Marine boundary layer cloud regimes and POC formation in a CRM coupled to a bulk aerosol scheme

A. Berner, Christopher S. Bretherton, Robert Wood, Andreas MühlbauerAtmospheric 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Marine stratocumulus clouds play a critical role in Earth's radiation budget, yet their transition between different organizational states remains a challenge for climate models. This study utilizes a cloud-resolving model (CRM) coupled with a novel bulk aerosol scheme to investigate the formation of Pockets of Open Cells (POCs) and the underlying aerosol–cloud–precipitation interactions. The results support the existence of two stable cloud regimes—polluted/non-drizzling and clean/drizzling—and identify a self-stabilizing feedback loop that allows POCs to persist within larger cloud decks.

Introduction: The Problem of Cloud Bistability

Marine stratocumulus clouds are often referred to as the planet's "air conditioners" due to their high albedo. A persistent mystery in atmospheric science is the occurrence of Pockets of Open Cells (POCs)—large, stable regions of broken, drizzling clouds embedded within otherwise solid, non-drizzling cloud decks. Understanding whether these represent distinct "regimes" and how they coexist is vital for improving global climate simulations. This research addresses these questions by simulating the delicate balance between turbulence, aerosols, and precipitation.

Methods: Modeling Aerosol-Cloud Interactions

The researchers employed the System for Atmospheric Modeling (SAM), a CRM, integrated with an intermediate-complexity bulk aerosol scheme. This scheme tracks both the mass ($q$) and number concentration ($N$) of a single lognormal accumulation mode of sea salt aerosol.

Schematic of the aerosol mass and number concentration sources and sinks in the bulk aerosol scheme.

The model accounts for surface flux, entrainment from the free troposphere, and various sinks including rainout and interstitial scavenging (the collection of dry aerosol by cloud droplets). The aerosol size distribution is modeled using a log-normal approximation, which is a key component of the scheme's physical parameterization.

Aerosol size distribution showing the log-normal approximation used in the model compared to observations from Clarke et al. (2006).

Simulations were initialized using data from the VOCALS-REx field campaign (Research Flight 06), which observed a mature POC off the Chilean coast. The study utilized extended 2-D simulations (up to 20 days) and a 10-day 3-D simulation to explore long-term system evolution.

Key Insights: Bistability and Feedback Loops

The simulations confirmed the Baker–Charlson hypothesis of atmospheric bistability. Two distinct regimes emerged:

  1. Closed-cell regime: High aerosol concentration, thick clouds, and negligible drizzle.
  2. Open-cell regime: Low aerosol concentration, thin clouds, and heavy drizzle.

Transitions between these states are driven by a "runaway" positive feedback: drizzle removes aerosols, which leads to fewer but larger cloud droplets, further increasing drizzle rates. This transition typically occurs over a 10-hour timescale.

A critical finding is the stabilizing negative feedback that allows POCs to coexist with overcast decks. In a large domain, the reduced entrainment of dry air within the POC slows the growth of the entire boundary layer. This prevents the surrounding overcast clouds from thickening enough to trigger the drizzle-aerosol sink, thereby stabilizing the overcast region and allowing the POC to persist indefinitely.

Results and Conclusions

Both 2-D and 3-D simulations demonstrated that these regimes could persist for days under steady forcing. In some cases, the system exhibited "slow limit cycles," oscillating between thick cloud decks and POC-like states as aerosols were depleted by rain and replenished by entrainment.

While the study provides a robust framework for understanding POC stability, limitations remain. The single-mode aerosol scheme omits the Aitken mode and complex nucleation chemistry, which may be significant in ultra-clean environments. Future work will focus on these complexities and the specific meteorological triggers that initiate the transition from closed to open cells in nature.

Summary updated

Abstract

A cloud-resolving model (CRM) coupled to a new intermediate-complexity bulk aerosol scheme is used to study aerosol–boundary-layer–cloud–precipitation interactions and the development of pockets of open cells (POCs) in subtropical stratocumulus cloud layers. The aerosol scheme prognoses mass and number concentration of a single lognormal accumulation mode with surface and entrainment sources, evolving subject to processing of activated aerosol and scavenging of dry aerosol by clouds and rain. The CRM with the aerosol scheme is applied to a range of steadily forced cases idealized from a well-observed POC. The long-term system evolution is explored with extended two-dimensional (2-D) simulations of up to 20 days, mostly with diurnally averaged insolation and 24 km wide domains, and one 10 day three-dimensional (3-D) simulation. Both 2-D and 3-D simulations support the Baker–Charlson hypothesis of two distinct aerosol–cloud "regimes" (deep/high-aerosol/non-drizzling and shallow/low-aerosol/drizzling) that persist for days; transitions between these regimes, driven by either precipitation scavenging or aerosol entrainment from the free-troposphere (FT), occur on a timescale of ten hours. The system is analyzed using a two-dimensional phase plane with inversion height and boundary layer average aerosol concentrations as state variables; depending on the specified subsidence rate and availability of FT aerosol, these regimes are either stable equilibria or distinct legs of a slow limit cycle. The same steadily forced modeling framework is applied to the coupled development and evolution of a POC and the surrounding overcast boundary layer in a larger 192 km wide domain. An initial 50% aerosol reduction is applied to half of the model domain. This has little effect until the stratocumulus thickens enough to drizzle, at which time the low-aerosol portion transitions into open-cell convection, forming a POC. Reduced entrainment in the POC induces a negative feedback between the areal fraction covered by the POC and boundary layer depth changes. This stabilizes the system by controlling liquid water path and precipitation sinks of aerosol number in the overcast region, while also preventing boundary layer collapse within the POC, allowing the POC and overcast to coexist indefinitely in a quasi-steady equilibrium.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{berner2013marine,
  author = {A. Berner and Christopher S. Bretherton and Robert Wood and Andreas Mühlbauer},
  title = {{Marine boundary layer cloud regimes and POC formation in a CRM coupled to a bulk aerosol scheme}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-13-12549-2013},
}
Figure