TL;DR
This paper explores the burgeoning coffee culture in Yunnan, China, a region historically known as the "land of tea." It details the rapid growth of coffee production and consumption, driven by a complex network of local and international actors, and examines how this new culture is shaping a distinct Chinese identity.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China is globally recognized as the "land of tea," with a deeply ingrained tea culture. However, the paper addresses the phenomenon of a rapidly emerging coffee culture, particularly in Yunnan province, which now accounts for 99% of China's coffee production. The authors investigate how this new coffee culture is developing, the actors involved, and its implications for both local economies and broader societal trends, challenging the traditional perception of China as solely a tea-drinking nation.
Methods
The research employs a mixed-methods approach, combining extensive literature review of both Chinese and English sources with recurrent ethnographic fieldwork. This fieldwork involved direct observation and interaction with coffee actors in Kunming, Dali, Pu'er, and Menglian since 2013. The study also incorporates netnography, a form of online ethnography, to understand the evolving coffee landscape.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on literature and fieldwork rather than formal datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Yunnan as a Coffee Hub: Despite its "land of tea" reputation, Yunnan has become China's primary coffee-producing region, with a history dating back to the early 20th century.
- From Producer to Consumer to "Prosumer": The paper highlights how coffee consumption in China is evolving, with consumers increasingly becoming "prosumers" who are actively involved in the coffee trade, from understanding bean origins to opening their own coffee shops.
- Emergence of New Coffee Experts: A new ecosystem of coffee professionals, including baristas, consultants, entrepreneurs, and machine makers, is rapidly developing, showcasing fluidity and innovation.
- Global and Local Interplay: The growth of coffee culture is driven by a complex web of interconnected actors, including transnational corporations (TNCs) like Nestlé and Starbucks, alongside local entrepreneurs and farmers.
- "Resource-Rich" Entrepreneurs: A new generation of entrepreneurs, often with international education and business acumen, are investing in and innovating within the Yunnan coffee industry, aiming to elevate its quality and global reputation.
- Coffee as a "Postmodern" Lifestyle Marker: For urban millennials and "xiaozi" (a term for urban, sophisticated youth), coffee consumption and coffeehouse culture serve as markers of an aspirational lifestyle and a form of performing a modern Chinese identity.
- Coffeehouses as "Third Places": Coffeehouses in Kunming are evolving into "third places" that offer a quiet haven for personal enjoyment and social interaction, contrasting with the more boisterous atmosphere of traditional Chinese restaurants and teahouses.
- Distinct Chinese Coffee Identity: There's a growing aspiration among Yunnan coffee actors to create a distinctive Chinese coffee identity, moving beyond simply producing beans for export.
Key Results
- Yunnan province produces 99% of China's coffee.
- The coffee industry in Yunnan has seen rapid development since the 1990s, supported by government initiatives and TNC investment.
- A significant number of new coffee-related jobs have emerged, indicating a dynamic and growing sector.
- The study identified numerous coffee houses in Kunming, particularly on Wen Lin Street, catering to a diverse clientele.
- Interviews with 20 individuals in Kunming revealed a growing appreciation for coffee quality, taste, and the overall coffeehouse experience.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Scope: The paper focuses primarily on Yunnan province and Kunming city, acknowledging that this may not represent the entirety of China's coffee culture.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that while coffee culture has taken root in China, it has not yet "come into full bloom." They anticipate that coffee will become a significant cultural element, coexisting with tea rather than replacing it, contributing to a broader "cup of humanity." Further research could explore the long-term impact of this evolving culture and the development of a unique Chinese coffee identity.
Summary updated