Matching Algorithm Based on Semantic Similarity of Service Requirement Ontology for CAE Simulation in Cloud Platform

Ziyun Deng, Jing Zhang, Lijun Cai, Lei Chen, Tingqin HeInternational Journal of u- and e- Service Science and Technology 2016 · DOI

Abstract

When Cloud Platform for Computer Aided Engineering Simulation (CPCAES) are developed to use Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA), it is necessary to accurately express user service requirements and the semantics of existing services to perform effective ontology matching. Existing algorithms like OWL-S/UDDI often lack the precision required for complex CAE applications. This paper presents a specialized service requirement ontology for CAE simulation, encompassing resource, domain, and job requirements. We define mapping relationships between this ontology and OWL-S, establish matching decision rules, and propose a similarity-based matching algorithm. Evaluation against traditional methods shows our approach achieves approximately 90% precision and recall, offering a more suitable solution for CPCAES.

Introduction

Computer-Aided Engineering (CAE) simulations, such as stress analysis and fluid dynamics, are computationally intensive tasks. While Cloud Platforms for CAE (CPCAES) aim to simplify access to these tools, matching specific user requirements—such as software versions, core counts, and licenses—to available cloud services remains a significant challenge. Standard protocols like OWL-S and UDDI are often too generic, failing to capture the technical nuances of high-performance engineering simulations, which leads to low matching precision.

The CAE Service Requirement Ontology

To address these limitations, we developed a specialized ontology that extends the standard OWL-S ServiceProfile. This RequirementProfile captures CAE-specific data across several dimensions:

  • RequirementResource: Software licenses, CPU configurations, and memory.
  • RequirementDomain: The specific engineering field (e.g., heat transfer, collision analysis).
  • RequirementJob: Operational constraints like priority, parallel scale, and response time.
Structure of the RequirementProfile ontology for CAE simulations.

Ontology Mapping and Similarity Algorithm

A critical component of our system is the formal mapping between the custom RequirementProfile and the standard ServiceProfile. This ensures compatibility with broader semantic web standards while allowing for specialized matching.

Mapping relationship between the RequirementProfile and the standard ServiceProfile.

Our matching algorithm moves beyond binary "yes/no" results. It calculates a numerical similarity score (ranging from 0 to 1) based on the semantic distance between nodes in the ontology tree. The final match is a weighted sum of four primary factors:

  1. Input matching
  2. Output matching
  3. Precondition matching (Resource and Domain requirements)
  4. Quality of Service (QoS) matching (Job requirements)

This weighted approach allows the system to prioritize certain parameters, such as specific software versions over memory size, depending on user needs.

Experimental Evaluation

The algorithm was evaluated using 100 services from a CPCAES prototype. We compared our approach against the classic OWL-S/UDDI matching algorithm and a general semantic similarity algorithm.

Key results include:

  • High Precision and Recall: Both metrics reached approximately 90%, significantly outperforming the OWL-S/UDDI baseline, especially as requirement complexity increased.
  • Qualitative Accuracy: The system successfully distinguished between similar services (e.g., different versions of ANSYS for different analysis types) that generic matchers often confused.
  • Real-world Application: The algorithm is currently integrated into the second prototype of the National Supercomputing Center in Changsha’s cloud platform.

Conclusion and Future Work

The proposed semantic matching algorithm provides a robust framework for service discovery in CAE cloud environments. While currently optimized for CAE, future work will explore adapting the ontology for other domains like bioinformatics. Additionally, we aim to transition from simple matching to fully automatic service composition using Petri nets and the Activiti process engine to manage complex simulation workflows.

Summary updated

Abstract

When Cloud Platform for Computer Aided Engineering Simulation (CPCAES) are developed to use Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA), on the one hand, it's necessary to accurately express the service requirements of users, on the other hand it's need to semantic of the existing services in the platform, and then to match the ontologies. The existing Ontology Web Language for Services / Universal Description Discovery and Integration (OWL-S / UDDI) algorithm has weak matching precision, and not meet the Computer Aided Engineering (CAE) simulation applications. The other semantic similarity algorithms also have weakness in judgment factor, or do not meet the requirements of CAE simulation applications for matching to service requirement ontology in cloud platform. Such that, the authors present a kind of ontology of service requirement for CAE simulation, model the content of the ontology, including resource requirements, computing requirements, computing job requirements, input, output, etc. The authors give the ontology mapping relationship between Ontology Web Language for Services (OWL-S) and the ontology, give the matching decision rules for the ontologies, propose a matching algorithm for matching the ontologies, and compare with the classic OWL-S / UDDI matching algorithm and a similarity matching algorithm proposed in other paper in the ability for measure the similarity quantity of services, the ability to suit the applications, as well as algorithms recall rate and precision rate. The results show the matching algorithm proposed in this paper is more suitable for service requirement ontology of CPCAES, can use the quantify value for the similarity analysis to the ontologies, and has higher precision rate and higher recall rate, which can reach about 90%. The research work in this paper is used in the second prototype of CPCAES, and the research team is developing the third prototype based on semantic Web Services and SOA framework.
BibTeX
@article{deng2016matching,
  author = {Ziyun Deng and Jing Zhang and Lijun Cai and Lei Chen and Tingqin He},
  title = {{Matching Algorithm Based on Semantic Similarity of Service Requirement Ontology for CAE Simulation in Cloud Platform}},
  journal = {International Journal of u- and e- Service Science and Technology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.14257/ijunesst.2016.9.9.22},
}
Figure