Matrix-propagator approach to compute fluid Love numbers and applicability to extrasolar planets

Sebastiano Padovan, Tilman Spohn, Philipp Baumeister, Nicola Tosi, D. Breuer, Sz. Csizmadia, Hugo Hellard, F. SohlSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a fast and efficient matrix-propagator method for calculating fluid Love numbers ($k_n$) from a planet's density profile. This approach is crucial for interpreting future observations of extrasolar planets, as Love numbers provide a direct constraint on their internal mass distribution, helping to break degeneracies in mass-radius relationships.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the internal structure of planets, especially exoplanets, is a significant challenge. While a planet's mass and radius give us its bulk density, this is a coarse measure. To infer more detailed information about composition and differentiation, we need more sensitive probes. The fluid Love number ($k_2$) is one such probe, quantifying how a planet deforms under tidal or rotational forces. However, calculating these numbers accurately for a given density profile has been computationally intensive. This paper addresses this by developing and validating a computationally efficient method to derive these Love numbers, making them more accessible for analyzing exoplanet data.

Methods

The core of this paper is the application of the matrix-propagator technique to calculate fluid Love numbers ($k_n$). This method, commonly used in geophysics, involves solving a system of differential equations that describe the planet's response to perturbations. Instead of directly solving these equations, the matrix-propagator approach discretizes the planet into a series of layers, each with a constant density. For each layer, a general solution is found, and then interface matrices are used to connect these solutions across layer boundaries. This process is repeated until the surface is reached, where boundary conditions are applied to determine the integration constants and, subsequently, the Love numbers. The authors emphasize that this method only requires the density profile and does not need the local density derivative, simplifying its implementation with existing interior structure codes. They also discuss how to handle boundary and interface conditions, and how to combine solutions for layered structures.

Datasets

The paper uses several existing datasets and models for validation and illustration:

  • Interior structure models: The authors utilize density profiles derived from interior structure codes for specific planets.
  • GJ 436b models: Three distinct interior models for GJ 436b are used, representing Earth-like, rocky, and ocean-like interiors, based on updated mass and radius values.
  • Jupiter models: Two density profiles for Jupiter are employed, representing a compact core versus a diluted core scenario.
  • Earth models: The Preliminary Reference Earth Model (PREM) is used to validate the method's accuracy for a well-characterized planet.
  • Analytical density profiles: Gaussian curves with varying standard deviations are used to explore the dependence of Love numbers on mass concentration.

No new datasets or benchmarks are introduced; rather, the paper focuses on applying its method to existing planetary models and data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Love numbers as direct probes of mass distribution: The paper strongly emphasizes that fluid Love numbers ($k_n$) are direct measures of a planet's internal mass concentration. This is a crucial insight because it means that measuring $k_2$ for exoplanets can help break the "degeneracy" of mass-radius relationships, where different internal structures can produce similar bulk properties.
  • Efficiency of the matrix-propagator method: The authors demonstrate that their matrix-propagator approach is computationally efficient, allowing for rapid calculation of Love numbers. This is vital for analyzing large datasets of exoplanets or for performing extensive parameter studies.
  • Applicability to extrasolar planets: The linear theory presented is well-suited for close-in, tidally locked gaseous exoplanets (like hot Jupiters), which are expected to be among the first targets for which Love numbers can be measured.
  • Convergence and accuracy: The paper shows that the matrix-propagator method converges to accurate results with a reasonable number of layers (typically 10³-10⁴), providing a good balance between precision and computational cost.

Key Results

  • Developed and validated a matrix-propagator code: The authors have implemented a code that calculates fluid Love numbers ($k_n$) for any given density profile.
  • Demonstrated accuracy: The method's results match those obtained from solving the full differential equations for Love numbers, as validated against Earth models (PREM) and Jupiter models. For Earth, the results are within one part per thousand of reference values even with a few hundred layers.
  • Computational speed: The computation of $k_2$ for a model with 10⁵ sub-layers takes approximately 1 second on a 2.5 GHz Intel Core i7 processor, highlighting its efficiency.
  • Illustrative applications: The paper applies the method to GJ 436b, showing how different internal structures (Earth-like, rocky, ocean-like) yield distinct $k_2$ values, and to Jupiter-like hot Jupiters, demonstrating the impact of core dilution on $k_2$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Linear theory: The current approach is based on linear theory. This means it cannot fully account for nonlinear effects that can arise in rapidly rotating planets (like Jupiter) or under certain dynamical conditions. For such cases, more complex methods like the concentric Maclaurin spheroids approach are needed.
  • Hydrostatic equilibrium assumption: The method assumes hydrostatic equilibrium, which is generally valid for gaseous planets but requires careful consideration for terrestrial planets with finite shear strengths and complex thermal histories.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that their method is a crucial step towards breaking the mass-radius degeneracy for exoplanets. Future work would involve applying this method to a wider range of exoplanet models and comparing predictions with observational data as it becomes available. The code is made freely available, encouraging its adoption and further development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Context. The mass and radius of a planet directly provide its bulk density, which can be interpreted in terms of its overall composition. Any measure of the radial mass distribution provides a first step in constraining the interior structure. The fluid Love number k2 provides such a measure, and estimates of k2 for extrasolar planets are expected to be available in the coming years thanks to improved observational facilities and the ever-extending temporal baseline of extrasolar planet observations. Aims. We derive a method for calculating the Love numbers kn of any object given its density profile, which is routinely calculated from interior structure codes. Methods. We used the matrix-propagator technique, a method frequently used in the geophysical community. Results. We detail the calculation and apply it to the case of GJ 436b, a classical example of the degeneracy of mass-radius relationships, to illustrate how measurements of k2 can improve our understanding of the interior structure of extrasolar planets. We implemented the method in a code that is fast, freely available, and easy to combine with preexisting interior structure codes. While the linear approach presented here for the calculation of the Love numbers cannot treat the presence of nonlinear effects that may arise under certain dynamical conditions, it is applicable to close-in gaseous extrasolar planets like hot Jupiters, likely the first targets for which k2 will be measured.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{padovan2018matrix,
  author = {Sebastiano Padovan and Tilman Spohn and Philipp Baumeister and Nicola Tosi and D. Breuer and Sz. Csizmadia and Hugo Hellard and F. Sohl},
  title = {{Matrix-propagator approach to compute fluid Love numbers and applicability to extrasolar planets}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/201834181/pdf},
}
Figure