Mapping of Whole-Brain Resting-State Networks with Half-Millimetre Resolution

Seong Dae Yun, Patricia Pais‐Roldán, Nicola Palomero‐Gallagher, N. Jon ShahbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel fMRI technique, TR-external EPIK, that achieves unprecedented whole-brain coverage at a half-millimeter resolution. This advancement allows for more detailed mapping of resting-state brain networks and reveals fine-grained anatomical structures previously unseen with fMRI.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mapping brain networks using resting-state functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) is crucial for understanding brain function and connectivity. However, achieving high spatial resolution in fMRI has been a significant challenge. Existing methods often struggle to balance high resolution with whole-brain coverage, leading to trade-offs where either the detail is lost or only a portion of the brain can be scanned. This limitation hinders the ability to study how spatially distributed brain regions interact and to identify subtle anatomical features that might be relevant for understanding neurological conditions.

Methods

The core innovation presented is a new fMRI method called TR-external EPI with keyhole (TR-external EPIK). This technique combines two key elements:

  • EPIK (Echo-Planar Imaging with Keyhole): This method uses a "keyhole" approach where the central part of k-space (containing most of the signal information) is fully sampled, while the peripheral k-space is sampled more sparsely. This allows for faster data acquisition.
  • TR-external EPI phase correction: This technique involves a separate, low-flip-angle excitation loop to acquire navigator echoes. This helps to shorten the echo time (TE), which is crucial for maintaining signal quality at high field strengths like 7 Tesla.

By integrating these, TR-external EPIK achieves a nominal spatial resolution of 0.51 x 0.51 x 1.00 mm³ (a voxel volume of 0.26 mm³) while maintaining whole-brain coverage. The method also incorporates acceleration techniques like partial Fourier, parallel imaging, and multi-band acceleration to further enhance efficiency.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 18 healthy volunteers. Resting-state fMRI data were acquired using the developed TR-external EPIK protocol. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the performance of the new method was compared against existing submillimeter-resolution fMRI studies from the literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unprecedented Resolution and Coverage: The most significant insight is the successful demonstration of whole-brain fMRI at a half-millimeter resolution. This breaks previous limitations where high resolution came at the cost of limited brain coverage.
  • Revealing Mesoscale Anatomy: The high-resolution images allowed for the visualization of fine anatomical structures, such as small cerebral vessels and the internal granular layer of the cortex, which are typically not discernible with standard fMRI.
  • Robust Resting-State Network Mapping: The method proved effective in identifying and mapping various resting-state brain networks across the entire brain from a single fMRI session.
  • Reproducibility: The study demonstrated the reproducibility of resting-state network detection across multiple subjects, highlighting the reliability of the TR-external EPIK protocol.
  • Potential for Cortical Depth-Dependent Studies: The ability to resolve signals within the cortical ribbon suggests that TR-external EPIK could be valuable for future studies investigating activity at different cortical depths.

Key Results

  • Spatial Resolution: Achieved a nominal spatial resolution of 0.51 x 0.51 x 1.00 mm³ (0.26 mm³ voxel).
  • Brain Coverage: Provided whole-brain coverage, a significant improvement over previous high-resolution methods.
  • Anatomical Detail: Successfully visualized mesoscale anatomical structures like small cerebral vessels and the internal granular layer of the cortex.
  • Network Identification: Identified six well-known resting-state networks (dorsal-DMN, ventral-DMN, visual, sensorimotor (LH), sensorimotor (RH), and fronto-parietal) in individual subjects.
  • Reproducibility: Resting-state networks were reliably detected across 13 subjects, demonstrating consistent performance.
  • Imaging Performance Comparison: TR-external EPIK demonstrated the largest brain volume coverage (4762.80 cm³) and the smallest voxel volume (0.26 mm³) compared to other submillimeter-resolution studies, leading to a significantly higher number of voxels per temporal volume (17.98 M).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Comparison Fairness: The authors acknowledge the difficulty of performing a perfectly fair comparison between different methods due to varying imaging conditions.
  • Event-Related fMRI: While effective for resting-state, the use of EPIK for event-related fMRI, which requires faster peripheral k-space updates, needs further investigation.
  • Potential for T1-Contrast: The high spatial resolution of TR-external EPIK suggests it could potentially be used as a substitute for anatomical imaging (like MPRAGE) if T1-contrast is incorporated, which could reduce co-registration errors. This is an area for future studies.
  • Non-BOLD Contrasts: While the paper focused on BOLD, the authors suggest that TR-external EPIK could be adapted for other non-BOLD contrasts (e.g., ASL, VASO) to gain complementary information, though this would require further development.
  • Susceptibility Artifacts: While EPIK can alleviate geometric distortions, further investigation into its benefits for brain regions prone to susceptibility artifacts (like frontal and temporal lobes) is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Resting-state fMRI has been used in numerous studies to map networks in the brain that employ spatially disparate regions. However, attempts to map networks with high spatial resolution have been hampered by conflicting technical demands and associated problems. Results from recent fMRI studies have shown that spatial resolution remains around 0.7 × 0.7 × 0.7 mm 3 , with only partial brain coverage. This work presents a novel fMRI method, TR-external EPI with keyhole (TR-external EPIK), which can provide a nominal spatial resolution of 0.51 × 0.51 × 1.00 mm 3 (0.26 mm 3 voxel) with whole-brain coverage. TR-external EPIK enabled the identification of various resting-state networks distributed throughout the brain from a single fMRI session, with mapping fidelity onto the grey matter at 7T. The high-resolution functional image further revealed mesoscale anatomical structures, such as small cerebral vessels and the internal granular layer of the cortex within the postcentral gyrus.
BibTeX
@misc{yun2021mapping,
  author = {Seong Dae Yun and Patricia Pais‐Roldán and Nicola Palomero‐Gallagher and N. Jon Shah},
  title = {{Mapping of Whole-Brain Resting-State Networks with Half-Millimetre Resolution}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.03.09.434629},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure