and Paul Fabry and Jean-François Ethier},
  title = {{Meaning Holism and Indeterminacy of Reference in Ontologies (Extended Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2025/1206},
}
Figure