Mapping the Landscape of Carbon-Neutral City Research: Dynamic Evolution and Emerging Frontiers

Yang Miao, Le Yang, Feng Chen, Jiawei ChenSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of carbon-neutral city research, revealing its dynamic evolution and emerging frontiers. It highlights that while research is extensive, particularly in China, collaboration among researchers is insufficient, suggesting a need for greater knowledge sharing to accelerate progress towards global carbon neutrality goals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global imperative to combat climate change has led to a surge in research on carbon-neutral cities. However, despite widespread attention, a holistic understanding of how this research landscape has evolved, its key themes, and its future directions has been lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically mapping the field, identifying its current frontiers, and providing insights for future research and policy development. It addresses the need for a comprehensive overview that goes beyond singular perspectives to offer a more integrated understanding of carbon-neutral city development.

Methods

The study employs bibliometric analysis and knowledge mapping techniques using CiteSpace software. The researchers analyzed a substantial corpus of literature from both Chinese (CNKI) and international (Web of Science) databases. Key analytical methods included:

  • Publication Volume Analysis: Tracking the number of published articles over time to understand research trends and growth.
  • Discipline Statistics: Categorizing research by academic discipline to identify interdisciplinary contributions.
  • Author Cooperation Analysis: Visualizing author networks to assess collaboration patterns and identify potential gaps.
  • Keyword Frequency and Timeline Analysis: Identifying prominent research themes and their evolution over time through keyword co-occurrence and timeline views.
  • Institution and Journal Analysis: Identifying leading institutions and journals in the field.
  • Citation Analysis: Identifying highly cited articles to understand influential research.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  • CNKI (China National Knowledge Infrastructure): A comprehensive database of Chinese academic literature.
  • Web of Science (WOS): A global, multidisciplinary citation index.

The search terms used were "low carbon" OR "carbon-neutral" OR "carbon peak" AND "city". After initial retrieval and manual screening to remove non-research literature, the final datasets comprised:

  • 2185 Chinese literature samples (2002-2022)
  • 2206 international literature samples (2002-2022)

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Global Research Lag: International research on carbon-neutral cities emerged earlier (2002) and grew rapidly, while Chinese research, though extensive, lagged by about two years.
  • Interdisciplinary Nature: Carbon-neutral city research is inherently multidisciplinary, spanning environmental science, economics, engineering, and urban planning.
  • Collaboration Deficit: Despite a growing number of researchers, the knowledge map reveals a lack of strong author cooperation and aggregation, indicating insufficient exchanges and potential for enhanced collaboration.
  • China's Leading Role: China has demonstrated extensive and fruitful research in this field, positioning itself at the forefront, largely driven by its universities and research institutions.
  • Divergent Focus Areas: While Chinese research often centers on low-carbon cities, industrial structure, and transportation, international research leans more towards urban governance, carbon emissions, and measurement methodologies.
  • Core Themes Remain Consistent: Key research themes like "low-carbon city," "low-carbon economy," and "carbon emission" have shown remarkable continuity since their initial emergence.

Key Results

  • Publication Trends: Research saw a significant upward trend globally starting around 2009, with a peak in China in 2011, followed by a dip and a rebound in 2020.
  • Dominant Disciplines: Environmental science and resource utilization are prominent in China, while international research is heavily focused on environmental science, energy, and engineering.
  • Leading Institutions: Tongji University, Tsinghua University, and Beijing University are among the top institutions in China, while the Chinese Academy of Sciences leads internationally.
  • Key Journals: In China, "China Population, Resources and Environment" is a leading journal. Internationally, "Journal of Cleaner Production" and "Sustainability" are prominent.
  • Most Cited Articles: Highly cited articles in China often focus on low-carbon economy and urbanization strategies, while international top-cited papers address transition paths, carbon metabolism, and emissions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their scientometric review might have overlooked publications outside of peer-reviewed journals and conference proceedings (i.e., gray literature). They suggest that future work could delve deeper into specific sub-themes within carbon-neutral city research and incorporate a broader range of literature. The study also points to the need for researchers to conduct more analyses of multi-system coupling and mechanisms, given the diverse and intersecting nature of research themes. The findings strongly suggest a need for increased collaboration and information exchange among researchers to accelerate progress in this critical field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon-neutral city research has attracted widespread attention. However, a comprehensive review of this research has not been conducted, and it is unclear how the various perspectives have evolved. In this study, CNKI and Web of Science were used as data sources. By summarizing the research results of carbon-neutral cities in recent years, the dynamics evolution trend is revealed, and the frontiers are explored. We found that: (1) the themes and contents of carbon-neutral city research were diverse and intersecting and mainly focused on energy, industrial structure, transportation, and building. (2) The knowledge map of author cooperation did not show many aggregates, which indicated that the cooperation and exchanges between relevant researchers are insufficient. (3) Chinese research on carbon-neutral cities was extensive and fruitful, taking the lead in the research in this field. Based on the current situation and trends, we provided a scientific reference for the development of carbon-neutral cities. Current research foci and cutting-edge findings will help to make cities more climate resilient, sustainable and livable. Understanding and magnifying these foci is what will help countries achieve their climate mitigation and carbon neutrality goals sooner rather than later.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{miao2024mapping,
  author = {Yang Miao and Le Yang and Feng Chen and Jiawei Chen},
  title = {{Mapping the Landscape of Carbon-Neutral City Research: Dynamic Evolution and Emerging Frontiers}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16166733},
}
Figure