Maximum Gain Round Trips with Cost Constraints

Franz Graf, Hans-Peter Kriegel, Matthias SchubertarXiv 2011 · arXiv

Introduction

Traditional navigation systems are optimized for efficiency, typically finding the shortest or fastest path between two points. However, many real-world applications—ranging from leisure activities like planning a scenic hike to logistical operations like blood donation drives—require maximizing a "gain" (e.g., scenery, population reached) within a specific "cost" budget (e.g., distance, time). This paper addresses the Maximum Gain Round Trip Query (MGRQ), a problem that seeks the most rewarding circuit starting and ending at the same node within a fixed budget.

Problem Definition: Cost-Gain Networks

The authors model the environment as a cost-gain network where each edge has an associated cost and gain. A key distinction in this work is the focus on "ways" rather than "paths." In standard routing, paths are sequences of distinct nodes. In MGRQ, an optimal route might revisit nodes or edges—for instance, to reach a high-gain dead-end trail and return. This flexibility significantly expands the search space, making efficient pruning essential.

Algorithmic Approach

To solve MGRQ efficiently, the authors propose a framework centered on three pillars:

1. Pareto Dominance Pruning

The search space is managed by discarding "dominated" routes. A route $A$ is dominated by route $B$ if $B$ reaches the same node with lower cost and higher gain. By maintaining a Pareto front of non-dominated routes at each node, the algorithm focuses only on the most efficient trade-offs between cost and gain.

2. Redundancy Control

In many scenarios, gain should only be counted once per edge (e.g., you don't get "double" scenery by walking the same path twice). This "redundancy control" complicates pruning. A route with lower gain might be kept if it has visited fewer edges, potentially allowing it to collect more gain later. The authors introduce a sophisticated pruning lemma that incorporates set-based conditions on visited edges to ensure optimal routes are not prematurely discarded.

Figure 3: (a) Vector representation of edge sets for redundancy control and (b) Pareto dominance pruning in the cost-gain space.

Since a round trip must return to the start, the search can be split. The algorithm explores outgoing routes and incoming routes simultaneously from the start node. By "meeting in the middle" at half the cost budget ($\tau/2$), the number of explored nodes is drastically reduced compared to a unidirectional search.

Experimental Evaluation

The algorithms were tested on real-world spatial data from OpenStreetMap (OSM) for three diverse locations: Kirchsee (Germany), Jasper (Canada), and Grand Canyon Village (USA). Costs were defined by Euclidean distance, while gains were assigned based on road classifications (e.g., trails and residential streets provided higher gain than highways).

Key findings from the evaluation include:

  • Bidirectional search provides a massive speedup, enabling the calculation of complex 17km round trips in under a minute on standard hardware.
  • Pareto pruning is highly effective, often keeping the search space growth linear relative to the cost threshold.
  • Redundancy control, while computationally more expensive due to weaker pruning conditions, is necessary for realistic routing in hiking and tourism applications.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work provides a robust foundation for gain-maximizing round trips in spatial networks. Future improvements could include the development of $A^*$-style heuristics to guide the search more effectively or parallelization techniques to handle larger cost budgets and more extensive networks. While the current focus is on exact solutions, approximation algorithms may offer a path toward scaling these queries to continental-sized datasets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Searching for optimal ways in a network is an important task in multiple application areas such as social networks, co-citation graphs or road networks. In the majority of applications, each edge in a network is associated with a certain cost and an optimal way minimizes the cost while fulfilling a certain property, e.g connecting a start and a destination node. In this paper, we want to extend pure cost networks to so-called cost-gain networks. In this type of network, each edge is additionally associated with a certain gain. Thus, a way having a certain cost additionally provides a certain gain. In the following, we will discuss the problem of finding ways providing maximal gain while costing less than a certain budget. An application for this type of problem is the round trip problem of a traveler: Given a certain amount of time, which is the best round trip traversing the most scenic landscape or visiting the most important sights? In the following, we distinguish two cases of the problem. The first does not control any redundant edges and the second allows a more sophisticated handling of edges occurring more than once. To answer the maximum round trip queries on a given graph data set, we propose unidirectional and bidirectional search algorithms. Both types of algorithms are tested for the use case named above on real world spatial networks.
BibTeX
@misc{graf2011maximum,
  author = {Franz Graf and Hans-Peter Kriegel and Matthias Schubert},
  title = {{Maximum Gain Round Trips with Cost Constraints}},
  year = {2011},
  eprint = {1105.0830},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1105.0830},
}
Figure