Many facets of multiparty broadcasting of known quantum information using optimal quantum resource

Satish Kumar, Anirban PathakQuantum Inf. Process 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper clarifies that "quantum broadcasting" of known quantum states is fundamentally a form of multiparty remote state preparation, distinct from the no-cloning theorem's implications for unknown states. The authors propose and experimentally demonstrate an optimal, resource-efficient scheme for broadcasting known quantum information to multiple receivers, showing it's more robust to noise than previous methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "no-quantum broadcasting theorem" states that it's impossible to broadcast arbitrary, unknown quantum states to multiple users. This is a weaker version of the no-cloning theorem. However, the paper highlights a common misconception: if the sender knows the quantum state they want to broadcast, the problem changes significantly. It becomes a task of multiparty remote state preparation (RSP). The authors point out that several recent works, while technically correct in their implementations, have mislabeled their protocols as "quantum broadcasting" without clearly specifying that the state was known, potentially causing confusion with the no-broadcasting theorem. This paper aims to rectify this by clearly defining the scope of broadcasting known states, proposing optimal resource utilization, and exploring its various facets.

Methods

The core of the paper involves:

  • Relating Broadcasting to RSP: Establishing that broadcasting a known quantum state is equivalent to multiparty remote state preparation.
  • Optimal Resource Design: Proposing a generalized scheme for broadcasting known quantum information to multiple users using optimal quantum resources. This involves using entangled states, specifically focusing on qubit-based implementations for practicality.
  • Noise Analysis: Investigating the effect of various noise models (bit-flip, phase-flip, amplitude damping, depolarizing) on the proposed schemes and comparing the robustness of different quantum channels (Bell states vs. cluster states).
  • Generalizations: Exploring various extensions of the broadcasting concept, including joint broadcasting (where multiple senders contribute incomplete information) and controlled broadcasting (where a controller determines who receives the information).
  • Experimental Realization: Implementing a proof-of-principle demonstration of the proposed optimal scheme using an IBM quantum computer.

The paper emphasizes using two-qubit entangled states (Bell states) as the optimal and most robust resource for these tasks, contrasting with schemes that might require more complex multipartite entangled states or higher-dimensional qudits.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical proposals and experimental realization on a quantum computer, not on training or evaluating against pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Known vs. Unknown States: The critical distinction between broadcasting unknown (impossible) and known (possible, via RSP) quantum states is clearly articulated, resolving potential confusion in the literature.
  • Optimality with Bell States: The paper demonstrates that broadcasting known quantum information to multiple receivers can be achieved optimally using pairs of Bell states, which are simpler and more robust to noise than the four-qubit cluster states used in some prior work.
  • RSP as the Underlying Mechanism: The paper firmly grounds quantum broadcasting of known states in the established framework of remote state preparation, providing a clearer theoretical foundation.
  • Noise Robustness: The analysis reveals that using Bell states as quantum channels for broadcasting is superior to using cluster states when subjected to common noise types.
  • Generalizability: The proposed framework is shown to be generalizable to various scenarios, including joint and controlled broadcasting, and can be implemented with readily available resources like Bell states.

Key Results

  • Optimal Scheme Proposed: A generalized scheme for broadcasting known quantum information to multiple receivers using optimal quantum resources (specifically, Bell states) is presented.
  • Noise Comparison: The study shows that using pairs of Bell states for broadcasting is more robust against bit-flip, depolarizing, amplitude damping, and phase damping noise compared to using a four-qubit cluster state.
  • Experimental Validation: A proof-of-principle implementation of the proposed optimal scheme was successfully executed on an IBM quantum computer (ibmq_manila).
  • Fidelity Metrics: The experimental results showed average fidelities of 86.47% for the cluster state scheme and 58.27% for the two-Bell-state scheme in the ideal scenario (simulated). The experimental results on ibmq_manila showed slightly different values due to inherent errors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Qubits: The paper primarily restricts its discussion and experimental realization to qubit-based systems, acknowledging that higher-dimensional states (qudits) could offer advantages but are harder to realize experimentally.
  • "Weaker" Broadcasting Not Explored: The authors mention that scenarios with partial overlap in output systems, leading to "quantum shared broadcasting," are not explored but are a promising avenue for future work.
  • Generalization Complexity: While generalizations to n senders and m receivers are discussed, the paper notes that for n senders, the required entangled states can become complex and difficult to produce.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest extending the study to explore weaker notions of quantum broadcasting and to investigate more complex scenarios like multi-directional and controlled broadcasting in greater detail. They also highlight potential applications in quantum voting, authentication, cryptography, and measurement-based quantum computing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The no-quantum broadcasting theorem which is a weaker version of the nocloning theorem restricts us from broadcasting completely unknown quantum information to multiple users. However, if the sender is aware of the quantum information (state) to be broadcasted, then the above restriction disappears and the task reduces to a multiparty remote state preparation. Without recognizing this fact, several schemes for broadcasting of known quantum states have been proposed in the recent past and erroneously/misleadingly referred to as protocols for quantum broadcasting (e.g., Yu et al. in Quant Inf Process 16(2):41, 2017 presented a technically correct scheme for multiparty remote state preparation which can at best be referred to as broadcasting of known quantum states, but referred to it as a scheme for quantum broadcasting). Here, we elaborate on the relation between the protocols of remote state preparation and those of broadcasting of known quantum information and show that it is possible to broadcast known quantum information to multiple receivers in deterministic as well as probabilistic manner with optimal resources. Further, the effect of noise on such schemes, and some new facets (like joint broadcasting) of such schemes have been discussed. A proof of principle realization of the proposed optimal scheme using an IBM quantum computer is also reported. Possibilities of generalizations of the so-called broadcasting schemes and potential applications are also discussed with appropriate importance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kumar2024many,
  author = {Satish Kumar and Anirban Pathak},
  title = {{Many facets of multiparty broadcasting of known quantum information using optimal quantum resource}},
  booktitle = {Quantum Inf. Process},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=EyDGpnYMB5},
}
Figure