Managing Identities via Interactions between Ontologies

Paolo CeravoloOtm Workshops 2003 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes an ontology-based approach to managing digital identities, enabling users to control the disclosure of their personal information across different online services. By leveraging ontologies, the system can represent complex user attributes and relationships, facilitating more granular and privacy-preserving identity management than existing centralized solutions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The proliferation of e-business services has led to increased user profiling, raising significant privacy concerns. While some solutions aim to give users control over their data, they often struggle with the complexity of representing user information and preventing unauthorized data sharing. Existing systems lack a rich representation of user interests and relationships, making it difficult to manage multiple identities effectively and disclose only the necessary information for each transaction. This paper addresses the challenge of creating a flexible and user-centric identity management system that can handle complex user attributes and ensure privacy.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in using ontologies as the foundational layer for identity management. Specifically, the authors advocate for the use of OWL (Web Ontology Language) to define personal identity ontologies. These ontologies model user attributes, credentials, and relationships in a structured and semantically rich way.

The system operates by:

  1. User Ontologies: Defining personal ontologies that represent various aspects of a user's identity, including attributes like name, address, and credentials.
  2. Credential Ontologies: Linking personal identity concepts to external "Credentials" ontologies, which specify the types of credentials needed to certify specific attributes.
  3. Provider Ontologies: Optionally linking to "Providers" ontologies to specify which authorities can issue these credentials.
  4. Bindings to SAML: Developing mechanisms to bind these ontology-based metadata representations to XML-based standards like SAML (Security Assertion Markup Language). This involves mapping ontology concepts to SAML assertions, allowing the identity management system to generate appropriate credentials for service requests.
  5. Usage Scenario: Illustrating a scenario where a client requests access to a remote service. Instead of sending all available information, the client's identity management system (acting as an "Authority") consults the personal ontology to determine the "right" amount of information to disclose, which is then sent to the server.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the conceptual framework and the use of ontologies, rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ontologies for Rich Identity Representation: The paper highlights the power of ontologies in moving beyond simple user profiles to model complex user interests, relationships, and nuanced identity aspects. This allows for a more sophisticated understanding of user data.
  • User-Centric Control: By placing ontologies at the core, the system empowers users to define and manage their digital identities, deciding what information is shared and with whom, thereby enhancing privacy.
  • Bridging Semantic Web and Identity Standards: The work demonstrates a practical approach to integrating semantic web technologies (ontologies) with established identity standards (SAML), creating a more robust and interoperable identity management ecosystem.
  • "Right Amount" of Information: The concept of disclosing only the "right" amount of information for a given transaction, rather than all available data, is a crucial insight for privacy preservation. Ontologies facilitate this by allowing for granular specification of required attributes.

Key Results

The paper presents a conceptual framework and demonstrates its application through examples and figures. It outlines the structure of personal identity ontologies, credential ontologies, and shows how these can be bound to SAML for service interactions. The key "result" is the proposed methodology for ontology-based identity management and the illustration of its potential for privacy-preserving interactions. Specific quantitative results are not presented as this is a foundational paper.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Efficient Binding Computation: The authors acknowledge that efficient computation of bindings between ontology metadata and SAML is a significant challenge. While they propose a graph transformation approach, they note that the efficiency of the cooperative computation of content is an open issue.
  • Fuzzy Structure Matching: Future work includes investigating the application of fuzzy structure matching for inducing identity ontology organization from SAML sample data, suggesting a direction for automated ontology creation.
  • Implementation Friendliness: The paper briefly mentions that a fully decoupled approach for SAML metadata might be more implementation-friendly, hinting at potential architectural refinements.
  • Content Synthesis: The paper notes that while ontologies might provide a nickname, suitable content for identity control (e.g., proof of consensus for payments) might need to be synthesized, potentially through delegation to auxiliary authorities.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{ceravolo2003managing,
  author = {Paolo Ceravolo},
  title = {{Managing Identities via Interactions between Ontologies}},
  booktitle = {Otm Workshops},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-540-39962-9\_74},
}

Loading related content...

Figure