Maternal nutritional risk factors for pre-eclampsia incidence: findings from a narrative scoping review

Mai‐Lei Woo Kinshella, Shazmeen Omar, Kerri Scherbinsky, Marianne Vidler, Laura A. Magee, Peter von Dadelszen, Sophie E. Moore, Rajavel Elango, Lucilla Poston, Hiten D. Mistry, Marie‐Laure Volvert, Cristina Escalona Lopez, Rachel Tribe, Andrew Shennan, Tatiana Taylor Salisbury, Lucy C. Chappell, Rachel Craik, Marleen Temmerman, Angela Koech, Sikolia Wanyonyi, Geoffrey Omuse, Patricia Okiro, Grace Mwashigadi, Esperança Sevene, Helena Boene, Corssino Tchavana, Eusébio Macete, Carla Carillho, Lazaro Quimice, Sónia Maculuve, Donna Russell, Ben Baratt, Joy E Lawn, Hannah Blencowe, Véronique Filippi, Matt J. Silver, Prestige Tatenda Makanga, Liberty Makacha, Yolisa Prudence Dube, Newton Nyapwere, Reason Mlambo, Umberto D’Alessandro, Anna Roca, Melisa Martínez-Álvarez, Hawanatu Jah, Brahima A. Diallo, Abdul Karim Sesay, Fatima Touray, Abdoulie Sillah, J. Alison Noble, Aris T. Papageorghiou, Judith E. Cartwright, Guy Whitley, Sanjeev Krishna, Rosemarie Townsend, Asma Khalil, Joel Singer, Jing Li, Jeffrey N. Bone, Kelly Pickerill, Ash Sandhu, Tu Domena, William StonesReproductive 2022 · DOI

Abstract

A growing body of literature highlights the involvement of maternal dietary factors in the development of pre-eclampsia. Our review findings support the need for further investigation into potential interactions between dietary factors and consideration of nutritional homeostasis and healthy dietary patterns. Further research is recommended to explore gestational age, potential non-linear relationships, dietary diversity and social, cultural contexts of food and meals.

Introduction: The Challenge of Pre-eclampsia

Pre-eclampsia remains a leading cause of maternal mortality worldwide, characterized by a complex "two-stage" etiology. Stage 1 involves poor placental development and defective trophoblast invasion, which subsequently triggers Stage 2: systemic maternal inflammation, oxidative stress, and endothelial dysfunction leading to clinical hypertension.

While nutritional status is a known risk factor, clinical trials focusing on single-nutrient supplementation (the "supplementation paradox") have often yielded disappointing results. This narrative scoping review by Kinshella et al. (2022) addresses this gap by mapping observational evidence against biological pathways, advocating for a holistic view of dietary patterns and nutrient homeostasis.

Methodology

The researchers employed the Arksey and O’Malley framework for a narrative scoping review. Unlike narrow systematic reviews, this approach prioritized observational studies and large-scale meta-analyses to capture real-world nutritional status across diverse populations. The search spanned major databases including Medline, EMBASE, and CINAHL, triangulating findings based on biological plausibility, consistency across populations, and effect size.

Biological Mechanisms and Nutritional Interplay

The review identifies several critical nutritional axes that influence the progression of pre-eclampsia. Rather than isolated vitamins, the evidence suggests that nutrient synergies are paramount.

Pathophysiology of pre-eclampsia and associated dietary mechanisms.

The Calcium-Vitamin D-Magnesium Axis

These three nutrients function as a cohesive unit. Vitamin D regulates calcium absorption, while magnesium acts as a natural calcium channel blocker to promote vasodilation. A deficiency in serum calcium can trigger parathyroid hormone (PTH) secretion, leading to vasoconstriction and the hypertension characteristic of Stage 2 pre-eclampsia.

