Management of COVID‐19 patients in Fangcang shelter hospital: clinical practice and effectiveness analysis

Pei Liu, Hongmei Zhang, Xiang Long, Wei Wang, Danting Zhan, Xinke Meng, Duoyun Li, Lingling Wang, Rongchang ChenThe Clinical Respiratory Journal 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the operational model and effectiveness of a Fangcang shelter hospital in Wuhan during the COVID-19 pandemic. It highlights how a structured management protocol and the use of WeChat enabled efficient care for a large number of mild-to-moderate COVID-19 patients with limited medical staff, proving to be a safe and effective strategy for isolation and basic medical management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic's rapid spread in Wuhan created an overwhelming demand for hospital beds, leading to a critical shortage for mild and moderate cases. Traditional hospitals were unable to cope, necessitating the rapid establishment of temporary "Fangcang shelter hospitals." These facilities, while providing much-needed capacity, faced challenges due to limited medical staff, basic infrastructure, and the need for efficient patient management and infection control. This paper addresses how to effectively manage a large cohort of COVID-19 patients in such a resource-constrained environment.

Methods

The study describes the clinical practice and effectiveness of the Wuhan Dongxihu Fangcang shelter Hospital. Key methodological aspects include:

  • Structured Patient Management Protocols: A comprehensive package was developed, covering admission criteria (mild-to-moderate cases, self-care ability, no severe organ dysfunction or mental illness, specific SpO2 and RR thresholds), evaluation and treatment (vital signs, chest CT, PCR testing, antiviral, antimicrobial, and symptomatic treatments), discharge criteria (normal temperature, symptom alleviation, improving CT, negative PCR, adequate SpO2, >14 days), and referral criteria for designated hospitals (respiratory distress, low SpO2, shock, organ failure, significant CT progression, elderly with comorbidities).
  • WeChat-based Communication and Management: The WeChat platform was extensively utilized for communication between doctors and patients, ward rounds (virtual), test appointments, and patient data sharing. Different WeChat groups were established for various functions, including patient information reporting, communication with headquarters, and coordination of referrals and discharges.
  • Shift-Based Medical Staffing: Doctors worked in rotating shifts, with a specific number of doctors on duty inside the ward room at all times and others managing patients remotely via WeChat.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the operational data and outcomes from a single Fangcang shelter hospital.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scalability of Shelter Hospitals: Fangcang hospitals, when managed with clear protocols and technology, can effectively scale to accommodate large numbers of patients during public health emergencies.
  • WeChat as a Critical Tool: The widespread adoption of WeChat proved instrumental in overcoming communication barriers, enabling remote patient monitoring, reducing face-to-face contact (and thus infection risk for staff), and managing workload efficiently.
  • Protocol-Driven Efficiency: A standardized management protocol package was crucial for ensuring consistent care, efficient decision-making (admission, discharge, referral), and reducing the burden on medical staff.
  • Effective Isolation and Basic Care: These facilities successfully served their primary purpose of isolating patients and preventing further transmission, while also providing essential medical care and early identification of deteriorating cases.
  • Low Mortality and Morbidity for Staff: The model demonstrated effectiveness in preventing deaths within the shelter and, importantly, achieved zero medical staff infections and no medical accidents.

Key Results

  • Patient Management: 442 mild or moderate COVID-19 patients were managed in Hall C.
  • Outcomes:
    • 246 patients (56%) were cured and discharged.
  • 196 patients (44%) were referred to designated hospitals.
  • Reasons for Referral: The primary reasons for referral were:
  • Poor resolution in CT image (59%)
    • Persistently positive PCR for SARS-CoV-2 (16%)
    • Unclear reasons (16%)
    • Deterioration in CT image (4%)
    • Other reasons (4%)
    • Development of dyspnea (1%)
  • Safety: There were no deaths among patients in Hall C, and no medical staff infections or accidents were reported.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unclear Referral Reasons: In 16% of referral cases, the specific reasons were not documented, hindering a complete analysis.
  • Lack of Final Outcome Tracking: The study could not trace the final outcomes of patients transferred to designated hospitals.
  • Limited Infrastructure: The reliance on WeChat was due to the absence of integrated hospital information systems, laboratory information systems, and picture archiving and communication systems.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that leveraging advanced technologies like 5G for remote operation systems could further improve the management of infectious disease pandemics, enabling more comprehensive remote medical observation and documentation. They also note that this was a retrospective analysis, implying prospective studies could offer deeper insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fangcang shelter (Cabin) hospitals were set up in order to cope with the rapid growth of confirmed cases of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Wuhan, China at a time when there were insufficient beds in designated hospitals. This paper describes the layout and functioning of a typical Fangcang shelter hospital, Wuhan Dongxihu Fangcang shelter Hospital, where the author has worked, the working mechanism, experience and effectiveness. A set of patient management protocols was employed for daily practice, which included preset criteria and procedure for admission, examination, medication treatment, referral and discharge. WeChat platform with different groups was used for communication, ward round, test appointments and patient data communication. All these procedures and mechanisms of working enabled the effective management of a larger number of patients with relatively few doctors. As a result, 442 mild or moderate COVID-19 patients in Hall C were successfully managed by a team of 40 doctors, with 246 (56%) patients were cured and discharged from the Fangcang shelter hospital while the remaining 196 (44%) patients were referred on to designated hospitals for further treatment. The reasons for referral included poor resolution in computerized tomography (CT) scan (59%), persistently positive severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 by PCR after 9 days of admission (16%), deterioration in CT image (4%), development of dyspnoea (1%) and other (4%) or unclear reasons (16%) due to no record of reasons for referral on the document. There were no deaths and no complaints from the patients in Hall C. In summary, the Fangcang shelter hospital could be run successfully with a set of patient management protocols under conditions of limited facilities and medical staff. It was effective and safe in isolating patients, providing basic medical care and early identification of potential severe cases. This experience may provide a successful example of a working mechanism for the prevention and control of the COVID-19 pandemic worldwide.
BibTeX
@article{liu2020management,
  author = {Pei Liu and Hongmei Zhang and Xiang Long and Wei Wang and Danting Zhan and Xinke Meng and Duoyun Li and Lingling Wang and Rongchang Chen},
  title = {{Management of COVID‐19 patients in Fangcang shelter hospital: clinical practice and effectiveness analysis}},
  journal = {The Clinical Respiratory Journal},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1111/crj.13293},
}
Figure