Maximum entropy solution to ill-posed inverse problems with approximately known operator

Jean–Michel Loubes, Bruno Pelletier2014

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "approximate maximum entropy" (AMEM) method for solving ill-posed inverse problems where the underlying operator is not precisely known, only an approximation is available. The method is shown to converge to the true solution as both the operator approximation and the discretization become finer, offering a robust approach for real-world scenarios where perfect knowledge is unattainable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many scientific and engineering disciplines face "inverse problems," where we aim to infer an underlying cause (often a distribution or measure) from observed effects. A common formulation is reconstructing an unknown measure $\mu$ from noisy observations of its "generalized moments," which are integrals of the form $y = \int_X \Phi(x) d\mu(x)$, where $\Phi$ is an operator. These problems are often "ill-posed," meaning small errors in the data can lead to large errors in the reconstructed solution, making them difficult to solve reliably.

A standard approach to stabilize these problems is regularization, often by minimizing a functional that penalizes complex solutions. The "maximum entropy" principle is a popular choice for regularization, leading to solutions that are as "spread out" as possible given the data. However, a significant practical challenge arises when the operator $\Phi$ itself is not perfectly known but only an approximation $\Phi_m$ is available. This paper tackles this specific challenge: how to find a stable, maximum entropy solution when the operator is only approximately known.

Methods

The core of the paper is the introduction of the Approximate Maximum Entropy on the Mean (AMEM) estimate, denoted by $\hat{\mu}_{m,n}$. This estimate is constructed as a discrete measure on $n$ points, where $m$ indexes the approximation of the operator $\Phi$. The AMEM estimate is derived by minimizing a convex functional (related to the negative entropy) subject to a sequence of convex constraints that incorporate the approximate operator $\Phi_m$ and the observed data.

The authors leverage concepts from convex analysis and information theory, specifically using Laplace and log-Laplace transforms and entropic projections. The AMEM estimate is defined through a process involving I-projections onto convex sets. A key technical contribution is the characterization of these I-projections and the establishment of an equivalence between the AMEM estimate and the solution of a discrete inverse problem closely related to the original one. The paper then proves the convergence of the AMEM estimate to the true solution of the inverse problem as both the operator approximation ($m \to \infty$) and the discretization ($n \to \infty$) improve.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the theoretical development of a method for solving inverse problems, rather than its application to specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Handling Unknown Operators is Crucial: The paper highlights that in many real-world applications (like remote sensing), the operator is not precisely known. Developing methods that can handle approximate operators is therefore essential for practical success.
  • AMEM as a Robust Estimator: The AMEM estimate provides a principled way to incorporate both the uncertainty in the operator and the noise in the data into a maximum entropy framework.
  • Convergence Guarantees: A significant insight is the proof that the AMEM estimate converges to the true solution under mild assumptions. This provides strong theoretical backing for the method's reliability.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The paper connects theoretical concepts like entropic projections to a practical numerical estimate, offering a path for implementation.

Key Results

The main result is Theorem 3.1, which establishes the weak convergence of the AMEM estimate $\hat{\mu}_{m,n}$ to the true minimizer $\hat{\mu}$ of the maximum entropy functional, as $m \to \infty$ (improving operator approximation) and $n \to \infty$ (finer discretization). This convergence is proven under assumptions on the existence of a solution, the properties of the entropy functional, and the approximation of the operator. The paper also provides a characterization of the AMEM estimate and its relationship to I-projections, which is crucial for its computational implementation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The convergence proof relies on several assumptions, including the existence of a unique solution to the original problem and certain boundedness properties of the entropy functional. Relaxing these assumptions could lead to more general applicability.
  • Computational Complexity: While the paper provides a theoretical framework, the practical implementation details and computational cost of the AMEM estimate, especially for large $m$ and $n$, are not deeply explored.
  • Specific Applications: The paper mentions applications like remote sensing but does not present concrete numerical experiments or comparisons with existing methods on real data. Future work could involve applying the AMEM method to specific inverse problems and evaluating its performance against state-of-the-art techniques.
  • Non-linear Operators: The current work focuses on linear inverse problems. Extending the AMEM framework to handle non-linear operators would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the linear inverse problem of reconstructing an unknown finite measure µ from a noisy observation of a generalized moment of µ defined as the integral of a continuous and bounded operator Φ with respect to µ. Motivated by various applications, we focus on the case where the operator Φ is unknown; instead, only an approximation Φm to it is available. An approximate maximum entropy solution to the inverse problem is introduced in the form of a minimizer of a convex functional subject to a sequence of convex constraints. Under several assumptions on the convex functional, the convergence of the approximate solution is established. Index Terms — Maximum entropy, Inverse problems, Convex functionals. 1
BibTeX
@misc{loubes2014maximum,
  author = {Jean–Michel Loubes and Bruno Pelletier},
  title = {{Maximum entropy solution to ill-posed inverse problems with approximately known operator}},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure