MAS: a multiplicative approximation scheme for probabilistic inference

Ydo Wexler, Christopher MeekNeurIPS 2008

Overview

The Multiplicative Approximation Scheme (MAS) provides a robust framework for approximating complex probabilistic inference problems with guaranteed error bounds. By dynamically decomposing large functions into smaller, manageable pieces during the inference process, the authors' DynaDecomp algorithm achieves orders of magnitude better accuracy than traditional methods like Mini-buckets, all while remaining computationally efficient.

The Challenge of Probabilistic Inference

Probabilistic Graphical Models (PGMs) are powerful tools for representing uncertainty, but they have a major Achilles' heel: performing exact inference—such as calculating the likelihood of evidence or finding the most probable explanation—is NP-hard.

To get around this computational bottleneck, researchers usually turn to approximation methods. However, existing techniques often force a difficult trade-off: you either get speed without knowing how far off your answer is (as seen in loopy belief propagation), or you get bounds that are too loose to be practically useful. The core challenge is to find an approximation that is fast, highly accurate, and provides a tight, provable guarantee on the error introduced during the calculation.

Methods: The MAS Framework

The authors introduce MAS (Multiplicative Approximation Scheme), which relies on a core operation called $\epsilon$-decomposition.

  1. $\epsilon$-Decomposition: Instead of dealing with a massive function over many variables, MAS breaks it down into a sum of functions over smaller subsets of variables. Crucially, this decomposition is done such that the error is bounded by a factor of $(1 + \epsilon)$.
  2. Error Translation: The "magic" of MAS is its ability to translate these local, step-by-step approximation errors into a global multiplicative bound on the final result (e.g., the log-likelihood).
Illustration of error propagation in MAS, showing how local epsilon-decompositions translate into a global multiplicative bound.
  1. Optimization: The paper provides a fast, closed-form solution for finding the best decomposition using the $L_2$ norm. They also show that the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence can be used for optimization via variational algorithms.
  2. DynaDecomp: This is the star of the paper—an implementation of MAS applied to the Variable Elimination (VE) algorithm. DynaDecomp monitors the size of functions during execution; if a function becomes too large to compute exactly, the algorithm dynamically decomposes it, keeps track of the error, and continues.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Context-Aware Decoupling: Unlike variational methods that remove edges from the graph entirely, DynaDecomp can decouple variables in one part of the computation while maintaining their dependence in others. This "surgical" approach to approximation preserves significantly more information.
  • Multiplicative vs. Additive: By working in the log-domain and using multiplicative bounds, the error guarantees remain meaningful even when dealing with the tiny probabilities common in large graphical models.
  • The "Dinosaur" Benchmark: To illustrate the scale of the problem, the authors estimate that exact inference on a $100 \times 100$ grid would take $3 \cdot 10^{15}$ seconds—longer than the time since the extinction of the dinosaurs. DynaDecomp finished the same task in about 7 to 8 seconds.
  • Efficiency of $L_2$: The discovery of a closed-form solution for $L_2$ optimization means that the overhead of finding the "best" approximation at each step is minimal, making the algorithm extremely fast in practice.

Empirical Results

The authors evaluated DynaDecomp across several challenging benchmarks, including Ising models, large-scale grids, real-world phylogenetic models, and standard UAI'06/CPCS benchmarks.

Performance of DynaDecomp on various grid models, demonstrating high accuracy, tight bounds, and significant speedups.
  • Superior Accuracy: On average, DynaDecomp was 200 times more accurate than the popular Mini-buckets (MB) algorithm across the tested models.
  • Tighter Bounds: The theoretical error guarantees for DynaDecomp were significantly better (often $<1\%$) compared to MB (often $>30\%$).
  • Phylogenetic Success: On large biological models containing tens of thousands of variables, DynaDecomp achieved less than 0.01% error in just a few seconds, outperforming previous variational methods by two orders of magnitude in both speed and accuracy.
  • Ising Model Performance: On $8 \times 8$ grids, DynaDecomp achieved an average error of $1.86 \times 10^{-5}$, vastly outperforming Generalized Belief Propagation (0.003) and Generalized Mean Field (0.366).

Limitations and Future Work

While highly effective, MAS does have limitations. The paper notes that $\epsilon$-decompositions are not well-defined for functions that contain zeros or infinities. In models with many "hard" constraints (zero-probability assignments), the theoretical error bounds can become arbitrarily bad, though the algorithm often still performs well in practice.

Additionally, while the paper provides a way to optimize a decomposition once the variable subsets are chosen, the initial choice of which variables to group together is still based on heuristics (like random partitioning). Future work could explore more sophisticated ways to choose these subsets to further minimize error. Finally, the authors suggest that MAS could be integrated into other inference frameworks, such as the junction tree algorithm, opening doors for even more complex applications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wexler2008mas,
  author = {Ydo Wexler and Christopher Meek},
  title = {{MAS: a multiplicative approximation scheme for probabilistic inference}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2008},
}
Figure