Abstract
Quantifying the impact of natural heatwaves on crop productivity requires direct comparison with a no-heatwave control. Yet conventional growth chambers, which rely on artificial lighting and stepwise heating–cooling programs, fail to capture natural sunlight and temperature variability, often leading to biased estimates of heatwave effects. Field-based experiments, on the other hand, provide realistic growing conditions but lack precise temperature control, especially air cooling, making it technically and economically infeasible to establish no-heatwave controls when extreme events occur. Heatwaves are increasingly unavoidable in rice-growing regions, but localized air cooling, under natural sunlight, on a small scale, is technically feasible. To address this gap, AmbControl was developed, a sunlit field chamber system designed to manipulate air temperature without altering natural light dynamics. The results showed that AmbControl successfully replicated the dynamics of natural heatwaves recorded in 2021 and 2022, enabling precise control of air temperature from +1.5 to −4 °C relative to ambient, as well as maintaining a fixed 28.9 °C treatment. Under +1.5 °C warming, daytime and nighttime temperatures were maintained within Δ1.8 °C and Δ1.0 °C of target values, respectively. Relative humidity and vapor pressure deficit co-varied with temperature treatments, highlighting RH as a potential confounding factor in warming studies. By combining environmental precision with field realism, AmbControl offers a versatile, field-relevant platform for directly quantifying plant–soil responses to extreme heat, with the objective of generating field-validated data that can be integrated into crop and climate models, to improve projections of crop resilience under future climate scenarios.
Introduction
As climate change increases the frequency and intensity of heatwaves, understanding their impact on crop yields—particularly rice—is critical for global food security. However, researchers currently face a significant "realism vs. control" trade-off. Indoor growth chambers offer high precision but rely on artificial lighting and "stepwise" temperature programs that fail to mimic the dynamic variability of natural sunlight and weather. Conversely, field-based experiments like Temperature Free-Air Controlled Enhancement (T-FACE) provide realistic conditions but generally lack cooling capacity.
This lack of cooling makes it nearly impossible to establish a true "no-heatwave" control during an actual extreme weather event; if a heatwave hits the field, every plant experiences it. The AmbControl system was developed to bridge this gap by "subtracting" heat from the field environment, enabling direct comparisons between heat-stressed and "normalized" plants under identical natural light conditions.
System Design and Methodology
The AmbControl system consists of six sunlit chambers (approximately 2.9 m³ each) constructed using double-layered transparent glass. The system’s core innovation lies in its bidirectional climate control hardware and logic.
Each unit features an 1,875 W air-conditioning unit for cooling and two 500 W hot-air fans for heating. The system employs an incremental Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) algorithm that continuously compares the target setpoint (e.g., ambient temperature or a fixed value) with the actual chamber temperature, adjusting the output of the AC or fans every minute to minimize error. Unlike fully enclosed chambers, these units are semi-open with airflow directed above the canopy to induce natural leaf movement and heat dispersion. They are also mounted on wheels, allowing for positional randomization in the field to minimize location bias.
Performance and Experimental Validation
The system was validated over two full rice-growing seasons (April to November in 2021 and 2022) in Suzhou, China. Researchers logged air temperature (TA), relative humidity (RH), and photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) at 1-minute intervals. Performance was evaluated against 30-year historical temperature averages (1961–1990) to define "abnormal" heat events.
Key results from the validation period include:
- Precision: The PID controller maintained internal temperatures within ±0.3 °C of the setpoint.
- Versatility: The system successfully replicated natural heatwave dynamics while supporting multiple scenarios: +1.5 °C (future warming), +0 °C (ambient control), and -4 °C (heatwave mitigation).
- Extreme Event Capture: During the record-breaking 2022 East Asian heatwave, the system successfully tracked ambient temperatures that exceeded 40 °C for 27 days, while simultaneously maintaining stable "non-stress" treatments.
- Light Realism: PPFD levels reached up to 2,323 µmol·m⁻²·s⁻¹, providing the full spectrum and intensity of natural sunlight that artificial LEDs struggle to replicate.
Discussion and Future Directions
The most significant advantage of AmbControl is the ability to maintain a chamber at -4 °C relative to ambient. This allows researchers to "cancel out" a natural heatwave, providing a true baseline to measure exactly how much damage the heat event caused compared to a "normal" year.
However, the study also highlights that manipulating temperature inherently shifts RH and Vapor Pressure Deficit (VPD). Because VPD affects how plants transpire and "breathe," these co-variations must be carefully accounted for in warming studies to avoid attributing all plant responses solely to heat. Additionally, the results showed a minor daytime cooling lag under intense solar radiation and a slight nighttime over-cooling due to radiative loss through the glass, identifying a specific engineering challenge in balancing transparency with insulation.
Future iterations of AmbControl are expected to include active humidity control modules to study the interaction between heat and atmospheric drought. Furthermore, adapting the units for in-situ installations directly over field soil would allow for unrestricted rooting, better capturing complex root-soil-microbe interactions.
Summary updated