Maximising student preparation for clinical teaching placements

Amanda S. Barnard, Cathy Owen, Alexandra Tyson, Sarah R. MartinThe Clinical Teacher 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

Medical education is shifting towards community-based learning, but students often lack sufficient preparation for clinical skills. This study found that a specialized pre-placement workshop on performing Pap smears significantly boosted student confidence and competence, though it didn't lead to a statistically significant increase in the number of smears performed compared to untrained peers. This highlights the value of intensive, hands-on training for difficult clinical skills in preparing students for real-world practice.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The landscape of medical education is evolving, with a notable shift from traditional hospital-based training to more ambulatory and community-based clinical placements. This transition presents a challenge: ensuring that medical students are adequately prepared to maximize learning opportunities in these settings. Specifically, the paper addresses the gap in preparing students for "on-the-job" clinical skills that are difficult to teach and assess in a standardized way, using the Papanicolaou (Pap) smear as a case study. Graduating medical interns are expected to be competent in such skills, but research suggests shortfalls in student training and confidence, often linked to the number of opportunities to practice. The authors question the "unspecified experiences" students are assumed to gain and explore the effectiveness of targeted, intensive pre-placement training for these essential, yet challenging, clinical skills.

Methods

The study employed a mixed-methods approach to evaluate the impact of a specialized pre-placement teaching program. The core of the intervention was an intensive Pap smear skills workshop for third-year medical students. This workshop involved:

  • Gynaecological Teaching Associates (GTAs): Women trained to act as patients, providing real-time feedback to students.
  • Active Practice: Hands-on simulation of the Pap smear procedure on pelvic models.
  • Real-time Feedback: Immediate, constructive criticism from the GTAs.

Quantitative data was collected through pre- and post-workshop questionnaires assessing student confidence and comfort with intimate examinations and the use of a speculum. The primary outcome measure for clinical practice was the number of Pap smears completed, tracked via student clinical portfolios. Qualitative data was gathered through open-ended discussion board prompts, asking students about their practical application of learned skills, comparisons to their learning experience, and suggestions for improvement. A comparison group of students who did not receive the pre-placement training was used to assess the impact of the workshop.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from third-year medical students at the Australian National University (ANU) Medical School.

  • Workshop Students: A group of 48 students (21 long-term rural, 27 mixed urban/rural) who participated in the pre-placement Pap smear skills workshop.
  • Comparison Students: The remaining 32 third-year students who underwent routine orientation without specific pre-placement Pap smear training.

Data sources included:

  • Pre- and post-workshop questionnaires (n=48).
  • Student clinical portfolios detailing Pap smear and vaginal examination experience (n=70).
  • Discussion board responses from workshop students.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on evaluating an existing educational intervention.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Confidence is Key: The most striking insight is how much pre-placement training can boost student confidence and comfort with intimate examinations, even before they encounter real patients. This "getting over the initial hurdle" is crucial for enabling students to seize learning opportunities.
  • The Value of Simulated Practice: Using trained teaching associates provides a safe, controlled environment for students to practice a sensitive skill, receive immediate feedback, and build confidence without the pressure of a real clinical encounter.
  • "Hard-to-Learn" Skills Need Targeted Training: The study strongly suggests that skills like Pap smear performance, which are difficult to teach and assess in standard clinical settings, benefit immensely from intensive, specialized preparation.
  • Gender Dynamics in Practice: Interestingly, male students noted that their opportunities to perform Pap smears might be influenced by gender, suggesting systemic factors beyond individual training that impact skill acquisition.
  • The GP Introduction Matters: Even with excellent training, students highlighted the critical role of the General Practitioner (GP) in introducing them to patients and facilitating consent for procedures, underscoring the importance of the broader clinical environment.

Key Results

  • Confidence Boost: Post-workshop, students reported significantly higher confidence in using a speculum (p < 0.0001) and comfort with intimate examinations (p < 0.0001).
  • Qualitative Feedback: Students overwhelmingly praised the teaching associates for their expertise and feedback, finding the workshop "tremendously beneficial" and "much more comfortable" than learning on the job.
  • Pap Smear Completion: On average, trained students completed more Pap smears during their placement than untrained peers. However, this difference did not reach statistical significance.
  • Portfolio Data: 77% of students observed and 57% conducted a Pap smear. Workshop students, on average, observed more and completed more Pap smears than the comparison group, though the difference in completed smears was not statistically significant.
  • Persistent Gaps: Despite the intervention, seven students (across both groups) did not complete any more smears, highlighting that training alone isn't always sufficient without other contextual factors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Significance: The lack of statistical significance in the number of Pap smears completed between the groups is a notable limitation. This could be due to the sample size, the relatively short duration of the placement, or the influence of other factors not controlled for.
  • Demographic Data: The study acknowledges the shortfall of not collecting detailed demographic data (beyond urban/rural) for the students, which could have provided further insights into differential learning experiences.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: While the workshop was deemed popular and valuable, a formal cost-effectiveness analysis was not undertaken.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further study into the value of intensive clinical skills training for other "hard-to-learn" clinical skills. They also propose future research that could include a more formal cost-effectiveness analysis and explore the impact of systemic factors, such as the GP's role in patient consent, on skill acquisition.

Summary updated

Abstract

Students given pre-placement training praised their learning experience, and on average took more Pap smears during their placement than did their untrained peers. The difference, however, did not reach statistical significance. The pre-placement teaching workshop on a difficult skill was popular and worthy of further study regarding other challenging clinical skills.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{barnard2011maximising,
  author = {Amanda S. Barnard and Cathy Owen and Alexandra Tyson and Sarah R. Martin},
  title = {{Maximising student preparation for clinical teaching placements}},
  booktitle = {The Clinical Teacher},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1111/j.1743-498x.2011.00440.x},
}
Figure