MAP Estimation for Graphical Models by Likelihood Maximization

Akshat Kumar, Shlomo ZilbersteinNeurIPS 2010 · OpenReview

Introduction

Finding the "most likely" configuration of variables in a graphical model—known as Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) estimation—is a cornerstone of machine learning, with applications ranging from computer vision to protein folding. However, for most real-world graphs, this problem is NP-hard.

The current "gold standard" for solving MAP estimation involves using Linear Programming (LP) relaxations, such as the MPLP algorithm. While these methods are powerful because they provide an upper bound on the solution (indicating how close the result is to the perfect answer), they struggle significantly with scalability. In dense graphs where every variable interacts with many others, the computational cost per iteration becomes prohibitive, making it difficult to obtain a high-quality answer quickly.

This paper introduces a novel approach to solving the MAP estimation problem by reframing it as a likelihood maximization task. By decomposing a complex Markov Random Field (MRF) into a mixture of simple Bayes nets and applying the Expectation Maximization (EM) algorithm, the authors achieve near-optimal solutions significantly faster than traditional LP relaxation methods.

A New Perspective: Likelihood Maximization

The authors propose a fundamental shift in perspective. Instead of relaxing the constraints of the problem (an "outer bound" approach like LP), they restrict the space of probability distributions to a simpler, factored form (an "inner bound" approach).

The methodology relies on three key transformations:

  1. Mixture of Bayes Nets: The complex MRF is transformed into a finite mixture of very simple, depth-1 Bayes nets. Each Bayes net represents a single edge of the original graph.
  2. The Reward Variable: A special binary "reward variable" ($\hat{\theta}$) is introduced. The authors prove that maximizing the likelihood of observing this reward variable is mathematically equivalent to solving the original MAP problem.
  3. EM Algorithm: A specific Expectation Maximization (EM) algorithm is derived to maximize this likelihood. The M-step updates the marginal probabilities for each node.
Transformation of an MRF into a mixture of simple Bayes nets.

The resulting update equations resemble a graph-based message-passing paradigm, similar to the well-known max-product algorithm, but they are computationally much leaner.

The Key Innovation: In traditional algorithms like MPLP, the complexity of sending a message depends heavily on the number of neighbors a node has ($O(d^2 \cdot deg)$). In this new EM approach, the complexity is independent of the degree ($O(d^2)$). This decoupling of neighbor influence during the update step bypasses the primary bottleneck that slows down traditional message-passing in dense networks. Furthermore, unlike MPLP which often requires sequential updates, the EM updates are "embarrassingly parallel," allowing every node's marginal to be updated simultaneously.

Experimental Results

The primary evaluation was performed on a notoriously difficult Protein Design Dataset consisting of 97 instances. These problems involve up to 170 variables with large domains (up to 150 possible values per variable) and high edge density (average degree around 30).

The EM approach demonstrated remarkable improvements over existing methods:

  • Speed: EM was significantly faster than MPLP and Max-Product. In dense protein design problems, the speedup factor per iteration was as high as 30x.
  • Convergence: On the largest instance ('1fpo'), EM reached a high-quality solution in roughly 350 seconds, whereas competing methods took much longer to reach comparable levels.
  • Quality: Despite the speed, EM achieved a solution quality within 95% of the optimal for most protein design instances, consistently outperforming standard Max-Product in head-to-head tests within the same number of iterations.
Performance comparison on the '1fpo' protein design instance showing EM's rapid convergence compared to MPLP.

Limitations and Future Directions

While highly efficient, the EM approach has limitations. As with most EM-based methods, the algorithm is not guaranteed to find the global maximum and can get stuck in local optima. Additionally, the method struggles with "reward scaling"—when there is a massive disparity between minimum and maximum potential values, the normalization process can squash meaningful differences, leading to poorer performance on certain instances.

Looking forward, the authors suggest a "hybrid" future where EM quickly finds a high-quality solution (a lower bound) while LP methods work in tandem to tighten the certificate of optimality (the upper bound). Future work may also incorporate advanced clustering techniques into the EM framework to avoid local optima and leverage distributed systems like MapReduce to fully exploit the algorithm's inherent parallelism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Computing a {\em maximum a posteriori} (MAP) assignment in graphical models is a crucial inference problem for many practical applications. Several provably convergent approaches have been successfully developed using linear programming (LP) relaxation of the MAP problem. We present an alternative approach, which transforms the MAP problem into that of inference in a finite mixture of simple Bayes nets. We then derive the Expectation Maximization (EM) algorithm for this mixture that also monotonically increases a lower bound on the MAP assignment until convergence. The update equations for the EM algorithm are remarkably simple, both conceptually and computationally, and can be implemented using a graph-based message passing paradigm similar to max-product computation. We experiment on the real-world protein design dataset and show that EM's convergence rate is significantly higher than the previous LP relaxation based approach MPLP. EM achieves a solution quality within $95$\% of optimal for most instances and is often an order-of-magnitude faster than MPLP.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kumar2010map,
  author = {Akshat Kumar and Shlomo Zilberstein},
  title = {{MAP Estimation for Graphical Models by Likelihood Maximization}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2010},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=B1Z9XvZOZS},
}
Figure