Managing food quality experience through digital channels

Lennart Schneider, Anna Müller, Felix Bauer, Kurt Vogel, Jonas Weber, M. HoffmannInternational Journal of Research in Management 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Digital channels now mediate how consumers form, test, and update their food quality experience across the full journey. This study integrates platform/social cues (reviews and ratings), visual-sensory cues (image-based signals of freshness/temperature/crispness), and assurance/traceability cues (interactive QR/2D codes exposing batch, expiry, and origin) into a single pathway connecting expectations to perceived food quality, satisfaction, trust, and behaviour. Using a 12-month, multi-source panel (28,412 users; 184,221 orders; 416 brands; 5,132 SKUs), we combine platform telemetry, review text and images, QR usage logs, delivery operations, and two-stage surveys. A covariance-based SEM, supplemented by staggered-adoption difference-in-differences, moderation tests, and A/B experiments, evaluates the proposed relationships. Measurement showed strong reliability and global fit. Platform/social cues raised perceived diagnosticity (β=0.41), visual congruence increased expectation strength (β=0.29), and assurance utilisation increased trust (β=0.33). Expectations predicted perceived food quality (β=0.42), which most strongly drove satisfaction (β=0.58); satisfaction (β=0.47) and trust (β=0.31) increased repurchase intention and willingness-to-pay. Mediation confirmed that reviews act mainly via diagnosticity → expectations, while assurance acts via trust. Moderation indicated steeper review effects for low-equity brands and stronger assurance payoffs under reliable last-mile delivery. Event-study estimates showed a sustained trust lift of ~+1.8 to +2.7 percentage points within three months of QR adoption. In A/B tests, assurance badges increased willingness-to-pay by +2.8%, repurchase by +1.9 percentage points, and basket share by +1.2 points. Out-of-sample predictivity improved from AUC=0.71 (baseline) to 0.79 in the full model. Managerially, governing diagnostic reviews, enforcing category-diagnostic imagery, and making assurance scannable—and then delivering on time and intact—jointly elevate perceived quality, satisfaction, and repeat patronage. The findings position “assurance quality” as a distinct, actionable layer alongside information, system, and service quality in digital food experiences.

Introduction

In the modern "platform economy," digital channels are no longer just ordering tools; they are the primary environment where food quality expectations are set. Consumers are bombarded with noisy signals, from star ratings to professional photography. However, practitioners often manage these elements in silos—marketing handles photos, operations handles traceability, and customer service handles reviews. This research addresses the lack of an integrated framework that explains how these disparate digital cues interact to form a cohesive food quality experience before the first bite is taken.

Methodology and Data

The study utilized a comprehensive 12-month panel dataset from a large food-ordering platform, encompassing 28,412 unique users and over 184,000 orders across 416 brands. To analyze this data, the researchers employed a multi-method approach:

  • Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): Used to map the psychological pathways from digital cues to behavioral outcomes.
  • Causal Identification: Staggered-adoption difference-in-differences (DiD) measured the impact of QR code adoption, while A/B experiments tested the effect of assurance badges.
  • Advanced Analytics: Natural Language Processing (NLP) extracted sentiment from reviews, while Computer Vision algorithms calculated a "visual congruence index" to measure how well product photos matched sensory expectations (e.g., the visual "heat" of a soup).

Key Results

The analysis revealed that digital signals actively scaffold consumer expectations and trust. Perceived food quality emerged as the strongest driver of satisfaction (β=0.58), which subsequently drove repurchase intention (β=0.47).

Path coefficients from the structural equation model showing the strength of relationships between digital cues and consumer outcomes.

Beyond simple correlations, the causal analysis demonstrated that the introduction of assurance/traceability features (QR codes) led to a significant and sustained increase in consumer trust. Within three months of adoption, trust lifted by 1.8 to 2.7 percentage points.

Event-study estimates showing the sustained lift in consumer trust following the adoption of QR-based assurance cues.

Discussion and Managerial Implications

The findings introduce "assurance quality" as a new, actionable layer of the digital experience. Unlike standard system or service quality, assurance quality relies on scannable, verifiable data to reduce uncertainty.

Key takeaways for managers include:

  1. Diagnosticity Matters: Reviews work by helping consumers form accurate expectations. High-quality, diagnostic reviews reduce the post-consumption "expectation-performance gap."
  2. Visual Anchoring: Category-congruent imagery (e.g., showing steam for hot food) acts as a sensory scaffold that lifts expectations.
  3. The Last-Mile Synergy: Transparency only pays off when delivery is reliable. If food arrives cold, the trust built by digital assurance cues evaporates.
  4. Brand Buffering: Social proof is significantly more critical for low-equity brands, whereas high-equity brands benefit from an established trust buffer.

By governing diagnostic reviews, enforcing category-diagnostic imagery, and making assurance scannable, firms can significantly elevate perceived quality and repeat patronage.

Summary updated

Abstract

Digital channels now mediate how consumers form, test, and update their food quality experience across the full journey. This study integrates platform/social cues (reviews and ratings), visual-sensory cues (image-based signals of freshness/temperature/crispness), and assurance/traceability cues (interactive QR/2D codes exposing batch, expiry, and origin) into a single pathway connecting expectations to perceived food quality, satisfaction, trust, and behaviour. Using a 12-month, multi-source panel (28, 412 users; 184, 221 orders; 416 brands; 5, 132 SKUs), we combine platform telemetry, review text and images, QR usage logs, delivery operations, and two-stage surveys. A covariance-based SEM, supplemented by staggered-adoption difference-in-differences, moderation tests, and A/B experiments, evaluates the proposed relationships. Measurement showed strong reliability and global fit. Platform/social cues raised perceived diagnosticity (β=0.41), visual congruence increased expectation strength (β=0.29), and assurance utilisation increased trust (β=0.33). Expectations predicted perceived food quality (β=0.42), which most strongly drove satisfaction (β=0.58); satisfaction (β=0.47) and trust (β=0.31) increased repurchase intention and willingness-to-pay. Mediation confirmed that reviews act mainly via diagnosticity → expectations, while assurance acts via trust. Moderation indicated steeper review effects for low-equity brands and stronger assurance payoffs under reliable last-mile delivery. Event-study estimates showed a sustained trust lift of ~+1.8 to +2.7 percentage points within three months of QR adoption. In A/B tests, assurance badges increased willingness-to-pay by +2.8%, repurchase by +1.9 percentage points, and basket share by +1.2 points. Out-of-sample predictivity improved from AUC=0.71 (baseline) to 0.79 in the full model. Managerially, governing diagnostic reviews, enforcing category-diagnostic imagery, and making assurance scannable—and then delivering on time and intact—jointly elevate perceived quality, satisfaction, and repeat patronage. The findings position “assurance quality” as a distinct, actionable layer alongside information, system, and service quality in digital food experiences.
BibTeX
@article{schneider2025managing,
  author = {Lennart Schneider and Anna Müller and Felix Bauer and Kurt Vogel and Jonas Weber and M. Hoffmann},
  title = {{Managing food quality experience through digital channels}},
  journal = {International Journal of Research in Management},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.33545/26648792.2025.v7.i1m.476},
}
Figure