MapOnLearn: The Use of Maps in Online Learning Systems for Education Sustainability

Sannyuya Liu, Dongpo Guo, Jianwen Sun, Jie Yu, Dongbo ZhouSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces MapOnLearn, a novel method for organizing and visualizing online learning resources using a 2D map interface. By transforming traditional hierarchical course structures into interactive maps, MapOnLearn aims to enhance student engagement, facilitate personalized learning, and ultimately promote educational sustainability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rise of online learning, accelerated by global events like the COVID-19 pandemic, presents challenges in maintaining student engagement and ensuring equitable access to educational resources. Traditional online learning systems often rely on linear, hierarchical structures (like tree diagrams or tables) that can be overwhelming, difficult to navigate, and fail to foster deep learning or persistence. This can lead to low course completion rates and a less than ideal learning experience. The authors argue that existing methods struggle to manage the vast amount of learning resources effectively and make them easily accessible, hindering the potential for personalized and interactive learning crucial for educational sustainability.

Methods

The core of MapOnLearn is a unique mapping method that transforms hierarchical course units (HCUs) and knowledge points (KPs) into a 2D map. This process involves:

  • Hierarchical to 2D Map Conversion: Tree-like course structures are converted into a 2D map composed of hierarchically divided polygons. This map serves as a container for all learning resources.
  • Zoomable Interface: A zoom feature allows users to navigate through different levels of detail, expressing the hierarchical knowledge structure. This mimics the experience of using public map services like Google Maps.
  • Path Analysis: The learning process is visualized using path analysis, showing how students progress through the material.
  • Topological Processing: Relationships between HCUs and KPs are represented using topological processing, providing a more nuanced understanding of connections.
  • Cartographic Principles: The visualization employs cartographic principles for shape, color, and annotation to enhance clarity and cognitive understanding. For instance, different knowledge categories are represented by distinct shapes (e.g., triangles for factual knowledge, rectangles for conceptual knowledge), and polygon sizes are influenced by information volume.
  • Resource Organization: Learning resources are dynamically assigned to specific polygons (Voronoi polygons for finer granularity) within the map, making them easily accessible.

Datasets

The authors tested their MapOnLearn method on three university courses in China:

  • A high-level mathematics course
  • A data structures course
  • An English course

Data for these courses were extracted from textbooks and supplemented with learning resources provided by teachers. The evaluation involved 264 students and 27 teachers who participated in a semester-long study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Maps as Learning Portals: The paper proposes a paradigm shift from linear text-based learning to a map-centric approach, treating the map as an interactive portal to educational resources.
  • Mimicking Geospatial Exploration: By adopting a Google Maps-style interface, MapOnLearn leverages users' familiarity with map navigation to make online learning more intuitive and engaging.
  • Personalized Learning Pathways: The ability to visualize learning progress and access resources dynamically through the map supports self-paced learning and caters to individual needs.
  • Bridging Abstract and Concrete: For subjects like mathematics, the map visualization helps make abstract concepts more concrete, potentially reducing cognitive load.
  • Attracting and Retaining Learners: The interactive and visually appealing nature of the map-based system is hypothesized to increase student engagement and time spent on learning platforms, contributing to educational sustainability.

Key Results

The study found that the MapOnLearn method had a positive impact on how teachers and students used online learning systems, leading to an improved online learning experience. Specifically:

  • Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) Findings: The evaluation, based on TAM, indicated that perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use of MapOnLearn were positively correlated with behavioral intention to use the system.
  • Perceived usefulness had a moderate significant effect on behavioral intention (r = 0.665, p < 0.001).
  • Perceived ease of use had a positive effect on behavioral intention (r = 0.700, p < 0.001).
  • Usefulness and ease of use were strongly positively related (r = 0.701, p < 0.001).
  • Qualitative Feedback: Teachers and students found the map approach attractive and easy to understand, facilitating better comprehension and retention of learned material. Some teachers noted that it made abstract knowledge more concrete.
  • Engagement: The interactive nature of the map was found to be particularly appealing to younger students, potentially increasing their interest and time spent on learning.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Sample Size: The quantitative and qualitative study samples were relatively small and may not be fully representative. Future work should expand the sample size.
  • Generalizability: While the method aims for universality, further research is needed to explore its applicability across a wider range of disciplines and learning contexts.
  • Map Generation Rules: The rules for map generation (e.g., sharp shapes, colors, relationships) could be further refined and combined with 2D topological relationships.
  • User Diversity: Future development should consider the diverse needs of users across different ages, genders, and personalities.
  • System Integration: The paper focused on the map generation method itself, not the full integration into existing learning systems. Further research could explore seamless integration.
  • Cognitive and Neuroscientific Validation: The authors suggest collaborating with cognitive scientists and neuroscientists to further validate the effectiveness of the map-based browsing learning style.

Summary updated

Abstract

Online learning and teaching have become the primary forms of education during the global pandemic, and online learning systems, which can provide fair educational opportunities for everyone, are increasingly important for sustainability in education. The amount of time a student spends on online learning systems affects the fairness and persistence of sustainability in education. To support personalized learning opportunities, interactive learning, and easy-to-access resources, we propose a map organization and visualization method called MapOnLearn for online learning systems. First, we converted tree-like hierarchical course units (HCUs) and knowledge points (KPs) into a fundamental two-dimensional (2D) map of hierarchically divided polygons and used the map to form containers to manage all learning resources. Then, we used the zoom feature of the map to express the hierarchical structures of knowledge and formulated corresponding rules for displaying information at different levels. Path analysis was applied to express the learning process, and topological processing was adapted to represent the relationships among HCUs and KPs. We developed maps for a high-level math course, a course on data structures, and an English course at a university in China and investigated 264 students and 27 teachers for a semester by using the technology acceptance model (TAM). We found that the map visualization and organization method had a positive impact on the way teachers and students use online learning systems and improved the online learning experience. To attract more students to spend more time on online learning, we hope our method can promote the sustainable development of education.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020maponlearn,
  author = {Sannyuya Liu and Dongpo Guo and Jianwen Sun and Jie Yu and Dongbo Zhou},
  title = {{MapOnLearn: The Use of Maps in Online Learning Systems for Education Sustainability}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12177018},
}
Figure