Mathematical modeling and simulation of thyroid homeostasis: Implications for the Allan-Herndon-Dudley syndrome

Tobias M. Wolff, Carina Veil, Johannes W. Dietrich, Matthias A. MüllerFrontiers in Endocrinology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses mathematical modeling to show that the unusual hormone profile of Allan-Herndon-Dudley syndrome (AHDS) can be explained by a single mechanism: the "trapping" of thyroxine ($T_4$) inside thyroid cells. By extending a classic feedback loop model to include membrane transport kinetics, the authors demonstrate that a loss of transporter activity leads to thyroidal $T_4$ retention, which subsequently drives the systemic hormone imbalances characteristic of the disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Allan-Herndon-Dudley syndrome (AHDS) is a rare, severe X-linked neurodevelopmental disorder caused by mutations in the SLC16A2 gene. This gene encodes monocarboxylate transporter 8 (MCT8), a key protein that moves thyroid hormones across cell membranes.

Patients with AHDS exhibit a puzzling "thyroid phenotype": low levels of free $T_4$ (FT4), high levels of free $T_3$ (FT3), and slightly elevated thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH). While it is known that MCT8 is defective, researchers have debated why these specific systemic levels occur. One leading hypothesis is that $T_4$ is partially retained (trapped) within the thyroid cells because it cannot be exported. Once trapped, more $T_4$ is converted into $T_3$ locally, which then leaks into the blood through other (non-MCT8) transporters. This paper seeks to validate this "retention hypothesis" using a formal mathematical framework.

Methods

The authors extended an existing nonlinear differential equation model of the pituitary-thyroid feedback loop.

  • Model Extension: They introduced a new state variable, $T_{4,th}$, representing the concentration of $T_4$ specifically within the thyroid gland's cells.
  • Transport Kinetics: They modeled the net effect of membrane transporters using two approaches:
  • Michaelis-Menten kinetics: A standard nonlinear approach for enzyme/transporter saturation.
  • Linear approximation: A simplified model assuming transport is proportional to concentration (valid when concentrations are well below the transporter's saturation point).
  • Parameter Estimation: The authors used constrained parameter optimization to fit the model to real-world clinical data. They estimated the maximal transport activity ($G_{MT}$) for both healthy individuals and AHDS patients.
  • Uncertainty Analysis: They employed parametric bootstrapping (simulating the model 100 times with added noise) to quantify the reliability of their parameter estimates.

Datasets

The study relied on previously published clinical data rather than new experimental datasets:

  • Healthy Individuals: Mean dynamic hormone concentrations (TSH, FT4, FT3) from a study of 27 healthy subjects (Russell et al., 2008).
  • AHDS Patients: Steady-state hormone measurements aggregated from several clinical case reports and studies (comprising data from approximately 13 patients).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Trapping" Sufficiency: The most significant insight is that thyroidal retention of $T_4$ is sufficient to explain the entire systemic hormone profile of AHDS. While some researchers suggested the kidney must play a role in $T_4$ clearance to explain the low serum levels, this model shows that simply "clogging" the exit in the thyroid gland reproduces the clinical observations.
  • Linearity in Biology: The authors found that the linear approximation of the transporter performed almost identically to the more complex Michaelis-Menten model. This suggests that in both healthy and AHDS states, the thyroid hormone transport system operates far from its saturation point.
  • Predictive Power: The model predicts that $T_4$ levels inside the thyroid cells of AHDS patients are approximately 18 times higher than in healthy individuals. This provides a concrete target for future experimental validation in animal models or cell cultures.

Key Results

  • Transport Activity: The estimated maximal transport activity ($G_{MT}$) for AHDS patients was roughly 18 times lower than that of healthy individuals, reflecting the loss of MCT8 function.
  • Hormone Replication: Dynamic simulations successfully replicated the AHDS phenotype:
  • FT3: ~1.4x higher than healthy levels.
  • TSH: ~1.4x higher than healthy levels.
  • FT4: ~2.1x lower than healthy levels.
  • Stability: A local stability analysis (provided in the supplementary material) confirmed that the feedback loop remains stable even with severely damaged membrane transporters, explaining why patients reach a (maladaptive) steady state rather than experiencing runaway hormone levels.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Compartmental Simplification: The model treats the "periphery" as a single block, merging the distinct roles of the liver, kidneys, and muscles.
  • MCT8 Specificity: The model focuses on $T_4$ transport. While MCT8 also transports $T_3$, the authors chose to simplify the model by assuming $T_3$ transport is less affected or handled by redundant transporters—a simplification that might need refinement.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future iterations should explicitly model the kidney. This would allow them to test whether renal $T_4$ accumulation (observed in mice) is a primary driver or merely a secondary effect of the syndrome. They also suggest investigating how MCT8 deficiency affects the feedback loop at other sites, such as the blood-brain barrier.

Summary updated

Abstract

The results support the hypothesis that a partial retention of <i>T</i> <sub>4</sub> in thyroid cells represents one mechanism responsible for the unusual hormone concentrations of AHDS patients. Moreover, our results suggest that the retention of <i>T</i> <sub>4</sub> in thyroid cells could be the main reason for the unusual hormone concentrations of AHDS patients.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wolff2022mathematical,
  author = {Tobias M. Wolff and Carina Veil and Johannes W. Dietrich and Matthias A. Müller},
  title = {{Mathematical modeling and simulation of thyroid homeostasis: Implications for the Allan-Herndon-Dudley syndrome}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Endocrinology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fendo.2022.882788},
}

Loading related content...

Figure