Mapping the Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy:The Second Flight of the QMAP Experiment

Tom Herbig, A. de Oliveira‐Costa, Michelle Devlin, Amber Miller, Lyman A. Page, Max TegmarkThe Astrophysical Journal 1998 · DOI

Abstract

We report the results from the second flight of QMAP, an experiment to map the cosmic microwave background near the North Celestial Pole. We present maps of the sky at 31 and 42 GHz as well as a measurement of the angular power spectrum covering the l-range 40-200. Anisotropy is detected at about 20 sigma and is in agreement with previous results at these angular scales. We also report details of the data reduction and analysis techniques which were used for both flights of QMAP.

Introduction

In the late 1990s, the race to map the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB)—the thermal relic of the Big Bang—was at a critical juncture. While the COBE satellite had successfully detected large-scale temperature fluctuations and ground-based experiments like Saskatoon had probed smaller scales, a significant gap remained in the intermediate "multipole" range ($l \approx 40–200$). Ground-based observations in this range are frequently compromised by atmospheric noise. The Quantitative Microwave Anisotropy Probe (QMAP) was designed to overcome these limitations by utilizing a balloon-borne telescope to observe from the stratosphere. This paper details the findings from QMAP’s second flight, which successfully bridged this angular scale gap with high-fidelity data.

Experimental Methods

QMAP operated from a high-altitude balloon at approximately 30 km, effectively eliminating the "flicker" noise caused by Earth's atmosphere. The instrument utilized six radiometry channels: two at Ka-band (31 GHz) and four at Q-band (42 GHz).

A cornerstone of the mission was its unique scanning strategy. The telescope employed an interlocking scan pattern, combining a fast 4.6 Hz sinusoidal "chop" with a slower "wobble" of the entire assembly. This dual-modulation approach was critical for breaking the $180^\circ$ phase degeneracy common in single-modulation scans and provided the redundancy necessary to mitigate systematic instrumental errors. Pointing was maintained via a CCD camera tracking guide stars, supplemented by a three-axis magnetometer. Calibration was performed using the supernova remnant Cassiopeia A (Cas A) as a standard flux candle.

Mapping and Data Analysis

The second flight gathered approximately 22.4 million radiometry samples over eight hours. Using Wiener filtering for visualization and a signal-to-noise eigenmode expansion for analysis, the team produced high-sensitivity maps covering 83 deg² near the North Celestial Pole.

CMB temperature maps at Ka-band, Q-band, and combined (All).

To ensure the signals were cosmic rather than instrumental, the team generated "difference maps" between polarization pairs. While individual maps showed strong signals, the difference maps were consistent with pure noise, confirming that the detected anisotropy originated from the sky.

Key Results: Bridging the Cosmological Gap

The experiment achieved a detection of CMB anisotropy at a $20\sigma$ confidence level. The resulting angular power spectrum provided a crucial "handshake" between the large-scale measurements of COBE and the small-scale measurements of ground-based arrays.

The angular power spectrum measured by QMAP2 compared with COBE and Saskatoon (SK) data.

Specific temperature fluctuation measurements included $\delta T_l \approx 56 \mu K$ at $l \approx 125$ (Q-band) and values of $46 \mu K$ and $63 \mu K$ at $l \approx 91$ and $145$ (Ka-band), respectively. These results were in excellent agreement with the emerging standard model of cosmology, reinforcing the theory that these fluctuations represent the seeds of large-scale cosmic structures.

Limitations and Legacy

Despite its success, the flight faced technical challenges, including repeated freezes of the attitude computer and data buffer overflows. These issues required complex post-processing to correct timing offsets. Additionally, the primary source of uncertainty (8.7%) stemmed from the flux density model of the calibration source, Cas A.

The QMAP mission laid essential groundwork for subsequent satellite missions like WMAP and Planck. By demonstrating the efficacy of stratospheric observations and sophisticated scanning strategies, it provided a vital link in our understanding of the early universe's evolution.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report the results from the second flight of QMAP, an experiment to map the cosmic microwave background near the North Celestial Pole. We present maps of the sky at 31 and 42 GHz as well as a measurement of the angular power spectrum covering the l-range 40-200. Anisotropy is detected at about 20 sigma and is in agreement with previous results at these angular scales. We also report details of the data reduction and analysis techniques which were used for both flights of QMAP.
BibTeX
@article{herbig1998mapping,
  author = {Tom Herbig and A. de Oliveira‐Costa and Michelle Devlin and Amber Miller and Lyman A. Page and Max Tegmark},
  title = {{Mapping the Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy:The Second Flight of the QMAP Experiment}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.1086/311768},
}

Loading related content...

Figure