Matter effects in active-sterile solar neutrino oscillations

C. Giunti, Yufeng LiPhysical 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The matter effects for solar neutrino oscillations are studied in a general scheme with an arbitrary number of sterile neutrinos, without any constraint on the mixing, assuming only a realistic hierarchy of neutrino squared-mass differences in which the smallest squared-mass difference is effective in solar neutrino oscillations. The validity of the analytic results are illustrated with a numerical solution of the evolution equation in three examples of the possible mixing matrix in the simplest case of four-neutrino mixing.

Introduction

In the standard model of particle physics, there are three "active" neutrinos ($\nu_e, \nu_\mu, \nu_\tau$). However, experimental anomalies from sources like the LSND and Gallium experiments hint at the existence of "sterile" neutrinos—hypothetical particles that do not participate in weak interactions. These particles would only be detectable through their mixing with active neutrinos, leading to unexpected flavor transitions or disappearances.

While the Mikheyev-Smirnov-Wolfenstein (MSW) effect describes matter-induced oscillations for active flavors within the Sun, incorporating an arbitrary number of sterile neutrinos typically introduces significant mathematical complexity. This paper, published by C. Giunti and Y.F. Li in 2009, provides a generalized analytic framework to address this, simplifying the multi-particle evolution into a manageable system.

Theoretical Framework

The authors utilize the natural hierarchy of neutrino masses to simplify the problem. By assuming that the mass difference relevant to solar oscillations ($\Delta m^2_{21}$) is significantly smaller than those associated with atmospheric or sterile oscillations, the high-frequency oscillations from heavier states can be averaged out.

This allows the full $N \times N$ evolution matrix to be truncated to an effective $2 \times 2$ system in the vacuum mass basis. Key to this derivation are the definitions of an effective mixing angle ($\xi$) and an effective matter potential ($A$). Unlike standard active-only models where neutral-current (NC) effects cancel out, sterile neutrinos are insensitive to NC interactions. This creates a potential difference that must be accounted for, which the authors successfully integrate into their effective parameters.

Solar Model and Parameters

To validate their framework, the authors utilize the BP04 Standard Solar Model. This model provides the necessary profiles for electron density ($N_e$) and the neutron-to-proton ratio throughout the solar interior.

Radial profiles of the hydrogen mass fraction ($X_H$), electron fraction ($Y_e$), and the ratio of neutral-to-charged current potentials ($-R_{NC}$) based on the BP04 Standard Solar Model.

The analytic derivation assumes that the ratio of neutral-to-charged current potentials ($R_{NC}$) is approximately constant. As shown in Figure 1, while $R_{NC}$ (plotted as $-R_{NC}$) does vary within the solar core ($r < 0.2$), numerical tests confirm that this variation has a negligible impact on the final oscillation probabilities. For their numerical examples, the authors also defined three specific mixing matrices (M1, M2, M3) for a $3+1$ neutrino scenario, constrained by data from reactor and long-baseline experiments like Bugey, Chooz, and KamLAND.

Key Insights and Results

The primary achievement of this work is the mapping of complex $N$-neutrino oscillations onto the familiar 2-flavor MSW framework. The resulting generalized probability formula provides the averaged survival probability for electron neutrinos ($P_{\nu_e \to \nu_e}$) and their transition into sterile states ($P_{\nu_e \to \nu_s$).

Numerical validations across a wide energy range ($10^{-2}$ to $10^6$ MeV) show that the analytic approximations are highly accurate. Furthermore, the study highlights that matter effects can either enhance or suppress transitions to sterile states depending on the mixing parameters, such as the sign of $\cos 2\vartheta_s$. Notably, in the extreme non-adiabatic limit, the presence of sterile mixing prevents the transition probability from simply reverting to its vacuum value, a distinct departure from standard 3-flavor physics.

Conclusion

The framework developed by Giunti and Li offers a robust tool for analyzing solar neutrino data in the context of sterile neutrino searches. By reducing the complexity of the $N$-neutrino problem without sacrificing precision, this model is well-suited for global fits of data from experiments like SNO, Borexino, and Super-Kamiokande, potentially revealing new physics beyond the Standard Model or setting more stringent bounds on sterile neutrino mixing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The matter effects for solar neutrino oscillations are studied in a general scheme with an arbitrary number of sterile neutrinos, without any constraint on the mixing, assuming only a realistic hierarchy of neutrino squared-mass differences in which the smallest squared-mass difference is effective in solar neutrino oscillations. The validity of the analytic results are illustrated with a numerical solution of the evolution equation in three examples of the possible mixing matrix in the simplest case of four-neutrino mixing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{giunti2009matter,
  author = {C. Giunti and Yufeng Li},
  title = {{Matter effects in active-sterile solar neutrino oscillations}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.80.113007},
}
Figure