Maximum Entropy Estimation via Gauss-LP Quadratures

Maxime Thély, Tobias Sutter, Peyman Mohajerin Esfahani, John LygerosIFAC-PapersOnLine 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approximation method for a class of parametric integration problems that arise in maximum entropy estimation. By combining an extension of Gauss quadratures with a convex clustering algorithm, they achieve computationally efficient approximations, particularly for complex domains and high-dimensional settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Estimating probability densities from limited moment information is a fundamental problem in many scientific fields. The maximum entropy (MaxEnt) principle offers a principled way to select a unique density by maximizing information entropy, but its direct computation often involves intractable infinite-dimensional optimization problems. While existing methods can reduce this to solving systems of nonlinear equations or finite-dimensional convex optimization problems, these still rely on evaluating multi-dimensional integrals, which is computationally challenging. This paper addresses the need for efficient numerical methods to tackle these integration challenges, especially when dealing with unusual domains or high-dimensional spaces.

Methods

The core of the proposed method lies in two key components:

  • Gauss-LP Quadratures: This approach extends traditional Gauss quadratures to handle multi-dimensional and non-standard domains. It leverages the idea of representing an integral as a finite sum of weighted function evaluations, where the weights and nodes are determined by solving a semi-infinite linear program (LP). The paper builds upon recent work that discretizes these infinite LPs into finite ones, making them solvable by standard LP solvers.
  • Convex Clustering Algorithm: To further reduce the computational cost, the authors employ a convex clustering algorithm. This algorithm, inspired by information theory and rate-distortion principles, effectively filters out the most important nodes from the quadrature set. This process is analogous to importance sampling, making it particularly effective in high-dimensional scenarios where traditional discretization methods become computationally prohibitive. The algorithm aims to find a sparse set of cluster centers that best represent the original quadrature nodes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical framework and applies it to a synthetic example problem.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The paper successfully connects the dual problem of maximum entropy estimation to a class of parametric integration problems that can be approximated using Gauss-LP quadratures.
  • Computational Efficiency through Sparsity: The convex clustering algorithm is crucial for reducing the number of function evaluations required. By identifying and keeping only the most informative nodes, it significantly speeds up the approximation process.
  • Controlling Approximation Accuracy: The parameter $\beta$ in the convex clustering algorithm directly controls the number of clusters (and thus the number of quadrature nodes), offering a tunable knob to balance computational cost and approximation accuracy.
  • Generalizability: The method is designed to handle unusual domains and multi-dimensional settings, which are often challenging for traditional numerical integration techniques.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of their approach through a two-dimensional example on a unit disc.

  • Sparse Quadratures: The initial Gauss-LP quadrature, before clustering, yields a sparse set of nodes (e.g., 28 nodes for 28 constraints).
  • Clustering Impact: The convex clustering algorithm successfully reduces the number of nodes (e.g., from 28 to 26, 27, or 25) while maintaining a good approximation of the maximum entropy distribution.
  • Entropy-Accuracy Trade-off: As the number of clusters ($k$) decreases (meaning more aggressive clustering), the computed entropy of the approximated distribution also decreases. The maximum entropy value is achieved when no clustering is applied ($k=n$). This highlights a clear trade-off between computational savings and the accuracy of the entropy estimate.
  • Approximation of Uniform Density: The method is shown to approximate the uniform density on the unit disc, which is the true maximum entropy distribution for that domain and moment constraints.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation Error Quantification: The authors acknowledge the need for a rigorous framework to quantify the approximation error introduced by the clustering approach.
  • Sparsity Phenomenon: Further investigation is needed to fully understand the sparsity phenomenon related to the choice of the $\beta$ parameter.
  • High-Dimensional Applications: The paper suggests applying the method to high-dimensional problems in systems biology, particularly for approximating chemical master equations using moment closure methods.
  • Comparison with Existing Methods: Future work will involve comparing the complexity and runtime of their approach with existing numerical schemes for maximum entropy estimation, such as Lasserre's SDE approach.
  • Broader Connections: The authors are interested in exploring the connection between their method and approximate dynamic programming for infinite-dimensional linear programs arising in Markov decision processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

<p>We present an approximation method to a class of parametric integration problems that naturally appear when solving the dual of the maximum entropy estimation problem. Our method builds up on a recent generalization of Gauss quadratures via an infinite-dimensional linear program, and utilizes a convex clustering algorithm to compute an approximate solution which requires reduced computational effort. It shows to be particularly appealing when looking at problems with unusual domains and in a multi-dimensional setting. As a proof of concept we apply our method to an example problem on the unit disc.</p>
BibTeX
@inproceedings{thely2017maximum,
  author = {Maxime Thély and Tobias Sutter and Peyman Mohajerin Esfahani and John Lygeros},
  title = {{Maximum Entropy Estimation via Gauss-LP Quadratures}},
  booktitle = {IFAC-PapersOnLine},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ifacol.2017.08.1977},
}
Figure