Match of the Bimaxillary Basal Bone Arches and Its Variations among Individuals

Chen Wen-qian, Hao Zeng, Luna Sun, Qiuping Xu, Zhenxue Chen, Yunhan Sun, Qi Jia, Chengyun Liu, Jing GuoScanning 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the 3D shape and alignment of the upper and lower jaw's basal bone arches, crucial for understanding tooth movement limits and potential orthodontic complications. They found that while the arches generally match, significant differences exist in the posterior (back) regions, particularly in females, suggesting potential challenges for orthodontic treatments like molar distalization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Orthodontic treatment aims to move teeth into ideal positions, but this movement is constrained by the underlying bone structure. Specifically, the basal bone, which forms the foundation of the jaw, dictates the boundaries for tooth movement. Pushing teeth too far can lead to root resorption or gum recession. While previous research has focused on the buccal (cheek-side) contours of the basal bone, this study highlights the importance of understanding the entire basal bone arch, including the lingual (tongue-side) and retromolar regions. Furthermore, the "match" or alignment between the upper and lower jaw's basal bone arches is critical for predictable treatment outcomes, especially when considering non-extraction methods that rely on maximizing available space. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the comprehensive 3D morphology and inter-arch matching of the basal bone, particularly its variations between genders and across different regions of the jaw.

Methods

The researchers employed two key statistical shape analysis techniques:

  • Generalized Procrustes Analysis (GPA): This method was used to align and average the 3D basal bone arch contours from multiple individuals. GPA is a standard technique for comparing shapes by removing differences in translation, rotation, and scale, allowing for the visualization of average shapes and their variations.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): PCA was applied to analyze the variations in basal bone morphology among individuals. It's a dimensionality reduction technique that identifies the principal modes of variation within a dataset. In this context, PCA helps to pinpoint which parts of the basal bone arch show the most significant differences between individuals.

The study defined the "basal bone" contour as the inner cortex of the upper and lower jaws, specifically along a horizontal plane passing through the furcation of the first molar roots, parallel to the mandibular occlusal plane. Landmarks were meticulously placed on CBCT scans to capture these contours.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 100 cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) images from young adults (18-21 years old), with an equal split of 50 males and 50 females. These images were acquired between 2017 and 2019. The dataset was not newly introduced but rather a collection of existing patient CBCT scans.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Posterior Mismatch is Key: The most significant finding is the mismatch in the posterior (back) regions of the upper and lower basal bone arches, particularly around the second molar and retromolar areas. This suggests that while the anterior (front) parts of the jaws align relatively well, the back ends don't perfectly mirror each other.
  • Gender Differences Matter: Females exhibit a more pronounced mismatch in the posterior basal bone than males. This implies that orthodontic treatments requiring significant posterior tooth movement might present different challenges based on gender.
  • Male Arches are Larger: On average, male basal bone arches are wider and longer than those of females, contributing to the observed gender-specific differences in arch matching.
  • Terminal Segments are Variable: PCA analysis revealed that the variations in basal bone shape among individuals are most prominent in the terminal segments (posterior regions) of the arches, while the anterior segments are relatively stable. This reinforces the idea that the back of the jaw is where most individual differences lie.
  • Clinical Implications for Molar Distalization: The findings have direct implications for molar distalization (moving molars backward). The study suggests that the convergent nature of the upper basal bone and divergent nature of the lower basal bone in the posterior region can restrict buccal (outward) movement of upper posterior teeth.

Key Results

  • Width Discrepancy: The retromolar region showed a significant width discrepancy, with the upper arch being shorter than the lower. For males, this difference was 7.30 mm, and for females, it was 9.09 mm.
  • Gender Differences in Mismatch: Statistical analysis (t-tests) confirmed significant gender differences in the ratio and difference width of the second molar and retromolar regions. Females showed a more pronounced mismatch.
  • Male vs. Female Dimensions: Male basal bone arches were wider (2.64 mm in the maxilla, 0.52 mm in the mandible) and longer (1.07 mm in the maxilla, 2.64 mm in the mandible) than female arches.
  • PCA Variance Explained: PCA successfully explained over 50% of the basal bone shape variation, with primary variations occurring at the terminal segments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Definition of Basal Bone: The study acknowledges that the definition of the basal bone border can vary, though they established a clear and reproducible method for their study.
  • Sample Age Range: The study focused on young adults (18-21 years). Future research could explore how these basal bone characteristics change with age.
  • Forecasting Basal Bone Shape: The authors suggest that understanding these variations could be applicable to forecasting basal bone shape based on gender and potentially predicting root absorption during tooth movement.
  • Further Investigation of Posterior Segments: The study emphasizes the need for more detailed evaluations of the transverse coordination of the second molar and retromolar regions, especially in cases of Class III malocclusion where maxillary deficiency is common.
  • Clinical Application: The findings highlight the importance of considering transverse matching tendencies of the bimaxillary basal bone when planning orthodontic treatments, particularly for molar distalization.

Summary updated

Abstract

For both male and female, the bimaxillary basal bone matched except terminal segments. Mismatch of female bimaxillary posterior basal bone was more pronounced than male. The basal bone arches of male were wider and longer than that of female.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wenqian2021match,
  author = {Chen Wen-qian and Hao Zeng and Luna Sun and Qiuping Xu and Zhenxue Chen and Yunhan Sun and Qi Jia and Chengyun Liu and Jing Guo},
  title = {{Match of the Bimaxillary Basal Bone Arches and Its Variations among Individuals}},
  booktitle = {Scanning},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1155/2021/9625893},
}
Figure