Management of Rigid Post-poliomyelitis Equinocavovarus Deformities: A Brief Review

Rajiv Ratn Shah, Shivam R Shah, Siddharth SharmaJournal of Foot and Ankle Surgery (Asia Pacific) 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This review outlines a comprehensive surgical roadmap for correcting equinocavovarus—the most common and complex foot deformity in post-polio patients. By combining meticulous muscle-power charting, 3D-printed modeling, and a strict "proximal-to-distal" surgical sequence, surgeons can transform rigid, painful deformities into stable, functional feet.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While polio has been largely eradicated in the developed world, millions of survivors in developing nations suffer from Post-Polio Residual Paralysis (PPRP). The hallmark of PPRP is muscle imbalance: when certain muscles weaken while others remain strong, they "tug" the foot into distorted positions.

The most challenging of these is equinocavovarus, a three-dimensional deformity involving a downward-pointing ankle (equinus), an abnormally high arch (cavus), and an inward-tilted heel (varus). If left untreated, these "supple" imbalances become "rigid" over decades. Patients end up walking on the outer edges of their feet, leading to agonizing corns, stress fractures, and secondary pain in the knees and back. This paper provides a clinical framework for surgeons to tackle these neglected, rigid cases.

Methods

The paper synthesizes established orthopedic practices with modern diagnostic tools. Rather than proposing a single new "algorithm," it advocates for a staged surgical strategy:

  1. Preoperative Planning: Beyond standard X-rays, the authors highlight the use of 3D-printed bone models created from CT scans. This allows surgeons to perform a "surgical rehearsal," physically handling the model to plan precise bone cuts (osteotomies).
  2. Muscle Power Charting: A vital step where every muscle's strength is mapped (Fig 2). This dictates which tendons are available for transfer to "rebalance" the foot's internal tug-of-war.
  3. The Surgical Sequence: The authors emphasize a strict order of operations:
  4. Direction: Always proceed from proximal (the heel/ankle) to distal (the toes).
  5. Tissue Type: Soft tissue releases (tendons/ligaments) must precede bony corrections (cutting or fusing bone).
  6. Specific Techniques: Includes Z-plasty for Achilles lengthening, Dwyer osteotomies for heel alignment, and the Jones procedure for correcting claw toes.

Datasets

As a clinical review, this paper does not utilize a computational dataset. Instead, it draws upon:

  • Clinical Case Studies: Visualized through photographs and 3D models of patients with bilateral equinocavovarus.
  • Literature Review: A synthesis of 24 foundational and recent sources in orthopedic surgery, ranging from classic 1923 studies on ankle fusion to 2011 papers on the Ilizarov external fixation method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Compensation Trap: A crucial "aha" moment for clinicians is realizing that a foot deformity might be helping the patient. For example, a downward-pointing foot (equinus) might be compensating for a weak knee. Correcting the foot without addressing the knee could actually make the patient's gait worse (the "hand-to-knee" gait).
  • Stepwise Bone Resection: When performing wedge osteotomies (removing a triangle of bone to straighten a curve), the authors advise removing smaller wedges than initially planned. It is easy to remove more bone later, but impossible to put it back if you over-correct.
  • Tendon Transfers as "Internal Braces": Even if bones are fused into the correct position (arthrodesis), the foot will fail again if the underlying muscle imbalance isn't addressed. Tendon transfers are essential to "balance the scales" and prevent recurrence.

Key Results

The paper defines success not just by "straightening" the foot, but by achieving a plantigrade position—where the sole of the foot is flat on the ground and capable of painless weight-bearing.

Qualitative results from the review suggest that:

  • Rigid vs. Supple: While orthotics work for children with flexible feet, long-standing rigid deformities in adults require surgical intervention to prevent total loss of mobility.
  • 3D Rehearsal: The use of 3D-printed models significantly reduces "unforeseen circumstances" during complex multi-planar corrections.
  • Stability: By following the "hindfoot-first" sequence, surgeons can create a stable base before fine-tuning the forefoot and toes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles:

  • Technical Demand: These surgeries are "technically demanding" and require high-level expertise in both soft tissue and bone surgery.
  • Complications: Risks include skin closure issues (due to the skin being stretched over the new foot shape), nerve injury, and non-union of fused bones.
  • Patient Compliance: Post-operative care involves six weeks in a cast followed by intensive physical therapy; non-compliant patients are poor candidates for these procedures.

Future Work: While not explicitly detailed, the trend toward 3D printing suggests a future where patient-specific cutting guides and custom-modeled implants could further refine these complex reconstructions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Foot and ankle deformities are frequent in patients with post-polio residual paralysis (PPRP), and can be attributed to abnormal muscle balance, abnormal posture, gravitation forces, and continued walking over the deformed foot. Equinocavovarus is the most common foot and ankle deformity in PPRP patients. Late presenting or neglected deformities can lead to gait abnormalities, abnormal pressure areas, increased energy expenditure, and arthritis of foot joints. Management of post-poliomyelitis equinocavovarus requires an in-depth understanding of the pathoanatomy as well as the interplay of muscle dynamics.
BibTeX
@article{shah2022management,
  author = {Rajiv Ratn Shah and Shivam R Shah and Siddharth Sharma},
  title = {{Management of Rigid Post-poliomyelitis Equinocavovarus Deformities: A Brief Review}},
  journal = {Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery (Asia Pacific)},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5005/jp-journals-10040-1173},
}
Figure