Maximum intensity of rarefaction shock waves for dense gases

Alberto Guardone, Calin Zamfirescu, Piero ColonnaJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper identifies the specific conditions under which rarefaction shock waves (RSWs) in dense gases reach their maximum intensity. Understanding these conditions is crucial for experimentally verifying the existence of these "exotic" non-classical gasdynamic phenomena and for developing new technologies that leverage them.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The existence of non-classical gasdynamic phenomena, such as rarefaction shock waves (RSWs), in the single-phase vapor region of fluids is a long-standing question in fluid mechanics. These phenomena are predicted to occur in fluids with complex molecular structures, often referred to as Bethe-Zel'dovich-Thompson (BZT) fluids. However, the thermodynamic conditions under which these phenomena are physically possible are limited, suggesting that the intensity of RSWs should reach a maximum for any given fluid. Identifying these "maximum intensity" conditions is paramount for both experimental verification and for potential technical applications. This paper aims to precisely locate these conditions in terms of pressure jump, wave Mach number, and shock strength.

Methods

The authors employ a theoretical approach to derive analytical procedures for identifying the states that lead to maximum intensity RSWs. They start by using the simple van der Waals model to establish fundamental relationships. This involves analyzing the Rankine-Hugoniot relations, which govern shock wave behavior, and introducing the concept of the fundamental derivative of gasdynamics ($\Gamma$) to characterize the thermodynamic region where non-classical phenomena are admissible ($\Gamma < 0$).

The core of their method involves a multi-dimensional maximization problem to find the pre-shock states that yield the largest pressure difference, wave Mach number, and shock strength. They systematically reduce the dimensionality of this problem by leveraging the properties of RSWs, such as the double-sonic locus and the relationship between pre- and post-shock sonic conditions.

Finally, they validate their findings from the simplified van der Waals model by applying more complex and realistic multi-parameter equations of state (Stryjek-Vera-Peng-Robinson, Martin-Hou, and Span-Wagner) to specific siloxane and perfluorocarbon fluids.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical models and equations of state rather than experimental datasets for its core analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "sweet spot" for RSWs: The paper pinpoints specific thermodynamic states where RSWs achieve their maximum intensity, moving beyond simply identifying if they can exist.
  • Three distinct maxima: Maximum intensity isn't a single condition; it manifests as distinct maxima in pressure jump, wave Mach number, and shock strength, each originating from different pre-shock states.
  • Double-sonic locus is key for pressure jump: The maximum pressure difference across an RSW is found to occur when the wave connects states on the "double-sonic locus," where both pre- and post-shock conditions are sonic.
  • Molecular complexity matters: The intensity of RSWs is directly linked to the molecular complexity of the fluid. More complex fluids generally exhibit stronger and more intense RSWs.
  • Experimental relevance: The predicted maximum wave Mach number (around 1.026 for D6 siloxane) is within the capabilities of newly developed experimental setups, offering a concrete target for demonstrating the existence of RSWs.

Key Results

  • The study analytically derives conditions for maximum pressure jump, wave Mach number, and shock strength for RSWs.
  • For the simple van der Waals model, the maximum pressure difference is found to occur for a double-sonic shock originating from the state with the lowest possible entropy.
  • The maximum wave Mach number and shock strength are found to increase with increasing molecular complexity (represented by the number of active degrees of freedom, N, in the van der Waals model).
  • Using more advanced equations of state for siloxanes and perfluorocarbons, the authors confirm these qualitative trends.
  • For the siloxane fluid D6 (dodecamethylcyclohexasiloxane), the Span-Wagner equation of state predicts a maximum wave Mach number of approximately 1.026. This value is significant as it is achievable with current experimental technology.
  • The maximum pressure difference across an RSW, when analyzed with more complex models, does not monotonically depend on molecular complexity but shows a trend of increasing with decreasing $\Gamma_{min}$ (a measure of molecular complexity).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model dependence: The paper acknowledges that the predicted values of $\Gamma_{min}$ and consequently the RSW intensity can depend significantly on the chosen thermodynamic model.
  • Experimental verification: While the paper provides theoretical predictions, the ultimate proof of the existence and intensity of these RSWs relies on ongoing and future experimental work. The authors mention a newly built experimental setup designed to demonstrate RSWs in dense vapors, with initial states chosen based on the theory presented.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that further experimental investigations are needed to confirm their theoretical predictions. The results are directly applicable to the design of experiments and the development of technologies that might exploit non-classical gasdynamics, such as organic Rankine cycle turbines.

Summary updated

Abstract

Modern thermodynamic models indicate that fluids consisting of complex molecules may display non-classical gasdynamic phenomena such as rarefaction shock waves (RSWs) in the vapour phase. Since the thermodynamic region in which non-classical phenomena are physically admissible is finite in terms of pressure, density and temperature intervals, the intensity of RSWs is expected to exhibit a maximum for any given fluid. The identification of the operating conditions leading to the RSW with maximum intensity is of paramount importance for the experimental verification of the existence of non-classical phenomena in the vapour phase and for technical applications taking advantage of the peculiarities of the non-classical regime. This study investigates the conditions resulting in an RSW with maximum intensity in terms of pressure jump, wave Mach number and shock strength. The upstream state of the RSW with maximum pressure drop is found to be located along the double-sonic locus formed by the thermodynamic states associated with an RSW having both pre- and post-shock sonic conditions. Correspondingly, the maximum-Mach thermodynamic and maximum-strength loci locate the pre-shock states from which the RSW with the maximum wave Mach number and shock strength can originate. The qualitative results obtained with the simple van der Waals model are confirmed with the more complex Stryjek–Vera–Peng–Robinson, Martin–Hou and Span–Wagner equations of state for selected siloxane and perfluorocarbon fluids. Among siloxanes, which are arguably the best fluids for experiments aimed at the generation and measurement of an RSW, the state-of-the-art Span–Wagner multi-parameter equation of state predicts a maximum wave Mach number close to 1.026 for D 6 (dodecamethylcyclohexasiloxane, [O-Si-(CH 3 ) 2 ] 6 ). Such value is well within the capacity of the measurement system of a newly built experimental set-up aimed at the first-ever demonstration of the existence of RSWs in dense vapours.
BibTeX
@article{guardone2009maximum,
  author = {Alberto Guardone and Calin Zamfirescu and Piero Colonna},
  title = {{Maximum intensity of rarefaction shock waves for dense gases}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1017/s0022112009991716},
}
Figure