Market Structure Analysis of Revenue of International Construction Professional Service (I-CPS): A Country-Level Analysis

Kangwook LeeSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the global market structure of International Construction Professional Services (I-CPS) by examining the revenue of top international design firms (TIDFs) over a decade. It reveals a significant shift in market dominance from Europe and the US towards Canada and China, highlighting the dynamic and often unstable nature of this knowledge-intensive industry. The findings offer a country-level perspective on competitiveness, crucial for firms and nations navigating this evolving landscape.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The International Construction Professional Service (I-CPS) sector, encompassing architecture, engineering, and consultancy, is a vital knowledge-intensive professional service (KIPS) that drives significant economic activity. However, this market has faced stagnation due to global uncertainties. For I-CPS firms, continuous growth and survival are paramount, making a country's competitiveness in supporting these firms increasingly important. Understanding the market structure – how competition unfolds between countries and firms – is key to identifying future opportunities and developing effective strategies. This paper addresses the need for a quantitative analysis of the I-CPS market structure at a country level, focusing on how revenue distribution and firm dynamics vary across different nations.

Methods

The study employs a quantitative approach to analyze the I-CPS market structure. It utilizes two primary analytical frameworks:

  • Static Analysis: This involves measuring market concentration using the Concentration Ratio (CR4), which calculates the aggregate market share of the top four firms. This metric helps understand market power and entry barriers.
  • Dynamic Analysis: This focuses on the evolution of market positions over time. It employs the TURN model to assess market mobility (the shift of market share between entrants, continuing firms, and exiting firms) and market instability. Market instability is further evaluated using CORSH (correlation coefficient of firm shares) and REGSH (regression coefficient of firm shares) statistics, which indicate the stability of revenue structures.

The study analyzes data from the Engineering News-Record's (ENR) Top 225/200 International Design Firms List for the decade 2011-2021.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is the Engineering News-Record's (ENR) Top 225/200 International Design Firms List for the period 2011–2021. This list provides annual rankings and revenue data for international design firms, serving as the basis for calculating market shares, concentration, mobility, and instability indices. The study focuses on the international revenue performance of these firms.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shifting Market Dominance: The I-CPS market is not static; there's a clear trend of market forces moving away from traditional European and US dominance towards emerging powerhouses like Canada and China. This suggests a need for firms to re-evaluate their global strategies.
  • Dynamic vs. Static View: Relying solely on static measures like market concentration can be misleading. The dynamic analysis, looking at mobility and instability, reveals a more nuanced picture of how firms and countries are performing and adapting.
  • Country-Specific Factors Matter: The study strongly implies that a country's environment significantly influences the success and survival of its I-CPS firms. This opens avenues for targeted policy and support mechanisms.
  • Unstable Market Positions: Many countries exhibit unstable market positions, meaning firms are constantly vying for market share. This highlights the highly competitive nature of the I-CPS sector.

Key Results

  • Market Concentration: The overall I-CPS industry is characterized as an "atomistic market" with fierce competition, indicated by a CR4 generally below 0.2500 for most of the decade, though it has shown an upward trend since 2018.
  • Geographic Shifts: The combined market share of Europe and the US declined from 71.9% in 2011 to 56.8% in 2021. Conversely, Canada and China saw their combined share increase from 10.9% to 24.8% during the same period.
  • High Mobility and Instability: Many countries exhibit high market mobility and instability. For instance, the United Arab Emirates, Egypt, and the Republic of Korea show very high mobility indices.
  • Country Categorization: The study categorizes 15 countries into four types based on their static (market concentration) and dynamic (market mobility and instability) characteristics, providing a framework for understanding different competitive environments.
  • Stable vs. Unstable Revenue Structures: Countries like the USA, Australia, France, Denmark, Egypt, and Italy tend to have more stable revenue structures, while others, such as Canada, the UK, and China, show greater instability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope Limitation: The study is limited to the ENR's Top 225/200 International Design Firms list for the past decade. While ENR data is considered reliable, it may not fully represent the entire I-CPS market, particularly smaller firms or those not consistently ranked.
  • Evolutionary Path: The study provides a macro-level analysis but does not delve into the specific evolutionary paths of countries or firms in achieving their competitiveness.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest future research should explore the impact of macro factors like climate change, ESG, and global events on I-CPS firms' financial and non-financial performance. Further in-depth case studies on major countries and firms are recommended to understand competitiveness from a firm-level perspective. Additionally, research into firms' resources, capabilities, profitability, and government support in relation to country competitiveness is proposed.

Summary updated

Abstract

International construction professional service (I-CPS) refers to a knowledge-intensive professional service (KIPS), such as architecture, engineering, and consultancy, which uses technology/human capital as its major input and is better positioned to create new market opportunities and profitability. While the I-CPS market has recently stagnated owing to political, economic, and social uncertainties, the continuous growth and survival of I-CPS firms are becoming an issue, and a country’s competitiveness in supporting these firms is becoming increasingly important. The market structure of an industry results from the competition between countries or firms, which helps identify future market opportunities and establish a timely competitive strategy. The objective of this study is to quantitatively analyze the I-CPS market structure based on top international design firms (TIDFs). This study analyzes the revenue structures of TIDFs by nationality to identify country-specific factors in the I-CPS industry. The Engineering News-Record’s (ENR) Top 225/200 International Design Firms List for the past decade (2011–2021) was used to analyze international revenue in the major 15 countries. This study analyzed the I-CPS industry’s concentration for static analysis, and for dynamic analysis, the rank distribution of TIDFs, their mobility, and instability by firm nationality were analyzed sequentially. The results confirmed that market forces shifted from Europe and USA to Canada and China and that the market position was unstable in many countries. Additionally, this study divides the 15 countries into four static and dynamic combinations: high-static and high-dynamic, high-static and low-dynamic, low-static and high-dynamic, and low-static and low-dynamic. The findings of this study help understand country-level competition in the I-CPS market from a macro perspective, and provide directions for follow-up studies related to the I-CPS market structure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2023market,
  author = {Kangwook Lee},
  title = {{Market Structure Analysis of Revenue of International Construction Professional Service (I-CPS): A Country-Level Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151813836},
}
Figure