Antioxidants and Oxidative Stress

Vitamin C acts as a "linchpin" by replenishing Vitamin E. Its role is intricately tied to iron homeostasis; the review notes a U-shaped risk curve where both very low and very high hemoglobin levels increase risk. Essential trace elements like zinc, copper, and selenium also play vital roles as components of antioxidant enzymes like superoxide dismutase.

Dietary Patterns vs. Single Nutrients

The review highlights the success of Mediterranean and Nordic diets over low-fat alternatives like the DASH diet. The protective effect is attributed to the quality of fats—specifically monounsaturated fats and omega-3 fatty acids—which modulate systemic inflammatory responses. Conversely, high sugar intake (≥125ml/day) was linked to a 27% increase in risk, likely due to metabolic stress.

Key Findings

  • Vitamin D: Deficiency (< 50 nmol/L) is a significant risk factor, with some meta-analyses showing an Odds Ratio (OR) of 2.11.
  • Folate: Women in the lowest quartiles of folate intake face approximately double the risk of pre-eclampsia.
  • Dietary Adherence: High adherence to Mediterranean-style dietary patterns correlates with a 14% to 42% reduction in hypertensive disorders of pregnancy.
  • Vitamin C: Low intake (<85 mg/day) is associated with a 2.1x higher incidence risk.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The current evidence base is heavily weighted toward high-income countries, leaving a significant knowledge gap in resource-limited settings. Future research must prioritize the "periconceptual window" (the first 12 weeks of pregnancy) when placental vascularization occurs. Additionally, moving beyond linear "deficiency vs. sufficiency" models to account for U-shaped risk curves and the social/cultural context of eating will be essential for developing effective public health interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

A growing body of literature highlights the involvement of maternal dietary factors in the development of pre-eclampsia. Our review findings support the need for further investigation into potential interactions between dietary factors and consideration of nutritional homeostasis and healthy dietary patterns. Further research is recommended to explore gestational age, potential non-linear relationships, dietary diversity and social, cultural contexts of food and meals.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kinshella2022maternal,
  author = {Mai‐Lei Woo Kinshella and Shazmeen Omar and Kerri Scherbinsky and Marianne Vidler and Laura A. Magee and Peter von Dadelszen and Sophie E. Moore and Rajavel Elango and Peter von Dadelszen and Laura A. Magee and Lucilla Poston and Hiten D. Mistry and Marie‐Laure Volvert and Cristina Escalona Lopez and Sophie E. Moore and Rachel Tribe and Andrew Shennan and Tatiana Taylor Salisbury and Lucy C. Chappell and Rachel Craik and Marleen Temmerman and Angela Koech and Sikolia Wanyonyi and Geoffrey Omuse and Patricia Okiro and Grace Mwashigadi and Esperança Sevene and Helena Boene and Corssino Tchavana and Eusébio Macete and Carla Carillho and Lazaro Quimice and Sónia Maculuve and Donna Russell and Ben Baratt and Joy E Lawn and Hannah Blencowe and Véronique Filippi and Matt J. Silver and Prestige Tatenda Makanga and Liberty Makacha and Yolisa Prudence Dube and Newton Nyapwere and Reason Mlambo and Umberto D’Alessandro and Anna Roca and Melisa Martínez-Álvarez and Hawanatu Jah and Brahima A. Diallo and Abdul Karim Sesay and Fatima Touray and Abdoulie Sillah and J. Alison Noble and Aris T. Papageorghiou and Judith E. Cartwright and Guy Whitley and Sanjeev Krishna and Rosemarie Townsend and Asma Khalil and Marianne Vidler and Joel Singer and Jing Li and Jeffrey N. Bone and Mai‐Lei Woo Kinshella and Kelly Pickerill and Ash Sandhu and Tu Domena and Rajavel Elango and William Stones and William Stones},
  title = {{Maternal nutritional risk factors for pre-eclampsia incidence: findings from a narrative scoping review}},
  booktitle = {Reproductive},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1186/s12978-022-01485-9},
}
Figure