Mapping Sensory Spots for Moderate Temperatures on the Back of Hand

Fan Yang, Guixu Chen, Sikai Zhou, Danhong Han, Jingjing Xu, Shengyong Xu2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study maps the precise locations of human sensory spots for moderate temperatures (40-50°C) on the back of the hand. The findings reveal a surprisingly low density of these spots, irregular distribution patterns, and significant asymmetry between left and right hands, offering valuable insights for designing advanced electronic skin and wearable devices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how humans sense temperature is crucial for developing sophisticated electronic skin (e-skin) and wearable devices that can mimic or augment our natural sensory capabilities. While we know that specialized receptors called thermoreceptors, particularly Transient Receptor Potential (TRP) channels, are responsible for detecting temperature, the precise spatial distribution of these sensory "spots" on the skin, especially for moderate temperatures, remains largely uncharacterized. Previous studies have often focused on smaller skin areas or different temperature ranges, leaving a gap in our knowledge about how these sensory networks are organized. This lack of detailed mapping hinders the design of e-skin that can accurately replicate or interact with our natural thermosensation.

Methods

The researchers developed a specialized thermal probe with a 0.5 mm diameter tip and a precise temperature control system, capable of maintaining temperatures between 40-50°C with an accuracy of ±0.3°C. To ensure objective results, a blind-test protocol was implemented: subjects wore sleeping masks, and the probe was moved by one tester while another controlled the temperature and recorded the subject's feedback. Subjects indicated a "hot" sensation only when it was distinctly different from tactile sensation. The back of the hand was chosen as the testing area due to the palm's high sensitivity to tactile stimuli, which could confound temperature perception. The skin was gridded into 1.0 x 1.0 cm² squares, allowing for a spatial resolution of 1.0 mm. Each point was tested for two seconds, with a two-second break between points.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from human subjects. Two rounds of experiments were conducted:

  • First round: Four Chinese college students (two female, two male) were tested.
  • Second round: Ten more healthy students (five female, five male, including left-handed individuals) were tested to investigate potential differences related to handedness.

No pre-existing datasets were used; the data was generated specifically for this research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sparse Sensory Network: The number of sensory spots for moderate temperatures on the back of the hand is remarkably low, significantly lower than densities reported in previous studies on different body parts or temperature ranges. This suggests that our thermosensory system might be more localized than previously assumed.
  • Irregular and Asymmetric Distribution: Sensory spots are not evenly distributed across the hand. Their locations are highly irregular and vary significantly between individuals. Crucially, there's a pronounced asymmetry between the left and right hands of the same individual, both in the number and location of sensory spots.
  • Temperature-Dependent Spot Activation: The number of sensory spots increases with rising testing temperatures within the 40-50°C range. However, only a small fraction of these spots maintain their location across different temperatures; new spots tend to appear at different locations as the temperature increases.
  • Potential for E-skin Design: The findings provide crucial spatial information that can guide the development of e-skin. Understanding the density and distribution of natural sensory spots can help engineers design artificial sensors that are strategically placed to mimic human perception.
  • Implications for Developmental Biology: The observed asymmetry between hands hints at complex developmental processes, potentially related to asymmetric cell division in neural development, which warrants further investigation.

Key Results

  • For a testing temperature of 40.0°C, subject 'a' had 24 sensory spots on her left hand and 12 on her right. Subject 'd' had as few as 5 and 7 spots on her left and right hands, respectively.
  • At 45.0°C, subject 'a' had 34 spots on her left and 20 on her right, while subject 'd' had 8 and 9 spots.
  • The number of sensory spots generally increased with temperature. For instance, subject 'β' showed an increase in sensory spots from 40.0°C to 47.5°C.
  • At 50.0°C, the back of the hand generally elicited an "insufferable burning tingling sensation" for most subjects, suggesting a different sensory mechanism or activation of more receptors at higher temperatures. However, fingers were more tolerant.
  • In the second round of experiments, male subjects M3 and M4 had as few as 2-3 sensory spots at 40.0°C.
  • No clear correlation was found between sensory spot distribution and hand usage habits (left-handed vs. right-handed).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the number of subjects was relatively small, and the study focused on a specific demographic (young Chinese college students). They suggest that further research with a larger and more diverse subject pool, including individuals of different ages and ethnicities, is necessary to fully understand the underlying mechanisms of sensory spot distribution. Additionally, exploring different testing areas and temperature ranges would provide a more comprehensive picture. The paper also highlights the need for further investigation into the developmental and biological factors contributing to the observed asymmetry between left and right hands. The findings also suggest that the intense sensation at 50.0°C might involve different TRP channels or mechanisms, meriting further exploration.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{yang2017mapping,
  author = {Fan Yang and Guixu Chen and Sikai Zhou and Danhong Han and Jingjing Xu and Shengyong Xu},
  title = {{Mapping Sensory Spots for Moderate Temperatures on the Back of Hand}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/s17122802},
}
Figure