Marginalization in Composed Probabilistic Models

Radim JirousekUAI 2000

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel procedural approach to constructing and manipulating multidimensional probability distributions using "composition operators." The authors present a key theorem for marginalizing variables in these composed models, offering a more localized and potentially efficient alternative to traditional graphical models for certain tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Representing and reasoning with high-dimensional probability distributions is a fundamental challenge in artificial intelligence. Traditional methods like Bayesian networks (a type of Graphical Markov Model) use a declarative approach, defining dependence structures via graphs. This paper proposes an alternative, procedural approach where multidimensional distributions are built by composing simpler, low-dimensional ones. The core problem addressed is how to efficiently compute marginal distributions within this compositional framework, especially when eliminating variables that are part of multiple component distributions.

Methods

The paper introduces "composition operators" (specifically, right and left composition, denoted by ▷ and < respectively) that combine two low-dimensional probability distributions into a higher-dimensional one. The focus is on the right composition operator, which is applied iteratively to form a "generating sequence" of distributions. A key concept is "perfect sequences," where the order of composition doesn't affect the final distribution. The main contribution is a theorem that provides a formula for marginalizing a variable from a distribution defined by a general generating sequence, expressing the result in terms of modified component distributions. This theorem offers a way to compute marginals locally, by operating on the component distributions rather than the full, high-dimensional distribution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Procedural vs. Declarative: The paper champions a procedural way of building probability distributions, contrasting it with the declarative nature of graphical models. This shifts the focus from "what are the dependencies?" to "how do we compute the distribution?".
  • Composition Operators: The introduction of composition operators provides a concrete mechanism for building complex distributions from simpler ones, offering a different perspective on model construction.
  • Marginalization as a Local Operation: The central theorem demonstrates that marginalization in this framework can be achieved by modifying and composing the original low-dimensional distributions, rather than performing a global summation over the high-dimensional space. This is a significant departure from traditional methods.
  • Perfect Sequences as a Bridge: The concept of "perfect sequences" is highlighted as a special class where the order of composition doesn't matter, and these sequences are shown to be equivalent to Bayesian networks in terms of representational power.

Key Results

The paper's main result is Theorem 3, which provides a formula for marginalizing a variable l from a distribution formed by a generating sequence P1, P2, ..., Pn. This formula expresses the resulting marginal distribution as a new generating sequence of modified distributions, where the variable l has been effectively eliminated from the relevant component distributions. This offers a structured way to perform marginalization within the compositional framework.

Limitations and Future Work

  • General Sequences vs. Perfect Sequences: While the main marginalization theorem is for general sequences, the paper notes that the concept of perfect sequences is crucial for understanding the connection to Bayesian networks.
  • Decomposable Models: The authors acknowledge that characterizing sequences corresponding to decomposable models is an open problem, particularly when the sets of variables in the generating sequence do not satisfy the running intersection property.
  • Uniform Distributions: The paper mentions that when all distributions in a generating sequence are uniform, the resulting distribution is decomposable, regardless of the variable sets. This suggests further avenues for research.
  • Possibilistic Distributions: The paper briefly touches upon the extension of composition operators to possibilistic distributions, suggesting a uniform approach to studying multidimensional distributions in both probability and possibility theories.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{jirousek2000marginalization,
  author = {Radim Jirousek},
  title = {{Marginalization in Composed Probabilistic Models}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2000},
}

Loading related content...

Figure