Markov Network Structure Learning via Ensemble-of-Forests Models

Eirini Arvaniti, Manfred ClaassenUAI 2014

TL;DR

This paper introduces the "ensemble-of-forests" (EF) model, a novel approach for learning the structure of Markov Random Fields (MRFs) that can handle complex, disconnected networks and non-Gaussian dependencies. The EF model offers a more flexible and accurate way to model real-world systems compared to existing methods, particularly in scenarios with limited data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modeling complex systems often involves understanding the relationships between many variables. Markov Random Fields (MRFs) are a powerful tool for this, representing these relationships as a graph. However, learning the structure of these MRFs (i.e., figuring out which variables are directly related) is a significant challenge. Existing methods often struggle with:

  • Non-Gaussian Dependencies: Many real-world systems exhibit dependencies that aren't well-described by simple Gaussian distributions.
  • Disconnected Structures: Real-world networks are often not a single connected graph but rather composed of multiple independent or semi-independent components.
  • Computational Complexity: Learning MRF structures is computationally intensive, especially as the number of variables or the complexity of dependencies increases.

This paper aims to overcome these limitations by proposing a new model and inference techniques that can handle arbitrary potentials and disconnected topologies in MRFs, even with limited data.

Methods

The core contribution is the ensemble-of-forests (EF) model, which generalizes the existing "ensemble-of-trees" (ET) model.

  • Ensemble-of-Trees (ET): The ET model represents an MRF as a mixture of distributions over all possible spanning trees of the graph. This allows for approximate inference and structure learning, especially for MRFs with "inconvenient" potentials (i.e., non-Gaussian). However, it implicitly assumes a connected graph.
  • Ensemble-of-Forests (EF): The EF model extends this by representing an MRF as a mixture over all possible forests (collections of trees), allowing for disconnected components. This is achieved by considering partitions of the nodes into multiple components.
  • Approximate Inference: Due to the combinatorial complexity of exact inference with forests, the authors propose two approximate inference techniques:
  • EF-cuts heuristic: This method focuses on graphs with at most two connected components and uses a scoring system based on minimum cuts to identify likely partitions.
  • EF-X heuristic: This method scales better with dimensionality and number of connected components by dropping the explicit summation over partitions and instead imposing an L1 penalty on structural parameters to encourage sparsity and naturally induce disconnected components. This is the primary method evaluated in the paper.
  • Copula Potentials: The EF model utilizes copula functions to model arbitrary dependency structures between variables, making it suitable for non-Gaussian data.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its methods on:

  • Synthetic Data:
    • Gaussian MRFs (both connected and disconnected components)
    • Non-Gaussian MRFs using Student's t-copula with 1 degree of freedom.
  • High-dimensional GMRFs with very low sample sizes.
  • Real-World Data:
    • Mass cytometry data from human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) to analyze immune cell signaling networks.

The synthetic datasets are generated to specifically test the model's ability to recover known graph structures under various conditions (sample size, dependency type, number of components).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Forests are Crucial for Real-World Networks: The paper strongly emphasizes that real-world biological and other complex systems frequently exhibit disconnected structures, making models that can handle forests essential.
  • EF-X Scales and Generalizes: The EF-X heuristic proves to be a robust and scalable approach, outperforming other methods in various scenarios, especially when dealing with disconnected components and non-Gaussian dependencies.
  • Non-Gaussian Dependencies are Common: The simulations with Student's t-copula highlight that assuming Gaussianity can lead to significant performance degradation in structure learning when dependencies are non-Gaussian.
  • Low Sample Size Performance: The EF model demonstrates impressive performance in high-dimensional settings with very limited data, a common challenge in fields like biology.

Key Results

  • Gaussian MRFs: The EF-X approach achieved comparable accuracy to state-of-the-art methods (ET and glasso) on connected Gaussian MRFs, often with zero false positive edges. For disconnected Gaussian MRFs, EF-X outperformed ET and glasso in terms of accuracy (lowest Hamming distance).
  • Non-Gaussian MRFs: The EF model significantly outperformed competing approaches (ET, glasso, and non-paranormal) in recovering sparse MRFs with Student's t-copula dependencies, achieving lower Hamming distances and higher precision/recall.
  • High-Dimensional, Low Sample Size: In a high-dimensional setting with very low sample size, the EF method recovered almost double the number of edges at a 1% FDR compared to glasso.
  • Immune Cell Data: Analysis of PBMC mass cytometry data revealed that signaling networks frequently exhibit multiple connected components, validating the need for the EF model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • EF-cuts Limitation: The EF-cuts heuristic is computationally prohibitive for graphs with more than two connected components and does not scale well with increasing node or sample size.
  • Optimization Challenges: The learning objectives for the EF model are non-convex, meaning there's no guarantee of finding the global optimum. The authors use a spectral projected gradient (SPG) algorithm for optimization, but initializations are crucial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the EF model is well-suited for other high-dimensional real-world settings with non-trivial dependencies. The paper also mentions that the EF model can be extended to discrete distributions. Further exploration of different copula families and more advanced optimization techniques could be future directions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{arvaniti2014markov,
  author = {Eirini Arvaniti and Manfred Claassen},
  title = {{Markov Network Structure Learning via Ensemble-of-Forests Models}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure